How the Five Compare on the Numbers
A family kitchen does not buy a mat, it buys a quantity of bakeware. So the useful figure on this shelf is the piece count and what the pieces actually are, because a purchase of six can be two pans, two racks and two mats, or it can be six mats in four shapes, and those are not remotely the same purchase. These five run from nine pieces down to one.
EWFEN publishes a pack of nine in three bakeware types and three sizes. M MCIRCO publishes six in the same three types and gives a figure for each. Angadona publishes six, all of them mats, in four shapes with the pan each one fits. MMMAT publishes a set of two identical half sheet mats. AMYONE publishes a single mat cut for a full size pan.
What the table cannot tell you is which of the six Angadona pieces are duplicated. The listing names four shapes and supplies six mats and never says which two arrive twice, so a family buying it for cake tins may get a second half sheet instead. EWFEN publishes nine pieces and not one figure for any of them, where M MCIRCO publishes a figure for all three kinds.
The Two Purchases That Include Steel
EWFEN Publishes Nine Pieces and No Sizes
EWFEN publishes the largest piece count here, a pack of nine made up of three rimmed baking pans, three cooling racks and three silicone mats in three different sizes. Its own argument is that the sizes can be freely combined and matched, which for a family cooking two things at once is the point of buying nine pieces rather than three.
What it never does is measure any of them. Its size slot reads Standard, Medium and Large, and no bullet gives an inch figure for a pan, a rack or a mat. It states stainless steel pans and racks with no chemical coating, mats of food grade silicone and reinforced fiberglass rated -40 F to 500 F, four raised feet on each rack, and 5 lb.
M MCIRCO Measures All Three Kinds of Piece
M MCIRCO is the only pick that publishes a figure for every kind of piece it sells. Its first bullet states a pack of six: two rimmed baking sheets at 16 by 12 by 1 inch, two cooling racks at 15.16 by 11 by 0.65 inch, and two silicone mats at 15 by 11 inch, and says each rack and mat fits inside the pans.
That is the sentence a family kitchen needs, because a rack that does not sit inside the pan is a rack that lives in a cupboard. It states pure stainless steel, rust and warp resistant, mats of silicone and reinforced fiberglass rated -40 F to 500 F, four raised feet and dense parallel lines on each rack, and a wash in warm water with mild soap and a gentle sponge. It publishes 5.12 lb.
The Purchases That Are All Mat
Angadona Gives Six Mats in Four Shapes
Angadona matches the M MCIRCO piece count and spends all six pieces on mats. Its last bullet publishes a mat figure and a pan for each shape: a half sheet mat of 16.5 by 11.625 in for a 13 by 18 in pan, a quarter sheet of 11.5 by 8.5 in for a 13 by 9.5 in pan, an 8.5 in round for a 9 in round pan, and an 8.625 in square for a 9 in square pan.
Four shapes across six pieces means two of them arrive twice and the listing never says which. It states 100 percent imported food grade silicone with an LEGB certificate, use in an oven and a freezer across -40 F to 480 F, and washing by hand or in the dishwasher on the top rack only, which is the only rack restriction among these five. It publishes 0.97 lb.
MMMAT and AMYONE Sell One Shape Each
MMMAT publishes a set of two identical half sheet mats at 11.625 by 16.5 in in its size slot, and its own bullet repeats the pair as 11.6 by 16.5 inches. It states German WACKER silicone with a plain capitalized note that the mats are not made in Germany, a 0.75 mm thickness, heat resistance up to 500 F which it also gives as 260 C, and 0.53 lb for the pair.
AMYONE goes further and sells one mat, cut for a full size sheet pan, published at 24.5 by 16.5 in with dimension fields that agree. It states food grade silicone internally reinforced with fiberglass, a European standard, the same 0.75 mm thickness as the MMMAT mats, a glossy dense finish, wider coated edges, -40 F to 480 F, and 0.57 lb for the single mat.
What the Piece Counts Do Not Tell You
Where the Published Figures Argue With the Words
The EWFEN box figure cannot be right. It reads 1.97 by 5.31 by 5.51 in, which is smaller than one of the three rimmed baking pans the same listing says are inside it, let alone three pans, three racks and three mats. That figure is treated here as unusable, and no claim on this page rests on it.
The AMYONE title is the second case. It claims 18 by 26 inches while the size slot and the dimension fields both publish 24.5 by 16.5 in, and since the listing says the mat is cut for a full size sheet pan, the larger pair reads as the pan rather than the mat. This page uses 24.5 by 16.5 in throughout.
Weight Tells You What Is in the Box
The weights here separate the two kinds of purchase more cleanly than the piece counts do. EWFEN publishes 5 lb and M MCIRCO 5.12 lb, against 0.97 lb for six Angadona mats, 0.53 lb for two MMMAT mats and 0.57 lb for the single AMYONE mat. Steel is the whole of that difference.
The figures to be careful with are the per purchase ones. The MMMAT 0.53 lb covers two mats and the AMYONE 0.57 lb covers one, so the lower number is not the lighter mat, and neither listing publishes a per mat weight. Angadona publishes 0.97 lb for six pieces and no figure for any single mat either.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
You are cooking three things at once. EWFEN publishes nine pieces, three rimmed pans, three cooling racks and three mats in three sizes, rated -40 F to 500 F, with four raised feet on each rack. It publishes no figure for any piece.
You want to know what fits what. M MCIRCO publishes two pans at 16 by 12 by 1 inch, two racks at 15.16 by 11 by 0.65 inch and two mats at 15 by 11 inch, and states that each rack and mat fits inside the pans.
You bake cakes and sheet pans both. Angadona publishes six mats in four shapes with the pan each fits, from a 16.5 by 11.625 in half sheet to an 8.5 in round. It washes on the top rack only.
You already own the pans. MMMAT publishes two identical half sheet mats at 11.625 by 16.5 in, 0.75 mm thick in German WACKER silicone, heat resistant to 500 F, and 0.53 lb for the pair.
You have one very large pan. AMYONE publishes a single mat at 24.5 by 16.5 in and 0.75 mm, fiberglass reinforced to a European standard with wider coated edges, rated -40 F to 480 F.
What We Could Not Verify
Six things a reader buying bakeware for a family would want, and no listing among these five supplies.
- Which two of the six Angadona shapes arrive twice, since four shapes are named for six pieces.
- Any inch figure at all from EWFEN, for its pans, its racks or its mats.
- What the EWFEN box figure of 1.97 by 5.31 by 5.51 in actually measures.
- A per mat weight from any of these five, since every figure covers the whole purchase.
- A thickness from EWFEN, M MCIRCO or Angadona, where two of these five publish one.
- Whether the M MCIRCO racks fit any pan other than the two in its own box.