Explainer
Do electric smokers take longer to cook?
Not really; cooking time depends on the temperature and the cut, not the fuel. An electric smoker at a given temperature cooks in much the same time as any smoker, though cold weather or a low-powered unit can slow it down.
By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared
Electric smokers do not inherently take longer to cook than other smokers, because smoking time is governed by the temperature you cook at and the size and type of the cut, not by whether the heat comes from electricity, charcoal or wood. An electric smoker holding a given temperature will cook a brisket or rack of ribs in much the same time as any other smoker at that temperature. What can make an electric smoker slower is a specific circumstance, like cold weather or an underpowered unit, rather than the fuel type itself. Our Best Offset Smokers compares the published figures of five of them.
What actually sets cooking time
The time a smoke takes is set mainly by two things: the cooking temperature and the food. Low-and-slow smoking at a low temperature takes many hours precisely because the heat is gentle, and a big, tough cut like brisket or pork shoulder takes far longer than ribs or chicken because there is more mass and more connective tissue to break down. These factors apply to any smoker.
Because of this, the heat source is largely beside the point for timing. A cut cooked at a steady low temperature will take roughly the same time whether an electric element, a charcoal fire or a wood burn is maintaining that temperature. So the premise that electric is slower misplaces the cause: it is the temperature and the meat that decide, not the fuel.
Why people think electric is slower
The impression that electric smokers are slow often comes from a few real but situational effects rather than the technology being inherently sluggish. Electric smokers are typically used for genuine low-and-slow cooking at modest temperatures, so the long cook times people associate with them are really the times any low-temperature smoke takes, not an electric penalty.
There is also the matter of maximum temperature. Some electric smokers top out at a lower temperature than a hot charcoal or pellet cooker can reach, so if a recipe calls for a higher heat, an electric smoker limited to a lower maximum will take longer to get there or cannot match it, which can make it slower for hotter cooks specifically. For the low temperatures most smoking uses, though, this rarely bites.
When an electric smoker genuinely is slower
There are conditions where an electric smoker does cook more slowly, and they are about the element keeping up rather than the fuel. In cold or windy weather, an electric smoker fights to hold temperature as heat leaks away, so it may run cooler than set and the cook stretches out. A smaller, lower-wattage unit struggles more with this than a well-built, well-insulated one.
Overloading the smoker with a lot of cold food at once also drops the temperature and lengthens the cook until the element recovers, and frequently opening the door lets heat out and adds time, more so than on a heavier charcoal cooker with lots of thermal mass. These are real slowdowns, but they are circumstances affecting whether the smoker holds its set temperature, not an inherent slowness of electric cooking.
Keeping cook times on track
To get the expected times from an electric smoker, help it hold its temperature. Preheat it fully before the food goes in, shelter it from wind and consider an insulating jacket in cold weather, avoid loading it with more cold food than it can recover from, and open the door as little as possible so hard-won heat is not lost and recovered repeatedly.
Judge doneness by the food, not the clock, using the meat’s internal temperature rather than a fixed time, since even at the same setting cuts vary. If an electric smoker is holding its set temperature steadily, it will cook on the same schedule as any smoker at that heat, so the goal is simply steady temperature. Where it falls behind, the fix is almost always about temperature stability rather than accepting that electric is just slow.
The short answer
Electric smokers do not take longer to cook by virtue of being electric, because cooking time is set by the temperature and the cut, not the fuel, so at a given temperature an electric smoker cooks in much the same time as any smoker. They can be slower in specific situations: a lower maximum temperature makes hotter cooks take longer, and cold weather, wind, a low-powered unit, overloading, or frequent door-opening can stop the element holding its set heat and stretch the cook. Keep the temperature steady, preheat, shelter it from cold, and judge by the meat’s internal temperature, and times stay on track.
Common questions
Do electric smokers take longer to cook than other smokers?
Not inherently. Cooking time is set by the temperature you cook at and the size and type of cut, not by the fuel, so an electric smoker holding a given temperature cooks in much the same time as a charcoal or pellet smoker at that heat. It is only slower in specific situations, like cold weather or a low-powered unit.
What actually determines how long smoking takes?
Mainly the cooking temperature and the food. Low temperatures take many hours because the heat is gentle, and big, tough cuts like brisket take far longer than ribs or chicken due to more mass and connective tissue. These apply to any smoker, which is why the heat source is largely beside the point for timing.
Why do people think electric smokers are slow?
Partly because they are used for genuine low-and-slow cooking, so the long times are really what any low-temperature smoke takes, not an electric penalty. And some electric smokers top out at a lower maximum temperature than a hot charcoal or pellet cooker, so for recipes needing higher heat they can be slower, though most smoking uses low temperatures.
When does an electric smoker genuinely cook slower?
When the element cannot hold the set temperature. Cold or windy weather makes heat leak away so it runs cool, a smaller low-wattage unit struggles more, overloading it with cold food drops the temperature, and frequent door-opening loses heat. These are about temperature stability, not an inherent slowness of electric cooking.
How do I keep an electric smoker's cook times on track?
Help it hold temperature: preheat fully, shelter it from wind and use an insulating jacket in the cold, do not overload it with more cold food than it can recover from, and open the door as little as possible. Judge doneness by the meat's internal temperature rather than the clock, since cuts vary even at the same setting.
Ready to compare actual models?
Our buying guides put five products side by side on the numbers their makers publish.