Explainer
Are water bath canners worth it?
Yes, if you want to preserve high-acid foods at home, jams, jellies, pickles, tomatoes, fruit, salsa, a water bath canner is worth it: it is the correct, safe tool for the job, and it is inexpensive (really just a big pot with a rack and lid). If you do not can, or only make refrigerator preserves, you do not need one. For home canners of high-acid foods, it is well worth it.
By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared
A water bath canner is worth it if you want to preserve high-acid foods at home, and not needed if you do not can. A water bath canner is essentially a large, deep pot with a lid and a rack inside, used to process filled, sealed jars of food in boiling water for a set time, which is the correct and safe method for canning high-acid foods, jams, jellies, marmalades, pickles, relishes, chutneys, tomatoes (with added acid), fruits, fruit juices, and acidified foods like salsa. For anyone who does this kind of home canning (preserving a glut of fruit, making jams and pickles, putting up tomatoes), a water bath canner is worth it because it is the right tool for the job: it holds the jars fully submerged in boiling water, surrounds them evenly, and lets you process them safely so they seal and keep on the shelf, which is important, proper processing is a food-safety matter, not just convenience. And it is inexpensive: a water bath canner is a simple piece of equipment (a big pot, a rack to keep jars off the bottom and let water circulate, and a lid), so it costs little, and some people even improvise with a large stockpot and a rack. So for home canners of high-acid foods, a water bath canner is well worth it, cheap, and the safe, correct way to can. But if you do not can at all, or only make small-batch refrigerator jams and pickles (kept in the fridge, not shelf-stable), you do not need one. (Note: water bath canning is only safe for high-acid foods, low-acid foods like most vegetables, meats and beans require a pressure canner instead.) So whether it is worth it depends on whether you want to can high-acid foods, if you do, yes; if not, no. Our Best Water Bath Canners compares five of them.
What a water bath canner is and does
To judge whether a water bath canner is worth it, understand what it does. It is a large, deep pot fitted with a rack (to hold jars off the bottom so boiling water can circulate all around them) and a lid, used for the water bath canning method: you fill clean jars with the prepared food, seal them with canning lids, place them on the rack in the canner, cover them with boiling water (by an inch or more over the lids), and boil (process) them for a specified time. The boiling water heats the jars and contents thoroughly, which destroys the relevant spoilage organisms for high-acid foods and drives air out so the jars form a vacuum seal as they cool, making the food shelf-stable (storable at room temperature) for a long time.
So a water bath canner is the vessel that lets you safely process jars of high-acid food for long-term, shelf-stable storage. This is the established, recommended method for canning high-acid foods at home. Its whole value is enabling safe home canning of these foods, something you cannot properly do without a suitable deep pot and rack. Understanding this shows that a water bath canner is worth it precisely for people who want to do this preserving, it is the tool that makes it possible and safe. So its purpose is clear and specific: boiling-water processing of high-acid foods in jars. So its worth depends on whether you want to do that. So it is the right equipment for a particular, worthwhile task. So if you can high-acid foods, it is essential kit.
Why it is worth it for home canners
For anyone who cans high-acid foods, a water bath canner is worth it for two main reasons: it is the correct, safe tool, and it is inexpensive. On safety and correctness: water bath canning is the recommended method for high-acid foods, and doing it properly, jars fully submerged in boiling water, processed for the right time, is a food-safety requirement that ensures the food is safely preserved and the jars seal reliably for shelf storage. A proper water bath canner (deep enough to cover the jars with water, with a rack for circulation and to stop jars touching the hot bottom) lets you do this correctly, so you get safe, shelf-stable preserves. Trying to can without the right setup risks jars not being properly covered or processed, so the canner matters.
On cost: a water bath canner is one of the cheapest pieces of specialist kitchen equipment, it is just a big pot, a rack and a lid, with no complex parts, so it costs little, and it lasts for years (a sturdy pot with no mechanism to wear out). Given that it enables a rewarding, money-saving activity (preserving seasonal gluts, homemade jams and pickles, reducing waste) safely and cheaply, it offers strong value for home canners. Many also find home canning satisfying and like controlling ingredients. So for people who want to preserve high-acid foods, a water bath canner is well worth it: inexpensive, durable, and the safe, correct way to can. So the value is high for its intended user. So if you preserve, it earns its keep easily. So canners benefit clearly.
When you do not need one (and the acid caveat)
A water bath canner is not worth it if you do not do home canning of high-acid foods. If you never preserve food this way, it would just be an unused big pot, so there is no reason to own one. Many people never can and have no need for it. You also do not need a water bath canner if you only make small-batch refrigerator preserves, quick jams, refrigerator pickles, freezer jams, that are stored in the fridge or freezer rather than processed for shelf storage, since those do not require water bath processing (you just keep them cold). So casual, non-shelf-stable preserving does not call for a canner.
