Explainer
Should canning seal be heated before canning?
No. Modern two-piece canning lids are used as they come out of the box, and the makers of the canners compared here publish no instruction to heat the lid or the band before processing.
By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared
No. A modern two-piece canning lid, the flat disc plus the screw band, is used as it comes out of the box, and none of the canner makers compared on this site publishes a step that calls for heating the lid or the band before jars go into the canner. What the makers do publish is how their canners build and hold pressure, and that is the part of the process their instructions cover.
The old practice of simmering flat lids in a saucepan belongs to an earlier generation of lid with a different sealing compound. If you are working from a family recipe card that says to heat the lids, the safer move is to follow the lid maker’s current package directions and the canner maker’s published operating steps, not the card.
What the canner makers actually publish
The Best Pressure Canners for Large-Batch Home Canning guide compares five stovetop canners, and their published features describe the vessel, the gauge and the safety hardware, not a lid-heating step. The Presto 01784 23-Quart Induction Compatible Pressure Canner, for example, is described with an air vent and cover lock that lets pressure build only when the cover is properly closed and prevents opening until pressure is safely reduced. That is a statement about the canner’s own lid, not about jar lids.
The All American 921 is listed with a metal-to-metal sealing system that forms a steam-tight seal without gaskets, plus an easy-to-read steam gauge and a precision machined regulator weight. Again, the published detail is about how the canner cover seals and how pressure is controlled. Nothing in the maker’s bullets describes preparing jar seals with heat.
This site has not compared jar lid manufacturers, so it publishes no figures or instructions from them. The absence here is precise: the canner makers’ published features do not include a lid-heating step, and this site has not reviewed lid packaging.
Electric canners and the seal question
The Best Electric Canners for Pressure and Water Bath Preserving guide covers five appliances, and their published features focus on automated pressure and temperature control. The NESCO NPC-9 is described with a safety lock lid, an automatic float valve and a pressure regulation system that prevent opening under pressure. The Presto 02144 12-Quart Digital Pressure Canner is described with ten built-in safety features, including a cover-locking system and a sensor that holds the correct temperature.
Those features matter to the seal question in one way: an electric canner that regulates its own pressure and temperature removes the guesswork that older stovetop routines tried to solve with extra steps. The maker’s published description of the Presto 02144 states that no adjustments are needed for high altitudes, which is a claim about the appliance’s program, not about jar lids.
What none of these five listings publishes is a preparation step for the flat lid or the band. If a manual that ships with an appliance adds one, that manual governs. This site has not read those manuals and does not claim to.
Water bath picks and jar handling
Two picks in the electric guide are water bath canners rather than pressure appliances. The WantJoin Water Bath Canner is listed at 33 quarts with an adjustable temperature range of 86 to 212 degrees Fahrenheit and a timer range of 30 to 180 minutes, and the maker states it holds up to 11 one-quart jars. The McSunley Prep N Cook is listed at 21.5 quarts with a jar rack that holds 7 one-quart, 9 one-pint or 12 half-pint jars.
Those figures describe capacity and control, and the McSunley listing adds that its rack keeps jars off the bottom for full water circulation. Jar handling is covered. Lid heating is not mentioned in either maker’s published features.
A water bath canner holds water at a set temperature, and the WantJoin listing publishes that range in Fahrenheit. That is the extent of what the maker states about heat in the vessel. It says nothing about what you do with the lid before the jar goes in.
Pressure hardware and why the seal matters
On the pressure side, the published safety hardware is about the canner cover, and it is worth understanding because it is often confused with jar sealing. The RVGMBO 12 Quart lists a secure-lock lid, a safety valve, a lid window and a pressure release valve, with settings from 10 PSI at low to 15 PSI at high. The Siftary 24 QT lists a gauge calibrated to 14.5 PSI and dual over-pressure relief valves.
Those are figures for the canner’s own pressure regulation. They tell you the appliance or vessel is built to hold a set pressure and to release it safely. They do not describe the jar lid, which seals against the jar rim through the heat of processing and the cooling that follows.
The Hestroney 10.57 Quart listing describes a six-tier safety protection system with pressure release valves, safety valves and self-locking valves. The VEVOR 10 Quart listing describes three pressure settings at 60 kPa and 100 kPa. Note that the VEVOR figure is published in kPa, and this site reports it as the maker states it. None of these listings addresses jar lid preparation.
The order of steps the makers describe
Read together, the published features describe a sequence built around the canner: close the cover properly, let pressure build, hold it for the processing time, then let pressure drop before opening. The Presto 01784 listing states that its air vent and cover lock prevent opening until pressure is safely reduced. The NESCO listing states that its safety lock lid and float valve prevent opening under pressure.
Jars go into the canner with lids and bands in place, and the processing cycle does the rest. That is the process the makers describe. A separate heating step for the flat lid does not appear in any of the ten listings compared across the two guides.
If you are canning for the first time, follow the lid package for lid handling and the canner manual for the vessel. Where the two disagree with an old recipe, the current package and manual win. This site reports what makers publish and does not test appliances, so treat the manual as the authority for your specific unit.
Common questions
Do I need to boil flat lids before using them?
The canner makers compared on this site publish no boiling step for jar lids, and this site has not compared lid manufacturers, so it publishes no lid package instructions. Follow the directions printed on the lid package you bought. Old recipes that call for simmering lids were written for an earlier lid design and should not be assumed to apply to current lids.
Does an electric canner change how I prepare lids?
The electric canners compared here publish features about automated pressure and temperature control, such as the Presto 02144 sensor that holds the correct temperature and the NESCO float valve that prevents opening under pressure. Those describe the appliance, not the jar lid. This site has not read the manuals that ship with these appliances, so check yours for any lid handling step.
What does the cover lock on a pressure canner do?
The Presto 01784 listing states that its air vent and cover lock let pressure build only when the cover is properly closed and prevent opening until pressure is safely reduced. The NESCO NPC-9 listing describes a safety lock lid and automatic float valve with the same purpose. Both are about the canner cover, not the jar lid.
How many jars do these canners hold?
Published capacities vary. The Presto 01784 listing states space for 7 quarts, 20 pints or 26 half-pints of regular Mason jars. The All American 921 listing states about 19 pint jars or 7 quart jars. The McSunley rack holds 7 one-quart, 9 one-pint or 12 half-pint jars, and the WantJoin holds up to 11 one-quart jars.
Does altitude affect whether I heat the seal?
Altitude affects processing pressure and time, not lid preparation. The Presto 02144 listing states that no adjustments are needed for high altitudes, which is a claim about that appliance's program. The Siftary listing describes its 14.5 PSI gauge as suited to high-altitude canning. Neither listing mentions heating the lid at any altitude.
Ready to compare actual models?
Our buying guides put five products side by side on the numbers their makers publish.