Explainer
Are tortilla presses worth it?
If you make tortillas (especially corn) or flatbreads from scratch often, a tortilla press is worth it: it flattens dough balls into even, round tortillas quickly and easily, far better than rolling by hand. For occasional or no homemade tortillas, you can manage with a rolling pin or buy them.
By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared
If you make tortillas from scratch, especially corn tortillas, or similar flatbreads often, a tortilla press is worth it, because it flattens a ball of dough into an even, round, thin tortilla quickly and easily with a single press, far more easily and consistently than rolling by hand. A tortilla press is a hinged device (usually cast iron, aluminum or wood) with two flat plates and a lever: you put a ball of dough (often between sheets of plastic) between the plates and press the lever down, and it flattens the dough into a round tortilla of even thickness in one motion. This is especially valuable for corn tortillas (masa dough), which are difficult to roll out thin and evenly by hand but press perfectly, and it makes the job fast and consistent for batches. So for anyone who makes homemade tortillas (or similar flatbreads) regularly, a press is a genuinely useful, often near-essential tool. If you do not make tortillas from scratch (you buy them), or only make them occasionally and are happy rolling by hand (which works better for flour tortillas than corn), you may not need one. So whether a tortilla press is worth it depends on how often you make tortillas from scratch, especially corn ones. Our Best Tortilla Presses compares five of them.
What a tortilla press does
A tortilla press is a device for flattening balls of dough into round, even, thin tortillas. It consists of two flat plates hinged together with a handle/lever, and you place a ball of tortilla dough (typically masa for corn tortillas, often between two sheets of plastic or parchment to stop sticking) on the bottom plate, lower the top plate, and press the lever down, which squashes the dough ball into a flat, round tortilla of fairly even thickness in one quick motion. You then peel off the pressed tortilla and cook it. Presses are usually cast iron (heavy, pressing firmly), aluminum, or wood.
So a tortilla press flattens dough into tortillas quickly and evenly, doing in one press what you would otherwise do by rolling with a rolling pin. Understanding this explains the question of whether it is worth it: since you can flatten dough by rolling, the press is about doing it faster, more easily and more consistently (and better for certain doughs), rather than being the only way, so its value depends on how often you make tortillas and how much easier the press makes it. It is especially useful for corn tortillas, which are hard to roll by hand. So whether a tortilla press is worth it comes down to how much you make tortillas from scratch, particularly corn ones, as the next sections cover. Its whole purpose is easy, even tortilla-flattening.
Why it is worth it for homemade tortillas
A tortilla press is worth it for people who make tortillas from scratch, because it makes flattening the dough fast, easy and consistent, which is otherwise the fiddly part. With a press, you flatten each dough ball into an even, round, thin tortilla in a single quick press, so making a batch of tortillas is quick and the tortillas come out uniform (even thickness and round), far more easily than rolling each one out with a rolling pin, which is slower and makes it hard to get them thin, even and round. So the press turns the awkward flattening step into a simple, speedy one.
This is especially valuable for corn tortillas: corn masa dough is not very elastic and is difficult to roll out thin and evenly by hand (it tends to crack or be uneven), but it presses beautifully into thin, even rounds, so a tortilla press is close to essential for good homemade corn tortillas, which is a big reason people get one. For anyone who regularly makes corn tortillas (or uses them for tacos, enchiladas, etc.) or other pressable flatbreads, the press makes authentic, fresh tortillas practical and easy. So for frequent from-scratch tortilla makers, especially of corn tortillas, the press’s speed, ease and consistency (and its suitability for masa that cannot be rolled well) make it genuinely worth it, often near-essential. So its value is clear if you make tortillas, particularly corn ones, regularly.
When you may not need one
You may not need a tortilla press in a few cases. If you do not make tortillas from scratch, buying them instead, then obviously you do not need a press, it is only for making them. Many people happily use shop-bought tortillas and never make their own. So if homemade tortillas are not something you do, the press is unnecessary.
If you make tortillas only occasionally, the press’s convenience is used too rarely to justify a dedicated (and often bulky, heavy) tool, and you could manage by rolling by hand for the odd batch. Also, for flour tortillas (as opposed to corn), rolling with a rolling pin works reasonably well (flour dough is more elastic and rollable, and some even prefer rolling for flour tortillas, which a press can make too thick or not as thin), so if you mainly make flour tortillas occasionally, a rolling pin may suffice and a press is less essential (though it still works and is quick). And a tortilla press is a single-purpose tool that takes up space. So if you buy tortillas, make them only rarely, or mainly make flour tortillas you are happy rolling, you can do without a press. So whether you need one depends on your tortilla-making: frequent from-scratch tortillas (especially corn) make it worthwhile, while buying them, occasional making, or rolling flour tortillas by hand means you can skip it. So it is a worthwhile tool for the keen homemade-tortilla maker, not a universal need.
