Lush Food & Drink

Buying Guide ·Cookware

Best Pancake Pans for the Shape You Want

The deciding specification is what the pan does to the batter, because these five offer a flat griddle, a lipped crepe round, a four cup mold and a hinged double pan.

By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared

  • Researched & ComparedSpecs pulled from the manufacturer listing
  • Like-for-LikeSame measures across every model
  • No Paid PlacementsNobody pays to appear here

I compared cooking surface shapes, published oven ratings, coating chemistry, handles, induction claims and weights across five pancake pans, using only what each maker writes on its own listing.

Our shortlist

Five products, one set of published numbers.
  1. Blue Diamond 11" Diamond Infused Ceramic Nonstick Sq...
    Best for finishing under the broiler

    Blue Diamond 11" Diamond Infused Ceramic Nonstick Sq...

    The highest oven claim on this page at 600 F with broiler safety, on an 11 inch square griddle with diamond infused ceramic stated 5 times harder and 10 times longer lasting, free of PFAS, PFOA, lead and cadmium.

    • Blue Diamond
    • 11"
    • 2.16 lb
  2. OXO Enhanced 11" Griddle Pan
    Best for a handle that will not melt

    OXO Enhanced 11" Griddle Pan

    The only pick with a stainless steel handle, on an 11 inch hard anodized square griddle rated to 430 F or 220 C, with a diamond reinforced ceramic coating and four substances ruled out by name.

    • OXO
    • 11" Griddle Pan
    • 2.62 lb
  3. SENSARTE 12 Inch Nonstick Crepe Pan Granite Coating ...
    Best for crepes as well as pancakes

    SENSARTE 12 Inch Nonstick Crepe Pan Granite Coating ...

    The only pick with a lip and a spreader, stating a 12 inch round surface with a 1/2 inch side to hold batter, a Swiss ILAG granite coating, a magnetic steel base for induction and a stated 2.5 pounds.

    • SENSARTE
    • 12 Inch
    • Weight not listed
  4. Egg Pan
    Best for four identical rounds at once

    Egg Pan

    The only mold pan here, with four cups that fix the pancake size, plus a triple layer tempered glass lid and a silicone strip that changes color as the pan heats, on a bakelite handle.

    • Xtujcya
    • Middle
    • 1.3 lb
  5. GOTHAM STEEL 8" Double Sided Pancake & Omlet Pan
    Best for a pancake that flips itself

    GOTHAM STEEL 8" Double Sided Pancake & Omlet Pan

    The only hinged pan on this page, closing so the pancake turns without a spatula, in solid aluminum with ceramic applied three times to both halves and the only claim here that metal utensils will not scratch it.

    • GOTHAM STEEL
    • 8 Inch
    • 1 lb

Side by side

Blank means the maker does not publish it.
ModelBrandSize (capacity)WeightBest for
Blue Diamond 11" Diamond Infused Ceramic Nonstick Sq... Blue Diamond 11" 2.16 lb Best for finishing under the broiler
OXO Enhanced 11" Griddle Pan OXO 11" Griddle Pan 2.62 lb Best for a handle that will not melt
SENSARTE 12 Inch Nonstick Crepe Pan Granite Coating ... SENSARTE 12 Inch not published Best for crepes as well as pancakes
Egg Pan Xtujcya Middle 1.3 lb Best for four identical rounds at once
GOTHAM STEEL 8" Double Sided Pancake & Omlet Pan GOTHAM STEEL 8 Inch 1 lb Best for a pancake that flips itself

Each pick in detail

What the listing says for it, and against it.
1 Best for finishing under the broiler

Blue Diamond 11" Diamond Infused Ceramic Nonstick Sq...

The highest oven claim on this page at 600 F with broiler safety, on an 11 inch square griddle with diamond infused ceramic stated 5 times harder and 10 times longer lasting, free of PFAS, PFOA, lead and cadmium.

