The deciding specification is the footprint and height each maker states in words, because on two of these five the published dimension fields describe something else.
By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared
I compared the size each maker writes into a bullet against the dimension fields the listing carries, the heights, the divider width one of them fits, drainage and drip trays, materials and weights, across five sink caddies using only each maker's own text.
A black powder coated SUS 304 steel caddy stated at 8.26 x 3.54 x 4.7 in with dimension fields that match exactly, a hollowed base for drainage, a removable plastic drip tray pulled from the front and anti slip silicone pads, at 0.64 lb.
A 304 brushed stainless caddy stated at 7.2 x 4 x 3.5 in with matching fields, an open hollow bottom to increase the draining area, and a removable drip tray that pulls out from the front and is stated dishwasher safe, at 0.62 lb.
A stainless caddy stated at 7.9 x 3.7 x 6.2 in, described by the maker as suited to narrow spaces, with a sloped drip tray that drains automatically, a brush holder that needs no assembly beyond dropping it in, at 0.84 lb.
A 304 stainless caddy stated at 7.20 x 3.54 x 3.15 in with a 2.75 inch bottom measurement, and the only listing here that publishes the divider it fits: a sink divider less than 1.40 inches wide, with a hook design and an open hollow bottom, at 0.4 lb.
A crock style organizer for storing a variety of cleaning tools, published as 3.82 by 5.87 by 5.47 inches in its size attribute, with dimension fields that read 2.31 x 1.5 x 2.15 in, one line of description in the whole listing, at 0.9 lb.
| Model | Brand | Size (Capacity) | Weight | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Consumest Sink Caddy | Consumest | Medium | 0.64 lb | Best for a size you can check twice |
| HULISEN Kitchen Sponge Holder | HULISEN | Medium | 0.62 lb | Best for the lowest published height |
| Kitsure Sponge Holder for Kitchen Sink | Kitsure | 7.9" Wide - 1 Tier | 0.84 lb | Best for a narrow strip of counter |
| JIANYI Stainless Steel Sponge Holder for Kitchen Sin... | JIANYI | Medium | 0.4 lb | Best for a caddy that hangs on the divider |
| OXO Good Grips Sinkware Caddy - White | OXO | 3.82” x 5.87” x 5.47”. | 0.9 lb | Best for a crock rather than a rack |
A black powder coated SUS 304 steel caddy stated at 8.26 x 3.54 x 4.7 in with dimension fields that match exactly, a hollowed base for drainage, a removable plastic drip tray pulled from the front and anti slip silicone pads, at 0.64 lb.
A 304 brushed stainless caddy stated at 7.2 x 4 x 3.5 in with matching fields, an open hollow bottom to increase the draining area, and a removable drip tray that pulls out from the front and is stated dishwasher safe, at 0.62 lb.
A stainless caddy stated at 7.9 x 3.7 x 6.2 in, described by the maker as suited to narrow spaces, with a sloped drip tray that drains automatically, a brush holder that needs no assembly beyond dropping it in, at 0.84 lb.
A 304 stainless caddy stated at 7.20 x 3.54 x 3.15 in with a 2.75 inch bottom measurement, and the only listing here that publishes the divider it fits: a sink divider less than 1.40 inches wide, with a hook design and an open hollow bottom, at 0.4 lb.
A crock style organizer for storing a variety of cleaning tools, published as 3.82 by 5.87 by 5.47 inches in its size attribute, with dimension fields that read 2.31 x 1.5 x 2.15 in, one line of description in the whole listing, at 0.9 lb.
Consumest states 8.26 by 3.54 by 4.7 inches and its fields agree exactly. HULISEN states 7.2 by 4 by 3.5 inches and its fields agree too. Kitsure states 7.9 by 3.7 by 6.2 inches. JIANYI states 7.20 by 3.54 by 3.15 inches while its fields read 7.2 by 7.2, and OXO publishes no size in words at all and fields that cannot be a caddy.
“Two listings publish fields that contradict their own words.”
Lush Food & Drink
JIANYI at 3.15 inches, on its own stated figures, followed by HULISEN at 3.5 inches. Consumest states 4.7 inches and Kitsure 6.2 inches, which is the top of the range here by a long way. OXO publishes 5.47 inches as part of a size attribute and nothing in words, so it is the one figure on this page with no sentence behind it.
