Lush Food & Drink

Buying Guide ·Baking

Best Silicone Tart Molds for Lunchbox Batches

The deciding figures are cavities per bake and whether anything keeps a filled tray from flexing on the way to the oven.

By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared

  • Researched & ComparedSpecs pulled from the manufacturer listing
  • Like-for-LikeSame measures across every model
  • No Paid PlacementsNobody pays to appear here

Five silicone molds compared on published cavity counts, diameters, depths, temperature ranges and reinforcement.

Our shortlist

Five products, one set of published numbers.
  1. Redfly Silicone Egg Molds for Breakfast Sandwiches 2...
    Best for a full week in one bake

    Redfly Silicone Egg Molds for Breakfast Sandwiches 2...

    Twelve cavities across two narrow trays, with 3 inch cups 0.7 to 0.75 inches deep.

    • Redfly
    • 2pcs: 3 inch Regular
    • 0.49 lb
  2. 4 Inch Jumbo Silicone Muffin Top Pan with Frame Non ...
    Best for sandwich sized rounds

    4 Inch Jumbo Silicone Muffin Top Pan with Frame Non ...

    Six 4 inch cups on one tray with a metal rim and handles, and a 450 F ceiling.

    • Vnray
    • 6 Cup Size
    • 0.9 lb
  3. Silicone Egg Molds
    Best for carrying a filled tray

    Silicone Egg Molds

    A hidden stainless steel frame around the edge, with 3 inch cups 0.65 inch deep.

    • CAKETIME
    • Regular 3"- 2pcs
    • 1.01 lb
  4. HUAKENER 2 Pcs Silicone Muffin Top Pan for Baking
    Best wider cavities in quantity

    HUAKENER 2 Pcs Silicone Muffin Top Pan for Baking

    Twelve cavities of 3.8 inches across two molds of 12.5 by 8.5 by 0.9 inches.

    • HUAKENER
    • Large
    • 0.73 lb
  5. 4-Piece Silicone Air Fryer Baking Ramekins with Nons...
    Best for four different lunches

    4-Piece Silicone Air Fryer Baking Ramekins with Nons...

    Four separate silicone ramekins with lift handles, published at 0.23 pounds for the set.

    • LivGrain
    • Gray
    • 0.23 lb

Side by side

Blank means the maker does not publish it.
ModelBrandSize (capacity)WeightBest for
Redfly Silicone Egg Molds for Breakfast Sandwiches 2... Redfly 2pcs: 3 inch Regular 0.49 lb Best for a full week in one bake
4 Inch Jumbo Silicone Muffin Top Pan with Frame Non ... Vnray 6 Cup Size 0.9 lb Best for sandwich sized rounds
Silicone Egg Molds CAKETIME Regular 3"- 2pcs 1.01 lb Best for carrying a filled tray
HUAKENER 2 Pcs Silicone Muffin Top Pan for Baking HUAKENER Large 0.73 lb Best wider cavities in quantity
4-Piece Silicone Air Fryer Baking Ramekins with Nons... LivGrain Gray 0.23 lb Best for four different lunches

Each pick in detail

What the listing says for it, and against it.
1 Best for a full week in one bake

Redfly Silicone Egg Molds for Breakfast Sandwiches 2...

Twelve cavities across two narrow trays, with 3 inch cups 0.7 to 0.75 inches deep.

  • For it
  • Publishes twelve cavities, six per tray
  • Publishes both diameter and depth, 3 inches and 0.7 to 0.75 inches
  • Trays are 6.8 inches across, so both fit one oven rack
  • Range of -104 F to 446 F, given also as -40 C to 230 C
  • Against it
  • No metal frame, only silicone rings of 0.3 cm and 0.7 cm
  • Recommends greasing for best results
  • Its 0.49 pound weight covers two trays, so it cannot be compared with single tray figures
2 Best for sandwich sized rounds

4 Inch Jumbo Silicone Muffin Top Pan with Frame Non ...

Six 4 inch cups on one tray with a metal rim and handles, and a 450 F ceiling.

  • For it
  • Publishes 4 inch cups, the largest cavity diameter here
  • Metal rim with handles, stated to stop sagging and tearing
  • Publishes the highest ceiling of the five at 450 F
  • States the routine: grease, fill, bake, release, and stores flat or hangs
  • Against it
  • Publishes no cavity depth
  • Six cavities in one tray, half the count of the two tray sets
  • No silicone thickness published behind the thickened claim

Who should skip this: Skip this if counter or storage space is tight: it has the largest published footprint of the five, 15.31 by 9.09 inches.

3 Best for carrying a filled tray

Silicone Egg Molds

A hidden stainless steel frame around the edge, with 3 inch cups 0.65 inch deep.