  • For it
  • The highest oven rating here at 600 F, and the only broiler claim
  • The only quantified coating claim, 5 times harder and 10 times longer lasting
  • Rules out PFAS, PFOA, lead and cadmium by name
  • A flat 11 inch square surface, the most usable area for the footprint
  • Against it
  • Never states what the handle is made of, on a pan claiming 600 F
  • Never names the metal in its body, only a heavy duty base
  • Says nothing about induction compatibility
2 Best for a handle that will not melt

OXO Enhanced 11" Griddle Pan

The only pick with a stainless steel handle, on an 11 inch hard anodized square griddle rated to 430 F or 220 C, with a diamond reinforced ceramic coating and four substances ruled out by name.

  • For it
  • The only stainless steel handle on this page
  • Hard anodized construction, named specifically for heat conduction and scratch resistance
  • Rules out PFAS, PFOA, lead and cadmium by name
  • Publishes its oven rating in both units, 430 F and 220 C
  • Against it
  • The heaviest published weight here at 2.62 pounds
  • Its oven rating is well below the 600 F rival claim
  • Says nothing about induction compatibility

Who should skip this: Skip this if weight matters: at 2.62 lb it is the heaviest of the five published weights.

3 Best for crepes as well as pancakes

SENSARTE 12 Inch Nonstick Crepe Pan Granite Coating ...

The only pick with a lip and a spreader, stating a 12 inch round surface with a 1/2 inch side to hold batter, a Swiss ILAG granite coating, a magnetic steel base for induction and a stated 2.5 pounds.

  • For it
  • The only pick publishing a side height, 1/2 inch, to hold batter in
  • The largest stated cooking surface here at 12 inches
  • A wooden spreader supplied for thin batter, unique on this page
  • A magnetic stainless base stated to work on all cooktops including induction
  • Against it
  • Its exclusion wording is narrower, free of intentionally added PFOA only
  • The lowest oven rating on the page at 302 F
  • Its dimension fields of 12 by 8 by 0.5 inches cannot describe a 12 inch round pan
4 Best for four identical rounds at once

Egg Pan

The only mold pan here, with four cups that fix the pancake size, plus a triple layer tempered glass lid and a silicone strip that changes color as the pan heats, on a bakelite handle.

  • For it
  • Four cups, so four identical rounds cook at once
  • The only lid here, stated triple layer tempered glass
  • A silicone strip that changes color to show the cooking stage
  • Stated compatible with gas, induction, electric, ceramic and glass cooktops
  • Against it
  • Publishes no oven rating at all
  • Names no substance ruled out of its marble stone coating
  • Publishes no diameter for its four cups, only that there are four
5 Best for a pancake that flips itself

GOTHAM STEEL 8" Double Sided Pancake & Omlet Pan

The only hinged pan on this page, closing so the pancake turns without a spatula, in solid aluminum with ceramic applied three times to both halves and the only claim here that metal utensils will not scratch it.

  • For it
  • Hinges shut so the pancake flips without a spatula
  • Ceramic coating applied three times, and to both halves
  • The only claim here that metal utensils, whisks and beaters will not scratch it
  • Riveted rubber grip handles stated to suit right and left handers
  • Against it
  • Publishes no oven rating, on a pan with rubber grip handles
  • Names no substance ruled out of its ceramic coating
  • The smallest cooking surface here at 8 inches

Our verdict

Blue Diamond and OXO are flat 11 inch square griddles that let the batter spread, and Blue Diamond publishes the highest oven rating here at 600 F. SENSARTE is a 12 inch round with a 1/2 inch lip and a wooden spreader. Xtujcya fixes the size with four cups and supplies a glass lid. GOTHAM STEEL hinges shut so the pancake flips itself, and is the lightest of the five at 1 pound.

“A flat griddle decides nothing. A mold decides everything.”

Lush Editorial Team

What separates these five

Shape Two flat 11 inch squares, one 12 inch round with a lip, one four cup mold, and one hinged pan that folds shut.
Oven ceilings Blue Diamond 600 F with the broiler, OXO 430 F, SENSARTE 302 F. Two picks publish no rating at all.
Coating chemistry Two listings rule out PFAS, PFOA, lead and cadmium. One rules out intentionally added PFOA. Two name nothing.
Induction SENSARTE names a magnetic steel base and Xtujcya names induction. The three ceramic griddles say nothing either way.
In the box A wooden spreader with one, a glass lid and a color changing strip with another, and nothing extra with the rest.