Consumest and HULISEN, because their dimension fields and their bullets agree exactly: 8.26 by 3.54 by 4.7 inches and 7.2 by 4 by 3.5 inches respectively. Kitsure states 7.9 by 3.7 by 6.2 inches and publishes the same three figures in its fields in a different order, which is a data entry difference rather than a disagreement.
JIANYI states 7.20 by 3.54 by 3.15 inches in a bullet while its fields read 7.2 by 7.2 by 3.15 inches, so the depth figure has been replaced by the length. OXO publishes no size in any bullet, a size attribute of 3.82 by 5.87 by 5.47 inches, and dimension fields of 2.31 by 1.5 by 2.15 inches, which are too small to be the product.
One, and it is the only listing in this pool that publishes the figure that decides it. JIANYI states a hook design and that it fits a sink divider less than 1.40 inches, or 3.6 cm, wide, and asks you to measure before buying. The other four stand on a surface, and Consumest adds anti slip silicone pads to keep it from sliding into the sink.
Four listings answer. Consumest and HULISEN both supply a removable drip tray that pulls out from the front, and HULISEN states its tray is dishwasher safe. Kitsure uses a sloped drip tray so the water drains away by itself. JIANYI has an open hollow bottom and expects the caddy to sit over the sink. OXO never mentions water at all.
Because it is the shape nothing else here offers: a crock that holds tall brushes upright rather than a rack that lays them down, and at 0.9 lb it stays put by weight. It is included with the warning attached, which is that its whole description is a single line and its published dimensions disagree with each other by more than three inches.
Specifications come from the manufacturers' own published listings. Lush Food & Drink may earn a commission if you buy through a link on this page, at no extra cost to you. How we research.
A sink caddy occupies the most contested surface in a kitchen: the strip between the basin and the wall, or a shelf in the cabinet below it. The figure that decides the fit is the footprint, and four of these five state one in a bullet rather than leaving it to a field. That is unusually good for this pool.
The heights are where they separate. The stated figures are 3.15, 3.5, 4.7 and 6.2 inches, so the top of the range is nearly double the bottom, and the 6.2 inch caddy is the one whose own listing calls it suitable for narrow spaces. The fifth pick publishes no size in words at all.
| Specification | Consumest | HULISEN | Kitsure | JIANYI | OXO |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Size in the maker’s words | 8.26 x 3.54 x 4.7 in | 7.2 x 4 x 3.5 in | 7.9 x 3.7 x 6.2 in | 7.20 x 3.54 x 3.15 in | not published |
| Dimension fields | 8.26 x 3.54 x 4.7 in | 7.2 x 4.0 x 3.5 in | 3.7 x 7.87 x 6.18 in | 7.2 x 7.2 x 3.15 in | 2.31 x 1.5 x 2.15 in |
| Size attribute | Medium | Medium | 7.9 in wide, one tier | Medium | 3.82 x 5.87 x 5.47 in |
| Fields match the words | Yes | Yes | Yes, reordered | No | not applicable |
| Height stated | 4.7 in | 3.5 in | 6.2 in | 3.15 in | 5.47 in, attribute only |
| Bottom measurement stated | not published | not published | not published | 2.75 in | not published |
| Divider width stated | not published | not published | not published | Less than 1.40 in, or 3.6 cm | not published |
| Drainage stated | Hollowed base and a drip tray | Open hollow bottom and a drip tray | A sloped drip tray | An open hollow bottom | not published |
| Drip tray removable | Yes, plastic, pulls out | Yes, dishwasher safe | Yes, sloped | not applicable | not published |
| Non slip stated | Silicone pads | not published | not published | A hook instead | not published |
| Material stated | Black powder coated SUS 304 | 304 brushed stainless steel | Premium stainless steel | 304 stainless steel | not published |
| Weight published | 0.64 lb | 0.62 lb | 0.84 lb | 0.4 lb | 0.9 lb |
| Bullets in the listing | Ten | Five | Five | Five | One |
What the table cannot settle is how much clearance any of these needs behind a tap. Every figure here is the caddy standing alone, and a caddy on a narrow surround is limited by the tap and the backsplash rather than by its own depth. No listing in this pool addresses it.
Consumest states 8.26 by 3.54 by 4.7 inches, and its dimension fields read 8.26 by 3.54 by 4.7 inches. On a pool where fields regularly describe cartons or placeholders, a listing whose two sources of size agree exactly is worth choosing on that basis alone.
