How the Five Compare on the Numbers
Weight is one of the few figures on a cookware listing that means the same thing to every buyer, which is why this page is built on it. A roasting pan comes out of a hot oven with several pounds of bird and fat in it, and the empty weight of the pan is the part you can choose. The published range here is narrow and the sources behind it are not.
Across sixteen listings, two makers state a weight in their own feature bullets and it matches the field. One states a weight almost a pound under its own field. Two publish a weight that cannot belong to the pan described and were dropped for it. The rest publish a field and never mention it again, which is most of this category.
What the table cannot tell you is how thin the metal is. Not one of these five publishes a gauge or a thickness, and a pan gets light by being thinner as often as by being smaller. It also cannot tell you what each weight includes, because four of the five never say whether a lid or a rack is counted in the figure they publish.
Where the Weight Field Is Backed Up in Words
The Two Listings That State a Weight
MICHELANGELO gives this page its one fully specified weight. A bullet headed with 2.3 pounds states that the carbon steel pan and rack together weigh about 2.3 pounds before food is added, and the published field reads 2.35. Two sources, one rounded, agreeing. The same listing publishes an interior of 14.6 by 10.6 by 2.2 inches and 16.7 inches across with the handles on, which almost nothing in this pool does.
AMZ-UTHHF does the same thing more briefly. Its first bullet states that the pan weighs 2 pounds, and the published field reads 1.98. That is a maker rounding its own figure up to the nearest pound, which is the ordinary and honest version of this. Its title gives 15.6 inches and a later bullet gives 15.5, a tenth of an inch of disagreement that nobody needs to worry about.
The One That Contradicts Itself
Ecookware publishes 3.64 pounds in its weight field. Its own first bullet states the pan weighs in at 2.8 pounds. That is a gap of almost a pound on a pan of this size, and there is no reading of the listing that makes both true. House rule and common sense agree here: the sentence a maker wrote about the product beats a field somebody typed, so 2.8 pounds is the figure this page uses and 3.64 is reported as unexplained.
The same listing splits on size too. Its title gives 16.5 by 12.4 by 3 inches and its published fields read 12 by 16 by 3. Half an inch on the long axis and four tenths on the short one is the difference between measuring to the rim and measuring to the outside of the handles, which is the usual explanation, but the listing never says so. Either figure keeps the pan on this page.
What a Light Pan Gives Up
Lids Instead of Racks
Granite Ware’s 13 inch oval is the lightest of these five at a published 1.48 pounds, and part of the reason is that it brings no rack. What it brings instead is a self basting lid, porcelain enamel on steel stated PFOA and PTFE free, an oven limit of 932 degrees Fahrenheit and stated room for up to 7 pounds of poultry. The listing also markets the same pan as a sourdough cloche.
bajindan is the only one of the five that includes both, published at 1.76 pounds with a removable rack, a domed lid, silicone handle covers and cleaning sponges. That is a lot in a 1.76 pound package, and it is also where this listing’s problems start: it is titled as a 16 inch pan, its bullets offer 13, 16 and 18 inch versions, and its fields read 7.99 by 13 by 4.72 inches.
Coating, Cleaning and Cooktops
MICHELANGELO is the only nonstick pan among the five, and it pays for that with its cleaning instructions. The listing asks for hand washing in warm soapy water with non scratch tools and states the dishwasher should be avoided to preserve the coating. In exchange it states an oven limit of 600 degrees Fahrenheit and use on induction, gas, ceramic, halogen, electric and glass cooktops, plus open flame, which no other pick claims.
AMZ-UTHHF and Ecookware go the other way with no coating at all. AMZ-UTHHF states freedom from PFOA, PTFE, lead and BPA and is stated dishwasher safe. Ecookware states a no coating design specifically to avoid peeling at high temperature, and then says nothing at all about a dishwasher or a cooktop. Both stop at 450 degrees Fahrenheit, the lowest ceiling on this page.