How we chose

Priorities, not a computed score. The inputs are published specifications, so we rank by what matters most and say how much.

  1. 30% What the pan does to the batterA flat griddle, a lipped round, a four cup mold and a hinged pan produce four different pancakes, and that is the decision before any figure.
  2. 25% Published oven ratingThe figures here run from 302 F to 600 F and two picks publish none, which decides whether the pan finishes a dish or only starts it.
  3. 20% Coating chemistry as writtenTwo listings rule out four substances by name, one rules out intentionally added PFOA, and two describe a coating without naming anything.
  4. 15% Handle and cooktop compatibilityOnly one handle here is metal, and only two listings confirm induction, both of which follow from the construction.
  5. 10% What comes with itA wooden spreader, a tempered glass lid and a color changing heat strip each solve a problem the bare pans do not.

How the Five Compare on the Numbers

All five of these are sold for pancakes and no two of them make the same pancake. OXO and Blue Diamond are flat 11 inch square griddles, where the batter spreads as far as you pour it. SENSARTE is a 12 inch round crepe pan with a 1/2 inch lip and a wooden spreader. Xtujcya is a four cup mold that fixes the diameter for you. Gotham Steel is a hinged double pan that closes to flip.

Because of that, the useful comparison is not size against size. It is what each one does to the shape of what you pour into it, and after that how hot it will go. The published oven ratings here run from 302 F to 600 F, with two of the five publishing none at all, and that spread tracks the coating rather than the metal.

Specification Blue Diamond OXO SENSARTE Xtujcya GOTHAM STEEL
Shape of the cooking surface Flat square griddle Flat square griddle Round, with a lip Four separate cups Two hinged halves
Stated size 11 in 11 in 12 in not published 8 in
Side height published not published not published 1/2 in not published not published
Oven rating published 600 F, broiler too 430 F, 220 C 302 F not published not published
Coating named Diamond infused ceramic Diamond reinforced ceramic Swiss granite, ILAG Marble stone Ceramic, coated 3 times
Substances ruled out PFAS, PFOA, lead, cadmium PFAS, PFOA, lead, cadmium Intentionally added PFOA not published not published
Coating durability claim 5 times harder, 10 times longer Scratch resistant not published not published Withstands metal utensils
Body construction Heavy duty base, metal not named Hard anodized Cast aluminum core, steel base Aluminum Solid aluminum
Induction stated not published not published Yes, magnetic steel base Yes not published
Handle not published Stainless steel Heat resistant bakelite Bakelite Riveted rubber grip, both hands
Lid supplied not published not published not published Tempered glass, triple layer not published
Other tool supplied not published not published Wooden spreader Silicone strip that changes color not published
Dishwasher stated Yes Yes not published Water or a soft sponge Yes
Weight in the maker’s own words not published not published 2.5 lb not published not published
Published weight field 2.16 lb 2.62 lb not published 1.3 lb 1 lb
Dimension fields 11.34 by 3.23 by 19.13 in 11.33 by 19.29 by 3.14 in 12 by 8 by 0.5 in 7.5 by 6.3 by 7.5 in 6 by 8 by 2 in
Is the long field the handle Yes, 19.13 in Yes, 19.29 in No, the fields disagree with 12 in No handle length given No, it is the pan
Third party rating cited not published Yes, a cooking magazine not published not published Award winning coating claimed

Two of those dimension rows need reading carefully. Blue Diamond’s 19.13 inch figure and OXO’s 19.29 are the pan plus the handle end to end, not the cooking surface, which both listings give as 11 inches. And SENSARTE’s fields read 12 by 8 by 0.5 inches, which cannot describe a 12 inch round pan at all, so its own stated 12 inch diameter is the figure used here.

