How the Five Compare on the Numbers
The five oval bannetons on this page differ most clearly in what their makers publish. DOYOLLA states a 10 by 6 inch size and a 0.88 lb weight for its set of two. Saint Germain Bakery states a 10 inch width, a 4 inch depth and a 5 inch height. RICCLE states a 10 inch width, a 5.5 inch depth and a 3.75 inch height. BACCZZY states a 1.5 lb weight for its set of three. KONGDY and Gejoy publish neither dimensions nor weight.
Set counts range from two to eight. DOYOLLA, Saint Germain Bakery, KONGDY and RICCLE each offer two baskets. BACCZZY offers three. Gejoy offers eight. Four of the five state a liner is included. Gejoy does not state a liner in its published features. Material statements are consistent: all five name natural rattan, while RICCLE names premium cotton.
The table does not tell you how any basket performs during proofing. No maker publishes a maximum dough weight, a weave density or a temperature limit. The dimensions that are published describe the basket, not the loaf. A 10 inch width and a 4 inch depth do not state how much dough the basket holds. The table also does not state whether the liner changes the fit of the dough.
What the Published Weights and Dimensions Mean for Handling
Weight as a handling figure
Only two of the five makers publish a weight. DOYOLLA states 0.88 lb for its set of two. BACCZZY states 1.5 lb for its set of three. The difference is 0.62 lb between the two sets, but the sets hold different counts, so the figure is not a per basket comparison. The maker does not publish a per basket weight for either set.
Saint Germain Bakery, KONGDY and Gejoy do not publish a weight. A reader who needs a known weight has two picks to consider. A reader who does not care about weight can look at set count and liner instead. The maker does not state how the weight is distributed across the basket, so the figure describes the whole set as shipped.
Dimensions as a fit figure
Saint Germain Bakery publishes a 10 inch width, a 4 inch depth and a 5 inch height. RICCLE publishes a 10 inch width, a 5.5 inch depth and a 3.75 inch height. The two widths match at 10 inches. The depths differ by 1.5 inches. The heights differ by 1.25 inches. The maker does not state which published figure is the depth of the object and which is the height, so read them as the listing gives them.
DOYOLLA states a 10 by 6 inch size, which names two figures rather than three. BACCZZY, KONGDY and Gejoy publish no dimensions. A reader who needs a stated height or depth has two picks with all three figures. A reader who needs a stated size in two figures has one. For the rest, the maker does not publish the figure.
Set Count, Liners and Cleaning
How many baskets you get
Gejoy offers eight baskets, the largest count among the five. BACCZZY offers three. DOYOLLA, Saint Germain Bakery, KONGDY and RICCLE each offer two. A baker who proofs one loaf at a time may not need eight. A baker who proofs several loaves at once may want more than two. The maker does not publish the dough capacity of any single basket, so set count is the only published measure of how much can be proofed at once.
Four of the five state a liner is included. Gejoy does not state a liner in its published features. RICCLE states a liner and a cover are included. Saint Germain Bakery states a cloth liner is included. DOYOLLA states two liners are included. BACCZZY and KONGDY each state a linen liner is included. The maker does not publish liner dimensions for any of the five.
Cleaning instructions as published
RICCLE states all components, including the baskets, liners and covers, are machine washable. DOYOLLA and BACCZZY state hand wash with warm water and keep dry after cleaning. Saint Germain Bakery states to shake out excess flour and, if dough sticks, let it dry and use a stiff brush. KONGDY and Gejoy state to remove excess flour or dough and store in a cool dry place. The maker does not publish a drying time for any of the five.
Material statements differ in one case. RICCLE states premium cotton. DOYOLLA, Saint Germain Bakery, BACCZZY, KONGDY and Gejoy state natural rattan. Saint Germain Bakery states the rattan is free from dye and chemicals. BACCZZY states the rattan is free of dyes and chemicals. KONGDY states the rattan is free from dye and chemicals. Gejoy states no nasty coating. The maker does not publish a weave density for any of the five.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
Baker who wants the lightest published set. The DOYOLLA set of two weighs 0.88 lb and measures 10 by 6 inches. It includes two liners. The maker states hand wash with warm water and keep dry after cleaning.
Baker who needs a published height and depth. The Saint Germain Bakery basket states a 10 inch width, a 4 inch depth and a 5 inch height. It includes a cloth liner. The maker states the rattan is free from dye and chemicals.
Baker who wants three baskets. The BACCZZY set of three weighs 1.5 lb, the heaviest among the five. It includes a linen liner. The maker states hand wash with warm water and keep dry after washing.
Baker who wants a two basket set with a liner. The KONGDY set includes two baskets and a linen liner. The maker states the rattan is free from dye and chemicals. The maker does not publish weight, width, depth or height.
Baker who wants the largest set count. The Gejoy set of eight is the largest count among the five. The maker states the rattan has no splinters and no nasty coating. The maker does not publish a liner, weight or dimensions.
What We Could Not Verify
Several figures a buyer might want are not published by the makers. These are the gaps I could not fill from the fact sheet.
- No maker publishes a maximum dough weight for any of the five baskets.
- No maker publishes the weave density or strand count for any of the five baskets.
- No maker publishes a temperature limit for proofing or baking.
- No maker publishes the liner dimensions for any of the five sets.
- No maker publishes the country of manufacture for DOYOLLA, BACCZZY, KONGDY or Gejoy.
- No maker publishes a per basket weight for any multi basket set.