How the Five Compare on the Numbers
The five picks split into two groups by stated coating. Bellemain, USA Pan, BreadTalk, HONGBAKE and Myyaowl state a nonstick coating on a metal body. Vinino, BIGOWL and Beasea state food grade silicone instead. For a page about nonstick surfaces, the metal pans with a named coating are the closer match, and the silicone pans are the alternative when a coating is not wanted.
Among the five metal picks, USA Pan publishes the most figures: width 11.13 inches, depth 15.75 inches, height 0.56 inches, weight 1.8 lb and an oven limit of 450°F. Myyaowl publishes a pan size of 15.76 by 8.87 inches and 1 oz per cavity. Bellemain publishes a weight of 0.9 lb. BreadTalk publishes a weight of 0.95 lb. HONGBAKE and Myyaowl publish no weight. The table below sets out what each maker states.
The table does not tell you how evenly each pan bakes or how long the coating lasts. Those are performance claims, and no one at Lush has used these pans. The figures show what each maker states about material, size and care, and nothing more. Where a figure is missing, the maker does not publish it.
What the Stated Coating Means for Release and Care
Metal pans with a named coating
Bellemain states a 100 percent food safe nonstick coating and dishwasher safe care. USA Pan states a proprietary silicone coating and an oven limit of 450°F. BreadTalk states a PFOA free coating and notes that the inside of the rolled edge is not coated, so the pan should be dried thoroughly after washing. HONGBAKE states a two layer Whitford coating free of PFOA, BPA and PTFE. Myyaowl states a nonstick coating and dishwasher safe care.
Each of these five states a coating on a carbon or aluminized steel body. The coating is what the maker says provides release. None of the five states a coating thickness or a number of baking cycles, so durability cannot be compared from the fact sheet. The care instructions differ: two state dishwasher safe, one advises thorough drying, and two state nothing about washing.
Silicone pans without a coating
Vinino, BIGOWL and Beasea state food grade silicone rather than a nonstick coating. Vinino states a metal reinforced frame and a temperature range of -104°F to 446°F. BIGOWL states a range of -22°F to 446°F and a set of 4 pans with 6 cavities each. Beasea states 3 pans with 6 cavities each in banana, shell and cat paw shapes.
Silicone releases baked goods by flexing, not by a coating. That is a different mechanism from the metal pans, and it changes care: silicone can be rinsed or washed, while a coated metal pan should avoid abrasive tools. If the goal is a coating specifically, the five metal picks are the match. If the goal is release without a coating, the silicone pans are the alternative.
Size, Weight and Batch Capacity
What the published figures show
USA Pan publishes the only full set of dimensions among the five picks: 11.13 inches wide, 15.75 inches deep and 0.56 inches tall, at 1.8 lb. Myyaowl states a pan size of 15.76 by 8.87 inches with 12 cavities at 1 oz each. Bellemain publishes 0.9 lb, BreadTalk publishes 0.95 lb, and HONGBAKE and Myyaowl publish no weight. BIGOWL is the lightest pan on the sheet at 0.49 lb.
Weight and size decide handling and storage more than baking. A 1.8 lb pan is heavier to lift when filled than a 0.9 lb pan, and a 15.75 inch pan takes more cabinet space than a pan whose size is not published. Because four of the five picks do not publish width, depth or height, fit cannot be confirmed for those. The maker does not publish the figure.
Cavity count and batch size
Bellemain, BreadTalk, HONGBAKE and Myyaowl state 12 cavities. USA Pan states 16 wells. Myyaowl states 1 oz per cavity. BreadTalk states each madeleine is about 2.6 by 2.6 inches. A 16 well pan bakes four more madeleines per batch than a 12 cavity pan, which is the largest stated difference in batch capacity among the five picks.
Cavity count also affects how a pan fits a standard oven rack. USA Pan publishes a 15.75 inch depth, which is the only stated depth among the five. The other four do not publish depth, so rack fit cannot be checked from the fact sheet. If rack fit matters, USA Pan is the only pick with a published depth to compare against.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
If you want two pans and dishwasher safe care. Bellemain states a nonstick coating and dishwasher safe care in a two pack of 12 cavity pans. It publishes a weight of 0.9 lb. It does not publish width, depth, height or an oven limit.
If you want the most published figures. USA Pan states a silicone coating, an oven limit of 450°F, and publishes width 11.13 inches, depth 15.75 inches, height 0.56 inches and weight 1.8 lb. It has 16 wells, four more than the 12 cavity pans.
If you want defined shell ridges. BreadTalk states 12 shell cavities at about 2.6 by 2.6 inches each and a PFOA free coating. It publishes a weight of 0.95 lb and advises drying thoroughly after washing to prevent rust.
If you want a two layer coating. HONGBAKE states a two layer Whitford coating free of PFOA, BPA and PTFE on carbon steel the maker says is 27 percent thicker. It publishes no weight and no dimensions.
If you want a published pan size. Myyaowl states a pan size of 15.76 by 8.87 inches, 12 cavities at 1 oz each, and dishwasher safe care. It publishes no weight and no height.
What We Could Not Verify
The fact sheet leaves several figures unstated. These are the ones we looked for and could not source.
- Oven temperature limits for Bellemain, BreadTalk, HONGBAKE and Myyaowl.
- Width, depth and height for Bellemain, BreadTalk, HONGBAKE and Myyaowl.
- Weight for HONGBAKE and Myyaowl.
- Coating thickness in microns for any pick.
- Number of baking cycles the coating is rated for.
- Whether the coatings are rated for metal utensils.