Four Geometries, Four Kinds of Pancake

The Flat Griddles

OXO and Blue Diamond are the closest pair on this page, both 11 inch square griddles with a diamond enhanced ceramic coating and the same four substances ruled out. A flat square gives you the most usable area for the footprint and it lets you cook four small pancakes at once or one very large one, with nothing to stop batter running to the edge.

That is the trade with a flat griddle: total freedom over size and no help at all with shape. It is also the format that suits everything else a breakfast needs, bacon, eggs and toasted sandwiches, which is why both listings call themselves griddle pans rather than pancake pans and why both are the heaviest published weights here.

The Ones That Shape the Batter

Xtujcya does the opposite and decides the pancake for you: four cups in one aluminum pan, so four identical rounds come out at once, and the listing names omelets, sandwiches, burgers and pancakes for the same wells. It is the only pick supplied with a lid, a triple layer tempered glass one, which is what turns a mold pan into something that can steam as well as fry.

SENSARTE shapes in a different way, with a lip. Its bullets state a 1/2 inch high side to stop liquid running off and to make flipping easier, on a 12 inch round surface, and it supplies a wooden spreader for pushing thin batter out evenly. That is a crepe pan that also does pancakes, and the spreader is the tool no other pick includes.

Coatings, and What Each Maker Will Put in Writing

Two Listings Rule Out Four Substances

OXO and Blue Diamond use the same wording: free of PFAS, PFOA, lead and cadmium. PFAS is the broad family, so ruling it out covers more ground than naming PFOA alone, and both pair it with a diamond enhanced ceramic. Blue Diamond adds the only quantified durability claim here, its coating stated 5 times harder and 10 times longer lasting than traditional coatings.

SENSARTE’s wording is narrower and worth reading twice. It states a Swiss ILAG granite coating free of intentionally added PFOA. Intentionally added is doing real work in that sentence, and it is a weaker claim than the flat exclusions the other two make. It is also the only listing here that names the coating supplier, which cuts the other way.

And Two That Say Nothing About Chemistry

Gotham Steel describes an award winning ceramic nonstick applied three times on both sides and never names a substance ruled out. Xtujcya describes a nonstick marble stone coating as harmless and easy to clean, and names nothing either. Both are coating descriptions rather than coating specifications, and on ceramic pans that is the difference between a claim you can check and one you cannot.

Gotham Steel does make one claim nobody else here makes: that the pan withstands metal utensils, spatulas, spoons, whisks and even electric beaters without scratching. On a ceramic coated aluminum pan that is a bold statement, and it is the only listing in this pool willing to make it.

Heat, Handles and What Will Not Go in the Oven

302, 430 and 600 Degrees

Blue Diamond publishes 600 F and adds the broiler, which is the highest claim on this page by a wide margin and unusual on a ceramic coated pan. OXO publishes 430 F, given also as 220 C. SENSARTE publishes 302 F, which is a low figure and consistent with the bakelite handle it states rather than with the pan itself.

Gotham Steel and Xtujcya publish no oven rating at all. On Xtujcya that is unsurprising given a bakelite handle and a glass lid. On Gotham Steel it is a genuine gap, because a hinged pan with rubber grip handles has an obvious limit and the listing never says what it is.

The Handles Explain the Ratings

OXO is the only pick with a stainless steel handle, and it is the only one of the three oven rated pans whose handle is metal rather than plastic. SENSARTE states heat resistant bakelite and a 302 F ceiling. Xtujcya states bakelite and publishes no rating. Gotham Steel states riveted rubber grip stay cool handles designed for right and left handers, and publishes no rating either.

Blue Diamond is the odd one out: it claims 600 F and broiler safety and never describes its handle at all, on a listing of six bullets. That is the figure on this page most worth confirming before putting the pan under a grill, because nothing published says what the handle is made of.

Which One Fits Your Kitchen

The cook who finishes things under the broiler. Blue Diamond publishes 600 F and broiler safety on an 11 inch square griddle, with diamond infused ceramic stated 5 times harder and 10 times longer lasting, free of PFAS, PFOA, lead and cadmium.

The cook who wants a metal handle. OXO is the only pick with a stainless steel handle, on an 11 inch hard anodized square griddle rated to 430 F or 220 C, with diamond reinforced ceramic and the same four substances ruled out.