  • For it
  • Hidden stainless steel frame around the outer edge
  • Publishes cup diameter and depth, 3 inches and 0.65 inch
  • Range of -104 F to 446 F, with oven, microwave, dishwasher, fridge and freezer listed
  • Stated as easy to hang for storage
  • Against it
  • Never states how many cavities a tray holds
  • Publishes 1.01 pounds for two trays, the most material here
  • No greasing guidance published
4 Best wider cavities in quantity

HUAKENER 2 Pcs Silicone Muffin Top Pan for Baking

Twelve cavities of 3.8 inches across two molds of 12.5 by 8.5 by 0.9 inches.

  • For it
  • Publishes twelve cavities of 3.8 inches across two molds
  • Publishes full mold figures, 12.5 by 8.5 by 0.9 inches each
  • Range of -40 F to 446 F, with microwave, oven, fridge and dishwasher named
  • Thicker silicone stated to resist deforming
  • Against it
  • No cavity depth published
  • At 8.5 inches each, two molds will not share one rack in most ovens
  • No frame or rim, and no thickness figure for the thicker silicone
5 Best for four different lunches

4-Piece Silicone Air Fryer Baking Ramekins with Nons...

Four separate silicone ramekins with lift handles, published at 0.23 pounds for the set.

  • For it
  • Four separate cups, each with a lift handle
  • Publishes 0.23 pounds for the set
  • Named for eggs, muffins, cupcakes, puddings, tarts and custards
  • Stated not to scratch nonstick pans, and reusable
  • Against it
  • Publishes no diameter, depth or capacity
  • Publishes no temperature range at all
  • No dishwasher statement, only that they are easy to clean

Our verdict

Redfly publishes twelve cavities across two narrow trays, 3 inch cups 0.7 to 0.75 inches deep, rated -104 F to 446 F. HUAKENER publishes twelve 3.8 inch cavities on larger trays. Vnray publishes six 4 inch cups with a metal rim and handles and the highest ceiling at 450 F. CAKETIME publishes a hidden steel frame. LivGrain publishes four separate cups with lift handles.

“A filled tray flexes. That is what the metal rim is for.”

Lush Editorial Team

What separates these five

Cavities decide the batch Twelve across two trays from Redfly and HUAKENER, six in one tray from Vnray, four separate cups from LivGrain, and an unstated number from CAKETIME.
Depth is mostly missing Redfly publishes 0.7 to 0.75 inch cups and CAKETIME 0.65 inch. The other three publish diameters only, so fill volume cannot be worked out.
Two publish a metal edge A filled silicone tray flexes on the way to the oven. Vnray publishes a metal rim with handles and CAKETIME a hidden stainless frame; nobody else publishes anything structural.
446 F, three times over Redfly, HUAKENER and CAKETIME all publish 446 F, which is 230 C converted. Vnray publishes 450 F and LivGrain publishes nothing at all.
Tray width decides the rack Two trays at 6.8 inches each sit side by side on one rack. Two at 8.5 inches each generally do not, which turns one bake into two.

How we chose

Priorities, not a computed score. The inputs are published specifications, so we rank by what matters most and say how much.

  1. 30% Cavities per bakeA lunch routine is counted in portions, and these five range from four cups to twelve cavities in one session.
  2. 25% Cavity diameter and depthA 3 inch cup and a 4 inch cup are different foods, and only two listings publish a depth to go with the diameter.
  3. 20% Frame or rimA filled silicone tray is the weak point of this category, and two of the five publish something to stop it flexing.
  4. 15% Temperature rangeBatches get frozen as well as baked, and one listing publishes no range in either direction.
  5. 10% Tray footprintTwo trays only save time if they fit one rack, which the published tray widths decide.

How the Five Compare on the Numbers

Lunch prep is counted in portions, so the first published figure that matters is how many cavities you get in one bake. Redfly publishes twelve across two trays, six per tray. HUAKENER publishes the same arrangement with 3.8 inch cavities. Vnray publishes six 4 inch cups in one tray. LivGrain publishes four separate cups, and CAKETIME publishes two trays without ever stating a cavity count.

The second figure is the temperature ceiling, and these five do not agree. Redfly and CAKETIME both publish -104 F to 446 F, and Redfly gives the Celsius equivalent of -40 C to 230 C. HUAKENER publishes -40 F to 446 F. Vnray publishes -40 F to 450 F, the highest ceiling here. LivGrain publishes no temperature at all.

