Lush Food & Drink

Explainer

How do electric smokers produce smoke?

An electric element heats a small tray of wood chips until they smolder, not burn, and that slow smoldering is what makes smoke. The element cooks; the wood is the only smoke source.

By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared

An electric smoker makes smoke by using its heating element to warm a small tray of wood chips until they smolder, which is burning slowly without a flame, and that slow smoldering releases smoke. The element has two jobs: it heats the cabinet to cook the food, and it heats the chip tray enough to make the wood smoke. There is no fire and no gas, just hot metal bringing wood to the point where it smolders. Our Best Offset Smokers compares the published figures of five of them.

Smoldering, not burning

The key is that the wood smolders rather than catches fire. A flame burns wood fast and cleanly and produces little usable smoke; a smolder burns it slowly and incompletely, and that incomplete burning is what throws off the thick, flavorful smoke that seasons food. An electric smoker is designed to hold the chips at smoldering heat, hot enough to smoke but not hot enough to flame.

That control is the whole trick. The chip tray sits directly on or very close to the element, in an enclosed, low-oxygen space, so the wood gets hot but cannot get enough air to burst into flame. It just chars and releases smoke steadily over a long time, which is exactly what low and slow smoking needs.

Where the tray sits

In most electric smokers the wood tray is a metal box or drawer positioned right above the heating element, often toward the bottom of the cabinet. The element radiates heat upward, the tray absorbs it, and the chips inside reach smoldering temperature. Some models have the tray tucked to one side with the element wrapping near it, but the principle is the same: the element is the heat source and the tray is where the wood meets that heat.

Because the element has to heat both the cabinet and the chips, the chips smoke most strongly when the element is actively on and cycling to hold temperature. During a long cook the element turns on and off to maintain the set heat, and the smoke tends to pulse with it, which is normal rather than a sign of a problem.

Why the smoke eventually stops

A tray of chips does not smoke forever. Once the wood has charred through, it stops releasing smoke and becomes spent, so smoke production from one load fades after a while and you add more chips to keep it going. On a long cook this means topping up the tray periodically rather than loading it once and walking away.

This is also why meat takes on most of its smoke early in a cook: the first loads of fresh chips smoke hardest, and the meat absorbs smoke best while its surface is still cool and damp. Many people add chips for the first hours and then let the cook finish on heat alone, because more smoke late on adds little and can turn the flavor bitter.

What affects how much smoke you get

Several things change the smoke output. Dry chips smolder readily; some people soak chips so they smoke more slowly and last longer, though soaked chips first have to drive off their water as steam before they smoke. The size of the wood matters too: fine chips smoke fast and briefly, chunks smolder slower and longer, which is why some smokers suit chunks or pellets better than loose chips.

Airflow plays a part as well. A little air keeps the smolder going, but too much lets the chips flame and burn out fast, while too little smothers them. The vents on the smoker set that balance, which is why smoking guides fuss over vent position: it is really about keeping the wood at a steady smolder rather than letting it flame or die.

The short version

Electric smokers produce smoke by heating wood chips on a tray with the same element that cooks the food, bringing the wood to a slow smolder that releases smoke without a flame. The smoke fades as each load of chips chars through, so you top up the tray during a long cook, and most of the smoke flavor goes into the food early. Control the smolder with chip size, dryness and the vents, and the element does the rest, turning plain wood into the smoke the whole machine exists to make.

Common questions

How does an electric smoker make smoke?

Its heating element warms a tray of wood chips until they smolder, which is slow burning without a flame, and that smoldering releases smoke. The same element also heats the cabinet to cook the food, so the element does the cooking and the wood is the only source of smoke.

Why do the chips smolder instead of catching fire?

Because the tray sits in an enclosed, low-oxygen space on or near the element, so the wood gets hot but cannot get enough air to flame. Smoldering burns the wood slowly and incompletely, and that incomplete burning is what produces thick, flavorful smoke rather than a clean fast flame.

Why does the smoke stop after a while?

Each load of chips chars through and becomes spent, so it stops releasing smoke. On a long cook you top up the tray periodically. Meat takes on most of its smoke early anyway, so many people add chips for the first hours and let the rest of the cook finish on heat alone.

Should I soak the wood chips?

You can. Soaked chips smolder more slowly and last longer, but they first have to drive off their water as steam before they smoke, so they start slower. Dry chips smoke readily and briefly. Chunks or pellets smolder longer than loose chips, which some smokers handle better.

Why does the smoke come and go during a cook?

Because the chips smoke most when the element is actively on, and during a long cook the element cycles on and off to hold the set temperature. The smoke pulses with it, which is normal. Vent position also matters, since a steady smolder needs a little air without letting the chips flame.

Ready to compare actual models?

Our buying guide puts five products side by side on the numbers their makers publish.

More questions about offset smokers