The cook making crepes as well. SENSARTE publishes a 12 inch round surface with a 1/2 inch lip to hold batter, a wooden spreader in the box, a magnetic steel base for induction and a stated weight of 2.5 pounds. Its oven ceiling is 302 F.

The cook who wants four identical rounds. Xtujcya is the only mold pan here, with four cups, a triple layer tempered glass lid and a silicone strip that changes color as the pan heats, in aluminum on a bakelite handle.

The cook who would rather not flip. GOTHAM STEEL hinges shut so the pancake turns itself, in solid aluminum with ceramic applied three times to both halves, riveted rubber grip handles and a claim that metal utensils will not scratch it.

What We Could Not Verify

Everything above is from the listings. These are the things looked for there and not found.

  • Gotham Steel and Xtujcya publish no oven rating at all, and neither names a substance ruled out of its coating.
  • Blue Diamond claims 600 F and broiler safety and never states what its handle is made of.
  • SENSARTE says free of intentionally added PFOA, which is a narrower claim than the flat exclusions two rivals make.
  • Only SENSARTE publishes a side height, so the other four give no depth for the batter.
  • SENSARTE’s dimension fields of 12 by 8 by 0.5 inches cannot describe the 12 inch round pan its bullets state.
  • No listing publishes a coating thickness or a warranty period of any length.

Frequently asked questions

Which shape should I choose for pancakes?+

It depends how much control you want. OXO and Blue Diamond are flat 11 inch squares, so the batter goes wherever you pour it and you decide the size. Xtujcya has four cups that fix the diameter, producing four identical rounds at once. SENSARTE is a 12 inch round with a 1/2 inch lip, built to hold thin batter in for crepes. GOTHAM STEEL hinges shut so the pancake turns without a spatula.

How hot can each of these go?+

Three publish a figure and two do not. Blue Diamond states oven and broiler safe up to 600 F, which is the highest claim here. OXO states 430 F, given also as 220 C. SENSARTE states 302 F, which is low and consistent with the bakelite handle it also states. GOTHAM STEEL and Xtujcya publish no oven rating at all, and both have plastic or rubber handles rather than metal ones.

What is the difference between free of PFOA and free of PFAS?+

Scope. PFAS is the whole family of compounds and PFOA is one of them, so ruling out PFAS is a wider statement. OXO and Blue Diamond both state free of PFAS, PFOA, lead and cadmium. SENSARTE states free of intentionally added PFOA, and the phrase intentionally added narrows it further. GOTHAM STEEL and Xtujcya name no substance either way, describing their coatings as ceramic and marble stone respectively.

Will any of them work on induction?+

Two say so. SENSARTE states a high magnetic conductive stainless steel base that allows the pan to work on all cooktops including induction, over a cast aluminum core. Xtujcya states compatibility with gas stoves, induction cookers, electric stoves, ceramic stoves and glass stovetops. Blue Diamond, OXO and GOTHAM STEEL never mention induction in either direction, and aluminum without a steel base will not work on it.

Why is one pan listed at 19 inches?+

Because the dimension fields measure the pan plus its handle. Blue Diamond's field reads 19.13 inches and OXO's 19.29, while both listings state an 11 inch cooking surface in their own bullets. The same caution applies to SENSARTE, whose fields read 12 by 8 by 0.5 inches, which cannot describe a 12 inch round pan. Use the stated size when working out whether a pan fits your burner.

Can I use a metal spatula on these?+

One listing says yes outright. GOTHAM STEEL states that its pan withstands metal utensils, spatulas, spoons, whisks and even electric beaters without scratching, which is unusual on a ceramic coated pan. OXO states scratch resistance from its hard anodized construction without inviting metal. Blue Diamond claims a coating 5 times harder than traditional ones and does not mention utensils. SENSARTE and Xtujcya say nothing about utensils at all.

Specifications come from the manufacturers' own published listings. Lush Food & Drink may earn a commission if you buy through a link on this page, at no extra cost to you. How we research.