Specification Vnray Redfly HUAKENER CAKETIME LivGrain
Cavities published Six in one tray Twelve, six per tray Twelve, six per mold not published, two trays Four separate cups
Cavity diameter stated 4 in 3 in 3.8 in 3 in at the top not published
Cavity depth stated not published 0.7 to 0.75 in not published 0.65 in not published
Tray figures published 9.09 x 15.31 x 0.7 in 11.6 x 6.8 x 0.75 in 12.5 x 8.5 x 0.9 in Package, 7.4 x 13 x 0.75 in Package, 3.94 x 3.94 x 1.18 in
Reinforcement stated Metal rim with handles Silicone rings, 0.3 cm and 0.7 cm Thicker silicone, no frame Hidden stainless steel frame not published
Temperature range stated -40 F to 450 F -104 F to 446 F -40 F to 446 F -104 F to 446 F not published
Dishwasher Yes Yes Yes Yes Easy to clean, no machine named
Hanging or flat storage Stores flat or hangs Elasticized hanging ring not published Stated as easy to hang not published
Published weight 0.9 lb 0.49 lb for two 0.73 lb for two 1.01 lb for two 0.23 lb for four
Greasing advised Yes, grease then fill Yes, for best results not published not published not published

None of those weights can be read against another. Vnray’s 0.9 pounds is one tray, Redfly’s 0.49 and HUAKENER’s 0.73 and CAKETIME’s 1.01 are each two trays, and LivGrain’s 0.23 pounds is four separate cups. The interesting pair is Redfly and CAKETIME: both publish two trays of 3 inch cups, and one publishes twice the weight of the other, which is what a steel frame adds.

Counting Portions per Bake

Twelve in one session

Redfly and HUAKENER both publish twelve cavities across two trays, which for a weekly lunch routine is the number that matters: six days of egg bites or mini quiches from one oven session. Redfly publishes 3 inch cavities on trays of 11.6 by 6.8 by 0.75 inches. HUAKENER publishes 3.8 inch cavities on larger trays of 12.5 by 8.5 by 0.9 inches.

Two trays also means two shelves or a wider one, and the published tray figures are what decides that. Redfly’s trays are the narrower pair at 6.8 inches, so both will sit side by side on a standard rack. HUAKENER’s at 8.5 inches each will not, in most home ovens, which turns a single bake into two.

Six larger cups, or four separate ones

Vnray publishes six cups at 4 inches, the largest cavity diameter here, on a single tray of 9.09 by 15.31 by 0.7 inches. Four inches is a sandwich sized round rather than a tartlet, which its listing acknowledges by naming hamburger buns and whoopie pies alongside egg patties. Six of those is a working week of breakfasts for one person.

LivGrain takes the opposite approach with four separate silicone ramekins, each with lift handles, published at 0.23 pounds for the set. Separate cups can be filled at different levels and taken out of the oven individually, which suits four different lunches rather than one repeated twelve times. It publishes no diameter, depth or temperature at all.

What Keeps a Full Tray Flat

The two reinforced trays

A silicone tray full of raw egg is the one that flexes on the way to the oven, and two listings here address it directly. CAKETIME publishes a hidden stainless steel frame around the outer edge and says it makes the mold more sturdy and stops spilling when the filled tray is carried from counter to oven. That frame is also where its 1.01 pound weight comes from.

Vnray publishes a metal rim with sturdy handles and makes the comparison explicit, saying that unlike pans that sag or tear it is reinforced and thickened for repeat use. Between them these are the only two picks here that publish anything structural, and they are the two aimed at people carrying a full tray several times a week.

The three without a frame

HUAKENER publishes thicker silicone rather than a frame, saying it is tougher and less likely to deform than ordinary molds, without giving a thickness. Redfly publishes something different again: silicone rings of 0.3 cm and 0.7 cm that it says improve durability, plus an elasticized hanging ring on the tray.

LivGrain publishes lift handles on each individual cup, which solves the same problem by making each portion small enough to carry. A four ounce ramekin does not flex the way a six cavity tray does. It also means four separate objects to fill, move and wash rather than one.

Temperatures, Cleaning and Release

Four ceilings, one silence

Vnray publishes -40 F to 450 F, which is four degrees above the 446 F that Redfly, HUAKENER and CAKETIME all publish. That 446 figure is the Fahrenheit conversion of 230 C, which Redfly states outright, so three of these listings are quoting the same underlying limit and one has rounded upward to a friendlier number.

At the cold end, Redfly and CAKETIME publish -104 F while Vnray and HUAKENER publish -40 F. All four name a freezer among their uses, and for lunch prep that matters: egg bites are usually made in a batch and frozen. LivGrain names no temperature in either direction, which on a mold sold for an air fryer is the most surprising gap here.

Release, greasing and washing

Two listings are honest about greasing. Vnray states the routine plainly, grease, fill, bake and release, and claims a five second pop out. Redfly says the cavities are smooth and flexible and then recommends greasing for best results. Neither HUAKENER nor CAKETIME mentions greasing, although both describe a non stick surface, and LivGrain describes silicone that will not scratch pans.