A crucial caveat defines the canner’s scope: water bath canning is ONLY safe for high-acid foods (fruits, jams, jellies, pickles, tomatoes with added acid, properly acidified salsa, etc.). Low-acid foods, most vegetables, meats, poultry, fish, beans, do NOT get hot enough to be safe in a boiling water bath and require a pressure canner (which reaches higher temperatures) instead, using a water bath canner for low-acid foods is unsafe (risking botulism). So if you want to can low-acid foods, a water bath canner is not the right tool, you need a pressure canner. So, in sum: a water bath canner is worth it if you want to preserve high-acid foods at home (it is the correct, safe, inexpensive tool for that), not needed if you do not can or only make fridge/freezer preserves, and not sufficient for low-acid foods (which need a pressure canner). So base the decision on whether you will can high-acid foods. So match the tool to what and whether you preserve. So it is worth it for high-acid home canning, and only that.
The short answer
A water bath canner is worth it if you want to preserve high-acid foods at home, and not needed if you do not can. It is essentially a large, deep pot with a rack and a lid, used to process filled, sealed jars in boiling water for a set time, which is the correct, recommended method for canning high-acid foods: jams, jellies, marmalades, pickles, relishes, chutneys, tomatoes (with added acid), fruit, and acidified foods like salsa. For anyone who does this preserving, a water bath canner is worth it because it is the right tool, it holds the jars fully submerged in boiling water (with a rack so water circulates and jars stay off the hot bottom) and processes them so they are safely preserved and seal for shelf-stable storage, which is a food-safety matter, not just convenience, and because it is inexpensive and durable, being just a pot, rack and lid with nothing to wear out. So for home canners of high-acid foods it offers strong value, enabling a rewarding, money-saving activity safely and cheaply. But if you never can, or only make small-batch refrigerator or freezer preserves (kept cold, not shelf-stable), you do not need one. And crucially, water bath canning is only safe for high-acid foods, low-acid foods like most vegetables, meats and beans require a pressure canner instead. So whether a water bath canner is worth it comes down to whether you want to can high-acid foods at home: if you do, yes, it is well worth it; if not, no.
Common questions
Are water bath canners worth it?
Yes, if you want to preserve high-acid foods at home, jams, jellies, pickles, tomatoes, fruit, salsa. A water bath canner is the correct, safe tool for processing sealed jars in boiling water so the food is safely preserved and shelf-stable, and it is inexpensive and durable (really just a big pot with a rack and lid). So for home canners of high-acid foods it is well worth it. But if you do not can, or only make small-batch refrigerator preserves kept cold, you do not need one. And it is only for high-acid foods, low-acid foods need a pressure canner instead.
What is a water bath canner used for?
Processing jars of high-acid food in boiling water to preserve them safely for shelf storage. You fill clean jars with prepared food (jam, pickles, tomatoes, fruit, etc.), seal them with canning lids, place them on the rack in the canner, cover them with boiling water by an inch or more, and boil them for a set time. This heats the jars thoroughly, safely preserving high-acid foods and driving out air so the jars form a vacuum seal as they cool, making the food shelf-stable at room temperature. So it is the tool for water bath canning high-acid foods, the recommended home-preserving method for them.
Can you use a water bath canner for any food?
No, only for high-acid foods. Water bath canning is safe for fruits, jams, jellies, pickles, relishes, tomatoes with added acid, and properly acidified foods like salsa, because their acidity, together with boiling-water processing, makes them safe to preserve. Low-acid foods, most vegetables, meats, poultry, fish and beans, do NOT get hot enough in a boiling water bath to be safe and require a pressure canner, which reaches higher temperatures, instead. Using a water bath canner for low-acid foods is unsafe and risks botulism. So match the method to the food: water bath for high-acid foods only, pressure canner for low-acid foods.
Do you need a special pot for water bath canning?
You need a pot that is deep enough to fully submerge the jars under at least an inch of boiling water and that has a rack to keep the jars off the bottom and let water circulate around them, which is exactly what a water bath canner is. Some people improvise with a large, deep stockpot plus a rack if it is tall enough to cover the jars properly, but a purpose-made water bath canner is inexpensive and designed for the job (correct depth, a fitted rack and lid). The key requirements are the depth to cover the jars and a rack for circulation, so the jars are processed correctly and safely.
When do you not need a water bath canner?
If you do not do home canning of high-acid foods, it would just be an unused pot, so you do not need one. You also do not need it if you only make small-batch refrigerator or freezer preserves, quick jams, refrigerator pickles, freezer jams, that are stored cold rather than processed for shelf storage, since those do not require water bath processing. And a water bath canner is not the right tool for low-acid foods (vegetables, meats, beans), which need a pressure canner. So you only need a water bath canner if you want to make shelf-stable, high-acid preserves at home; otherwise you can do without one.
Ready to compare actual models?
Our buying guide puts five products side by side on the numbers their makers publish.