How the Five Compare on the Numbers
Two unrelated products share this keyword. YUANSHAO and SECOAT sell non woven sheets, 100 to a bag, that stretch over the rim of whatever basket you own. Koackl, BEABOO and Boao sell woven cloth cut to a size, 9 or 10 inches, that you lay inside the basket. The first kind is sized by the largest basket it will reach. The second is sized by the basket it was made for.
That is why the diameters look incompatible. YUANSHAO states a stretch to 19 inches and SECOAT to 21 inches, and neither figure is the liner’s own width; both are the largest rim the sheet will cover. Koackl states 9 inches, BEABOO and Boao 10, and those are cloth diameters. Boao is the only one of the five that publishes a depth as well, at 3.15 inches, or 8 centimeters.
What the table cannot tell you is how much flour any of these fabrics still needs. Every listing claims a non stick or easy release surface, two of them tell you to dust with flour first, and none states a quantity or a fabric weight in grams per square meter. Nor does any of the five say how many washes a cloth liner survives, which is the figure that decides whether six pieces is a season or a decade.
Two Different Products Under One Name
A Sheet Sized by the Biggest Basket It Reaches
YUANSHAO and SECOAT both sell non woven sheets in bags of 100 with an elastic edge, and both describe the same working method: stretch the sheet over the basket, put the dough in, lift the sheet out with the loaf. YUANSHAO states a maximum reach of 19 inches in diameter and SECOAT 21, so one bag covers every basket in a kitchen rather than one basket.
They part company on what happens next. SECOAT calls its liners disposable and sells the count as the point, a fresh liner every bake. YUANSHAO says reusable, or replace at any time, which leaves the decision to you. Both listings state that no cleaning is needed rather than how to clean a non woven sheet, and neither gives a method, so a bag of 100 is best treated as 100 bakes either way.
A Cloth Cut to One Basket
The three cloth liners work the other way. Koackl supplies 9 inch rounds of dense cotton with a textured finish, BEABOO a 10 inch set in a linen cotton blend with an elastic edge, and Boao 10 inch rounds of untreated flax linen at a stated 3.15 inches deep. A cloth this size drapes into one basket and stays there, which is why the pack counts are six rather than a hundred.
Only BEABOO addresses the oval basket problem. Its eight piece set is three 10 inch rounds, three 10 inch ovals and two elastic covers for starter jars, so a baker running a round loaf and a batard on the same day is covered. Koackl and Boao are round only, and a round cloth in an oval basket gathers at the ends, which is where a wet dough sticks.
What the Liner Does to the Crust
Moisture Is the Real Job
A proofing liner is not only a non stick layer. Boao says its flax linen absorbs moisture from the dough for a crisp round crust, BEABOO says its thick fabric wicks moisture away from the dough surface to support crust formation, and Koackl says its cotton absorbs excess moisture while keeping the surface from drying out. Those three claims describe the same mechanism and are the argument for cloth over plastic.
The non woven sheets make a different case. YUANSHAO names good breathability and no fluff, and SECOAT repeats both, but neither claims to absorb anything. A polypropylene sheet holds moisture against the dough rather than drawing it away, which suits a wet dough you want to lift cleanly and works against the dry skin a scored loaf needs. Neither listing acknowledges the trade.
Texture, Release and Flour
Koackl is the only pick that names its surface as the reason it releases: dense cotton with a textured finish, dusted with flour, described as releasing without tearing or clinging. That texture is also what leaves the faint spiral on a proofed loaf. BEABOO calls its linen cotton blend textured and adds that the natural woven surface gives a traditional feel, which is a claim about looks rather than release.
The non woven sheets claim release from the material itself. YUANSHAO compares itself directly to a cloth liner and argues that a wet, high hydration dough moves more easily off non woven fabric, and SECOAT calls it non stick dough technology. SECOAT still tells you to sprinkle flour evenly before placing the dough, which is the same instruction a cloth liner carries and undercuts the claim a little.
Pack Counts, Washing and What Was Left Out
One Hundred Against Six
The pack counts here are not comparable, and that is worth saying plainly. A hundred non woven sheets is a consumable supply, and YUANSHAO at least ships them in a reclosable zipper bag so the rest of the bag stays clean. Six cloth liners is a rotation, and the point of six is that one is always clean while the others are in the wash or on a basket.
Washing is where the cloth liners separate. Koackl gives an actual instruction: shake off the flour, gentle cycle, air dry. BEABOO says to wash before first use and after baking as needed. Boao says washable and reusable without naming a method or a temperature. None of the three says how many cycles the fabric survives, and a floured linen that goes through a hot wash felts and loses its release.
Two Listings Left Out, and One Contradiction
A second eight piece combo sits in this data under another brand, with the same three round and three oval 10 inch liners, the same two starter jar covers, the same linen cotton blend and the same elastic edge. It is the same set, so only one of the two is here. A separate two piece 10 inch flax and cotton liner, reversible and published at 0.13 pounds, was left out as a smaller version of what Boao already covers.
Koackl contradicts itself and it is worth knowing which figure I used. Its title and its size field both say six pieces, 9 inch round, while one of its own bullets refers to a three piece set. I have used six throughout, because two fields agree on it against one. Its package measures 9.84 by 9.84 by 0.67 inches, slightly wider than the 9 inch cloth its title states.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
The baker with baskets of several sizes. YUANSHAO covers all of them from one bag, with 100 non woven sheets that stretch to a stated 19 inch maximum diameter, in food grade PP tested for BPA and food contact to US standards, and shipped in a reclosable zipper bag.
The baker who wants to watch the rise. SECOAT is the only pick whose material is described as transparent, so the dough can be checked without lifting anything, and it stretches to a stated 21 inches. It is sold as disposable, 100 to a pack, with no washing instruction at all.
The baker with one 9 inch round basket. Koackl gives six dense cotton rounds with a textured easy release finish, machine washable on a gentle cycle and air dried, published at 0.19 pounds in a package of 9.84 by 9.84 by 0.67 inches. Round only, and its own bullets disagree on the pack count.
The baker running rounds and ovals. BEABOO is the only pick that supplies both shapes: three 10 inch rounds and three 10 inch ovals in a thickened linen cotton blend with elastic edges, plus two elastic covers for starter jars. No weight and no dimensions are published.
The baker who wants a crisp bottom crust. Boao supplies six untreated flax linen rounds at a stated 10 by 3.15 inches, the only pick that publishes a depth, and the listing is explicit that the linen absorbs moisture from the dough for a crisp round crust. No dye, no treatment, no weight published.
What We Could Not Verify
For a product whose whole function is a fabric surface, nothing about the fabric is quantified:
- The fabric weight of any of the five, in grams per square meter or any other unit.
- How much flour each surface needs, although two of the five tell you to dust before use.
- How many washes the cloth liners survive before the weave felts and stops releasing.
- Whether the non woven sheets can be washed at all. Both makers state only that no cleaning is needed.
- The depth of four of the five, because the only published depth on this page is Boao’s 3.15 inches.
- A weight for BEABOO and Boao, and any figure for Koackl beyond the 9 inch diameter it states.