How the Five Compare on the Numbers
Small batch preserving means one or two jars, so the lid is stored more than it is used. The published width and depth decide whether it sits flat in a drawer. Three of the five publish those figures. The Mfacoy lid is published as 3.31 by 3.31 by 0.1 inches, and the wide mouth Masontops Pickle Pipes as 0.5 by 3.3 by 3.3 inches. The small mouth Masontops set is published as 4.0 by 4.0 by 4.0 inches.
The other two publish no width, depth or height at all. Easy Fermenter publishes only a weight of 0.64 pounds, the heaviest of the five. Xelyra publishes neither weight nor dimensions. That absence matters for a small batch buyer, because a lid that cannot be measured against a drawer cannot be promised to fit one. The table below sets out what each maker states.
| Specification |
Mfacoy B0FG8CY9VD |
Masontops B01LWS63OF |
Masontops B01ERZGVVK |
Easy Fermenter B0D7KFZPSJ |
Xelyra B0G2T88RKV |
| Published width |
3.31 inches |
0.5 inches |
4.0 inches |
not published |
not published |
| Published depth |
3.31 inches |
3.3 inches |
4.0 inches |
not published |
not published |
| Published height |
0.1 inches |
3.3 inches |
4.0 inches |
not published |
not published |
| Published weight |
0.24 pounds |
not published |
0.15 pounds |
0.64 pounds |
not published |
| Jar fit |
Wide mouth |
Wide mouth |
Small mouth |
Wide mouth |
Wide mouth, 4oz to 64oz |
| Date tracker |
Yes |
No |
No |
No |
Yes |
| Valve type |
One-way waterless |
One-way waterless |
One-way waterless |
Airlock |
One-way airlock |
| Lid count |
Not stated |
4 |
4 |
4 |
6 |
| Dishwasher safe |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Not stated |
Yes |
The table cannot tell you how any lid performs. No one at Lush has used these lids, and the makers publish capability rather than results. What the table does show is how much of the picture is missing. Two of the five publish no dimensions, one publishes no weight, and one does not state a lid count. A reader comparing on storage alone has three products to work with.
Storage and the Small Batch Drawer
What the published figures allow
The Mfacoy lid is published as 3.31 by 3.31 by 0.1 inches, which is the smallest published height of the five. That figure describes a lid that lies flat. The wide mouth Masontops Pickle Pipes are published as 0.5 by 3.3 by 3.3 inches, a set that stacks rather than lies flat. Both figures come from the maker, and neither says how the lid behaves once a jar is sealed.
The small mouth Masontops set is published as 4.0 by 4.0 by 4.0 inches, larger than the wide mouth set on every published figure. It is also the lightest of the five at 0.15 pounds. For a reader with a single small mouth jar and very little drawer space, that combination is the trade: the lightest set, but the largest published footprint among the three that publish one.
Where the record goes quiet
Easy Fermenter publishes a weight of 0.64 pounds and nothing else dimensional. Xelyra publishes no weight and no dimensions. A reader who needs a lid to fit a specific drawer cannot check either against a figure, because the figure does not exist. This guide will not estimate one. The honest position is that two of the five cannot be compared on storage at all.
That does not make them poor choices. The Easy Fermenter kit is the heaviest of the five, which suggests a set of four lids with airlocks and gaskets rather than a single molded piece, though the maker does not state a material weight breakdown. The Xelyra set is the only one of the five published as six complete sets, with six lids, six airlocks, six rings and six grommets.
Valves, Dates and Reusable Parts
What each lid does that the others do not
The Mfacoy lid and the Xelyra lid both carry a date tracker. That is the clearest functional difference among the five. A small batch fermenter running one jar at a time has less need for a tracker than someone running six, but the feature costs nothing to have. The Mfacoy maker states the tracker can be set at a glance, and the Xelyra maker states each lid carries one.
The Masontops sets use a one-piece waterless valve. The maker states it requires no water, no burping and no maintenance. The Easy Fermenter kit uses airlock lids with a leak proof gasket, and the maker states the gasket gives an airtight fitted seal. The Xelyra set uses a one-way airlock system, and the maker states it reduces the need for daily burping.
Parts that can be replaced
JILLMO publishes spare silicone grommets and a one year replacement for damaged small parts. That is the only pick on the sheet with a published replacement term. The maker also states the plastic airlocks should be washed in warm water only and not boiled, which is a care instruction the other four do not carry.
Xelyra publishes six silicone rings and six silicone grommets in the set, which gives a reader spares without a separate order. Masontops publishes food safe silicone that is BPA free and phthalate free, and states the lids can go in the dishwasher with the jars. Mfacoy publishes 100 percent BPA free silicone and states the lids will not crack or warp.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
One jar, one drawer, no fuss. The Mfacoy Original Patented Airlock Fermentation Lids are published as 3.31 by 3.31 by 0.1 inches, the smallest published height of the five, and carry a date tracker for a single batch.
Wide mouth jars already on the shelf. The Masontops Pickle Pipes for wide mouth jars are published as 0.5 by 3.3 by 3.3 inches and use a one-piece waterless valve that the maker states needs no water or burping.
Small mouth jars and the lightest set. The Masontops Pickle Pipes for small mouth jars are the lightest of the five at 0.15 pounds, though the published footprint of 4.0 by 4.0 by 4.0 inches is larger than the wide mouth set.
Four jars at once. The Easy Fermenter kit publishes four lids with airlocks and a leak proof gasket, and is the heaviest of the five at 0.64 pounds. Width, depth and height are not published.
Six jars and spares in one box. The Xelyra six lid set publishes six lids, six airlocks, six rings and six grommets, with a date tracker on each lid. Weight and dimensions are not published.
What We Could Not Verify
These are figures the makers do not publish, and this guide does not fill them in.
- Masontops does not publish a weight for the wide mouth Pickle Pipes set.
- Easy Fermenter does not publish a width, depth or height for its lid kit.
- JILLMO does not publish a width, depth or height for its stainless steel lids.
- Fermentaholics does not publish a width, depth or height for its gallon jar lid.
- Xelyra does not publish a weight, width, depth or height for its six lid set.
- No maker on the sheet publishes a lid diameter for the wide mouth sets beyond the jar fit named in the listing.