All four trays state dishwasher safety. LivGrain says only that the cups are easy to clean and reusable, naming no machine. CAKETIME lists oven, microwave, dishwasher, fridge and freezer together, which is the broadest appliance list of the five and the same list HUAKENER gives minus the freezer.

Which One Fits Your Kitchen

The cook batching a whole week. Redfly publishes twelve cavities across two trays of 11.6 by 6.8 by 0.75 inches, with 3 inch cups 0.7 to 0.75 inches deep and a range of -104 F to 446 F. Both trays are narrow enough to sit on one rack.

The cook making sandwich rounds. Vnray publishes six 4 inch cups, the largest cavity here, on a 9.09 by 15.31 inch tray with a metal rim and handles, and the highest stated ceiling at 450 F. Its listing gives the greasing routine in full.

The cook carrying a full tray. CAKETIME publishes a hidden stainless steel frame, 3 inch cups 0.65 inch deep, and a range of -104 F to 446 F across two trays at 1.01 pounds. It never states how many cavities each tray holds.

The cook who wants wider cups in quantity. HUAKENER publishes twelve cavities of 3.8 inches across two molds of 12.5 by 8.5 by 0.9 inches, with thicker silicone instead of a frame and a range of -40 F to 446 F. Two trays that wide need two rack positions.

The cook making four different lunches. LivGrain publishes four separate silicone ramekins with lift handles at 0.23 pounds, for eggs, custards and tarts in an air fryer or an oven. No diameter, depth or temperature is published anywhere in the listing.

What We Could Not Verify

All the figures above come from the makers’ published text. These are the gaps.

  • No cavity count from one listing that sells two trays.
  • No cavity depth from three of the five, so fill volume is unknown.
  • No diameter, depth or temperature from the set of individual cups.
  • No silicone thickness from any of the five, including the one that sells itself on being thicker.
  • No explanation of a 450 F ceiling where three other listings publish 446 F.
  • No cavity volume in ounces or milliliters anywhere in this group.

Frequently asked questions

How many portions can I make in one bake?+

Twelve, if you buy one of the two tray sets. Redfly publishes twelve cavities across two trays at six per tray, and HUAKENER publishes twelve across two molds. Vnray publishes six in a single tray, and LivGrain publishes four separate cups. CAKETIME sells two trays and never states how many cavities each one has, which for a batch routine is the one figure you would want confirmed before ordering.

Will two trays fit in the oven at once?+

It depends on the tray, and the published figures answer it. Redfly's trays are 11.6 by 6.8 inches each, so two will sit side by side on a standard rack. HUAKENER's are 12.5 by 8.5 inches each, which in most home ovens means one tray per shelf. Vnray publishes a single tray of 9.09 by 15.31 inches, which occupies most of one rack by itself.

Does a silicone tray need a metal frame?+

It helps at exactly one moment: carrying a full tray of liquid to the oven. CAKETIME publishes a hidden stainless steel frame around the outer edge and says it prevents spilling during that transfer. Vnray publishes a metal rim with handles for the same reason. HUAKENER offers thicker silicone instead, and Redfly publishes silicone rings of 0.3 cm and 0.7 cm. The individual cups avoid the problem by being small.

What temperature can these molds take?+

Four publish a figure and three of those are the same figure. Redfly, HUAKENER and CAKETIME all publish 446 F, which is 230 C converted, and Redfly states both. Vnray publishes 450 F, slightly above the others. At the cold end Redfly and CAKETIME publish -104 F and Vnray and HUAKENER publish -40 F. LivGrain publishes no temperature at all, which is odd for a mold sold for air fryer use.

Do I still need to grease silicone?+

Two of these listings say so. Vnray gives the routine as grease, fill, bake, release, and claims a five second pop out. Redfly describes smooth flexible cavities and then recommends greasing for best results. HUAKENER and CAKETIME describe non stick surfaces without mentioning grease, and LivGrain says only that the cups release baked goods while keeping their shape. Treat a light greasing as the safe default for egg mixtures.

Which of these can go in the freezer?+

Four of the five name it. CAKETIME lists oven, microwave, dishwasher, fridge and freezer. Redfly publishes -104 F and describes a wide temperature range. Vnray publishes -40 F and names the fridge. HUAKENER names the refrigerator and publishes -40 F. LivGrain publishes no temperature range, so freezing is unstated. For a lunch batch that gets frozen and reheated, the published cold figure is as important as the ceiling.

Specifications come from the manufacturers' own published listings. Lush Food & Drink may earn a commission if you buy through a link on this page, at no extra cost to you. How we research.