The Figures We Threw Out
Two Weights That Cannot Be the Pan
Chicago Metallic should have been on this page. Its bullets are the most thorough in the pool: 13.5 by 9.5 by 2.25 inches outer rim to rim, a 12.75 by 9.875 inch cooking surface, a 0.4 mm vessel gauge, a flat fold out handle rack and a named nonstick coating. Its published weight field is close enough to zero that the pipeline nulled it, so the one figure this page ranks on does not exist.
Cuisinart publishes 1 pound for a triple ply stainless roaster with fields of 20.75 by 6.25 by 13.25 inches. A stainless pan that size with an aluminum core and a solid steel rack is not a 1 pound object, so the figure was left out rather than used. In the same pool All-Clad states its roaster is oven and broiler safe up to 6 degrees Fahrenheit, which is a typing error nobody caught.
Sizes That Describe Something Else
Granite bowl sells three pans in one box and publishes 7 pounds for the set, with a package figure of 13.4 by 17 by 3 inches for the carton. The individual pans are described in a bullet at 13.4 by 8.7 by 2.2, 15 by 9.9 by 2.6 and 16.5 by 11 by 3 inches. None of that yields a weight for one pan, so a set cannot be compared against single pans on this axis.
At the heavy end of the same pool, E-far publishes 6 pounds and All-Clad 10.03 for stainless pans of roughly the footprint of the five above. That is the honest context for a lightweight page: the difference between 1.48 pounds and 10.03 is not mostly about how much food fits, it is about how much steel the maker put into the walls and the rack.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
The cook who lifts with one hand. Granite Ware publishes 1.48 pounds, the lightest of these five, in a 13 inch enameled steel oval with fields of 8 by 13 by 5 inches. It brings a self basting lid, states 932 degrees Fahrenheit and claims room for 7 pounds of poultry, and there is no rack to lift separately.
The buyer who wants everything in the box. bajindan is published at 1.76 pounds with a removable rack, a domed lid, silicone handle covers and cleaning sponges, and states room for a small turkey up to 12 pounds. Plan around the 500 degree bullet rather than the 932 in the title, and check which of its three sizes you are ordering.
The cook who will not have a coating. AMZ-UTHHF states 2 pounds, its field reads 1.98, and the pan is uncoated food grade stainless with a stainless rack. Fields of 11.6 by 15.6 by 2.8 inches, stated free of PFOA, PTFE, lead and BPA, dishwasher safe, and an oven limit of 450 degrees Fahrenheit.
The buyer who reads the fine print. MICHELANGELO states about 2.3 pounds for the pan and rack together against a field of 2.35, publishes an interior of 14.6 by 10.6 by 2.2 inches and 16.7 inches across the handles, and states 600 degrees Fahrenheit. It is nonstick, so it wants hand washing rather than a dishwasher.
The cook roasting something that spits. Ecookware states 3 inch high sides to hold juices, includes parchment paper and a stainless rack, and is 304 stainless with no coating. Its own figures disagree, 2.8 pounds in a bullet against a 3.64 pound field, and 16.5 by 12.4 inches in the title against 16 by 12 in the fields.
What We Could Not Verify
Everything above comes from the makers’ own listings. These are the things a buyer choosing on weight needs and the published data does not supply.
- Not one of the five publishes a steel gauge or a wall thickness, which is the specification that actually explains why one pan weighs less than another of the same size.
- Only MICHELANGELO states what its weight covers. For the other four there is no published answer to whether the lid or the rack is inside the figure.
- Ecookware publishes 3.64 pounds in its field and states 2.8 pounds in a bullet, and nothing in the listing explains the gap, so the maker’s sentence is used and the field is reported.
- bajindan’s weight of 1.76 pounds cannot be tied to a size: the title says 16 inch, the bullets offer 13, 16 and 18 inch versions, and the fields read 7.99 by 13 by 4.72 inches.
- bajindan states two different oven limits in one listing, 500 degrees Fahrenheit in a bullet and 932 in the title, and no bullet reconciles them.
- Chicago Metallic publishes a full set of dimensions and no usable weight, so the best documented pan in this pool could not be ranked on the axis this page is about.