How to decide and choose
To decide, consider whether and how often you make tortillas from scratch, and which kind. If you make corn tortillas (or similar pressable flatbreads) from scratch regularly, a tortilla press is worth it and close to essential, since it presses masa into even, thin rounds far better and faster than rolling, making good homemade corn tortillas practical. If you make tortillas often even of other types, a press speeds and evens the job. If you buy tortillas, make them only occasionally, or mainly roll flour tortillas and are happy doing so, you can skip it. So base it on your from-scratch tortilla habits, especially for corn.
If you buy a tortilla press, consider the material and weight (cast iron is heavy and presses firmly for good flat tortillas, and is durable; aluminum is lighter; wood is traditional), the size (big enough for the tortillas you want to make), sturdy build and a good hinge and lever (that presses evenly and lasts), and ease of use and cleaning. Cast iron is popular for its weight and durability. You also use plastic/parchment sheets with it to stop sticking. So the honest answer is that tortilla presses are worth it if you make tortillas from scratch regularly, especially corn tortillas, flattening the dough into even, round tortillas quickly and easily (far better than rolling, and essential for corn masa), and not needed if you buy tortillas, make them only occasionally, or mainly roll flour tortillas by hand. So base the decision on how often you make tortillas from scratch, particularly corn ones, and choose a sturdy, suitably sized press (cast iron is a popular, firm-pressing choice) if you do.
The short answer
If you make tortillas from scratch, especially corn tortillas, or similar flatbreads regularly, a tortilla press is worth it, because it flattens a ball of dough into an even, round, thin tortilla quickly and easily with one press of its lever, far more easily and consistently than rolling by hand. This is especially valuable for corn tortillas: corn masa dough is hard to roll out thin and evenly by hand (it cracks and is uneven), but presses beautifully into thin, even rounds, so a press is close to essential for good homemade corn tortillas, which is a main reason people get one. For anyone who regularly makes corn tortillas (for tacos, enchiladas and so on) or other pressable flatbreads, the press makes fresh, authentic, uniform tortillas quick and practical, so it is genuinely worthwhile, often near-essential. You do not need one if you buy your tortillas, make them only occasionally (where rolling by hand for the odd batch suffices), or mainly make flour tortillas you are happy rolling with a rolling pin (flour dough rolls reasonably well, unlike corn masa). A tortilla press is also a single-purpose, often heavy tool that takes up space. So whether it is worth it depends on how often you make tortillas from scratch, particularly corn ones: worthwhile and near-essential for the regular from-scratch (especially corn) tortilla maker, and skippable if you buy them, make them rarely, or roll flour tortillas by hand. A cast-iron press presses firmly and lasts if you buy one.
Common questions
Are tortilla presses worth it?
If you make tortillas from scratch regularly, especially corn tortillas, yes, often near-essential. A tortilla press flattens a dough ball into an even, round, thin tortilla in one quick press, far easier and more consistent than rolling by hand, and it is especially valuable for corn masa dough, which is hard to roll thin and evenly by hand but presses beautifully. If you buy tortillas, make them only occasionally, or mainly roll flour tortillas by hand, you can skip it. So it depends on how often you make tortillas from scratch, particularly corn ones.
What does a tortilla press do?
It flattens balls of dough into round, even, thin tortillas. It is a hinged device with two flat plates and a lever: you put a ball of tortilla dough (usually masa, often between plastic sheets to stop sticking) on the bottom plate, lower the top plate and press the lever, and it squashes the dough into a flat, round tortilla of even thickness in one motion, which you then peel off and cook. So it does in one press what rolling with a rolling pin would do, faster, more easily and more consistently, especially for corn tortillas.
Why is a tortilla press worth it for homemade tortillas?
Because it makes the fiddly flattening step fast, easy and consistent: you press each dough ball into an even, round, thin tortilla in one motion, so a batch is quick and the tortillas come out uniform, far more easily than rolling each by hand. It is especially valuable for corn tortillas, as corn masa dough is not elastic and is hard to roll thin and evenly by hand but presses beautifully into thin, even rounds, so the press is near-essential for good homemade corn tortillas. So for regular from-scratch tortilla makers it is genuinely worthwhile.
Do you need a tortilla press for flour tortillas?
Less so than for corn. Flour tortilla dough is more elastic and rolls out reasonably well with a rolling pin (and some prefer rolling flour tortillas, which a press can make too thick or not thin enough), so for flour tortillas a rolling pin can suffice, though a press still works and is quick. It is corn tortillas (masa dough) that really benefit from a press, since corn dough is hard to roll by hand. So a press is near-essential for corn tortillas but optional for flour ones, where rolling is a workable alternative.
When do you not need a tortilla press?
If you do not make tortillas from scratch (you buy them), since the press is only for making them; if you make tortillas only occasionally, where rolling by hand for the odd batch suffices and a dedicated, often heavy tool is not justified; or if you mainly make flour tortillas and are happy rolling them with a rolling pin. A tortilla press is also a single-purpose tool that takes up space. So buying tortillas, occasional making, or rolling flour tortillas by hand all mean you can do without, since the press mainly earns its place for regular from-scratch corn-tortilla making.
Ready to compare actual models?
Our buying guide puts five products side by side on the numbers their makers publish.