It is also the most thoroughly described caddy here. Black powder coated SUS 304 steel stated anti fingerprint, a hollowed design for rapid drainage, a removable plastic drip tray that pulls out from the front, anti slip silicone pads to stop it sliding into the sink, and a rectangular base described as resistant to bending. At 0.64 lb the pads are doing the work rather than the mass.
HULISEN states 7.2 by 4 by 3.5 inches and its fields match. At 3.5 inches it is the second lowest caddy on this page, and no other pick here publishes more than 4 inches front to back, which is the trade: a lower box takes more surface to hold the same brush.
Its drainage is the best documented here. An open hollow bottom stated to increase the draining area and allow airflow, plus a removable drip tray pulled out from the front and stated dishwasher safe, which is the only tray in this pool with a washing rating. It publishes 0.62 lb and 304 brushed steel, and no non slip feature at all.
Kitsure states 7.9 by 3.7 by 6.2 inches and describes itself as suitable for narrow spaces on a countertop. Both statements are true at once: 3.7 inches front to back is narrow, and 6.2 inches tall is the highest figure on this page. If the constraint is a shelf or a window ledge rather than counter depth, this is the wrong shape.
What it buys with the height is a sloped drip tray that drains automatically rather than being emptied, and a brush holder that simply drops into position with no further assembly. It publishes stainless steel construction, a stated list of what fits including spice bottles and cutlery, and 0.84 lb.
JIANYI is the only listing in this pool to publish the sink divider it fits: less than 1.40 inches, given also as 3.6 cm, with an instruction to measure first. For a caddy that hangs rather than stands, that is the specification, and four other listings here leave it out entirely.
It states 7.20 by 3.54 by 3.15 inches with a 2.75 inch bottom measurement, which is more detail than most, and then publishes fields of 7.2 by 7.2 by 3.15 inches, where the depth has been replaced by the length. This page uses the bullet. At 0.4 lb it is the lightest pick here and it has no drip tray, because the water is meant to fall into the sink.
OXO’s entire description is one line: a crock style organizer for storing a variety of cleaning tools. Its size attribute reads 3.82 by 5.87 by 5.47 inches. Its dimension fields read 2.31 by 1.5 by 2.15 inches. Those two sets of figures differ by more than three inches on every axis, and no bullet exists to break the tie.
It is on this page because the shape is genuinely different from the other four. A crock holds long handled brushes upright in a single well, where a rack lays them across a tray, and at 0.9 lb it is the heaviest pick here, which is how a crock stays put. No material, no drainage and no capacity is published.
Across all five the missing figure is the same: not one publishes a load limit, so nothing tells you how many full soap bottles a caddy will take before it tips or bends. Consumest describes a base resistant to bending and Kitsure describes a sturdy structure, both in words.
The second missing figure is clearance. A caddy 8.26 inches long fits a surround 9 inches deep only if the tap is not in the way, and no listing here publishes the space it needs behind or above itself. The best a buyer can do is take the stated footprint, add the tap, and measure the gap in the cabinet if that is where it will live.
A figure you can rely on. Consumest, stated at 8.26 x 3.54 x 4.7 in with fields that match exactly, in black powder coated SUS 304 steel with a removable plastic drip tray and anti slip silicone pads, at 0.64 lb.
The lowest profile that still stands. HULISEN, stated at 7.2 x 4 x 3.5 in with matching fields, an open hollow bottom for airflow and a removable drip tray stated dishwasher safe, in 304 brushed steel at 0.62 lb.
A narrow strip with room above it. Kitsure, stated at 7.9 x 3.7 x 6.2 in with a sloped tray that drains itself and a drop in brush holder, stated to take sponges, dish soap, spice bottles and cutlery, at 0.84 lb.
No counter space at all. JIANYI, stated at 7.20 x 3.54 x 3.15 in with a 2.75 inch base, hooking over a sink divider it publishes as under 1.40 inches wide, with an open bottom and no tray, at 0.4 lb.
Tall brushes standing upright. OXO, a crock style organizer published as 3.82 by 5.87 by 5.47 inches in its size attribute, at 0.9 lb, on the understanding that its listing is one line long and its fields say something else.
Every figure above comes from the maker’s own listing text. These are the things we went looking for and could not source in any of them.
