Lush Food & Drink

Buying Guide ·Preserving

Best Yogurt Makers for Greek Yogurt and Probiotics

The deciding specification is the temperature range, and only two of these five publish one.

By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared

  • Researched & ComparedSpecs pulled from the manufacturer listing
  • Like-for-LikeSame measures across every model
  • No Paid PlacementsNobody pays to appear here

I compared published temperature ranges, timers, container arrangements, strainers, displays and weights across five yogurt makers, using only what each maker states.

Our shortlist

Five products, one set of published numbers.
  1. GDOR Yogurt Maker Machine with Adjustable Temp & Tim...
    Best for setting the fermentation temperature

    GDOR Yogurt Maker Machine with Adjustable Temp & Tim...

    Publishes the widest stated range here, 68 to 131 degrees Fahrenheit, with a timer up to 48 hours, a clear digital display, auto shut-off and a stainless steel body, across 8 BPA-free glass jars of 6 ounces each so several flavors ferment in one run.

    • GDOR
    • MEDIUM
    • Weight not listed
  2. Yogurt Maker with Adjustable 48 Hour Time & 68-127℉ ...
    Best for watching the set through the lid

    Yogurt Maker with Adjustable 48 Hour Time & 68-127℉ ...

    Pairs a published range of 68 to 127 degrees Fahrenheit and a 48 hour timer with an LED display and a clear top cover, so the fermentation can be judged by eye as well as by clock, across 8 dishwasher-safe glass jars of 6 ounces each.

    • cewajbaa
    • Eight 6oz Jars
    • 4.21 lb
  3. Ultimate Probiotic Yogurt Maker with TruTemp™ Adjust...
    Best for a 36 hour reuteri ferment

    Ultimate Probiotic Yogurt Maker with TruTemp™ Adjust...

    Built for long low ferments, holding a steady temperature for up to 48 hours and naming the cultures it is for, L. reuteri and L. gasseri, with two 1-quart glass containers making about eight 1-cup servings a batch, a recipe ebook and an unlimited lifetime warranty.

    • Ultimate
    • With Two 1-Quart Containers
    • 4.45 lb
  4. Bear Yogurt Maker
    Best for straining Greek yogurt in the machine

    Bear Yogurt Maker

    The only pick supplying a strainer, a 100-mesh food-safe one for turning plain yogurt into Greek, alongside a 304 stainless inner pot, a microcomputer timer up to 14 hours, an LED display, auto shut-off with a buzzer and dishwasher-safe containers.

    • Bear
    • 2 x 33.8 oz
    • 3.5 lb
  5. Euro Cuisine YM80 Electric Yogurt Maker Machine- Pro...
    Best for a switch and nothing to program

    Euro Cuisine YM80 Electric Yogurt Maker Machine- Pro...

    The simplest machine here: an on and off switch, an indicating light, a time reminder and a transparent lid, with seven 6 ounce glass jars and BPA-free lids so seven different yogurts can be made and then stored in the refrigerator in the same jars.

    • Euro Cuisine
    • YM80
    • 4 lb

Side by side

Blank means the maker does not publish it.
ModelBrandSize (capacity)WeightBest for
GDOR Yogurt Maker Machine with Adjustable Temp & Tim... GDOR MEDIUM not published Best for setting the fermentation temperature
Yogurt Maker with Adjustable 48 Hour Time & 68-127℉ ... cewajbaa Eight 6oz Jars 4.21 lb Best for watching the set through the lid
Ultimate Probiotic Yogurt Maker with TruTemp™ Adjust... Ultimate With Two 1-Quart Containers 4.45 lb Best for a 36 hour reuteri ferment
Bear Yogurt Maker Bear 2 x 33.8 oz 3.5 lb Best for straining Greek yogurt in the machine
Euro Cuisine YM80 Electric Yogurt Maker Machine- Pro... Euro Cuisine YM80 4 lb Best for a switch and nothing to program

Each pick in detail

What the listing says for it, and against it.
1 Best for setting the fermentation temperature

GDOR Yogurt Maker Machine with Adjustable Temp & Tim...

Publishes the widest stated range here, 68 to 131 degrees Fahrenheit, with a timer up to 48 hours, a clear digital display, auto shut-off and a stainless steel body, across 8 BPA-free glass jars of 6 ounces each so several flavors ferment in one run.

  • For it
  • The widest published temperature range here, 68 to 131 degrees Fahrenheit
  • A 48 hour timer with a clear digital display
  • Auto shut-off, published as a feature rather than implied
  • 8 BPA-free glass jars of 6 ounces each
  • Against it
  • Publishes no weight and no dimensions at all
  • Publishes no strainer, so Greek yogurt needs your own cloth
  • Publishes no dishwasher statement for the jars
2 Best for watching the set through the lid

Yogurt Maker with Adjustable 48 Hour Time & 68-127℉ ...

Pairs a published range of 68 to 127 degrees Fahrenheit and a 48 hour timer with an LED display and a clear top cover, so the fermentation can be judged by eye as well as by clock, across 8 dishwasher-safe glass jars of 6 ounces each.

  • For it
  • Publishes a temperature range, 68 to 127 degrees Fahrenheit, and a 48 hour timer
  • An LED display showing both the set time and the set temperature
  • A clear top cover for judging the set without opening the machine
  • 8 glass jars of 6 ounces, stated dishwasher safe and BPA free
  • Against it
  • Its 127 degree ceiling is 4 degrees below the highest published here
  • Publishes no auto shut-off
  • Publishes no dimensions, so counter space is unknown
3 Best for a 36 hour reuteri ferment

Ultimate Probiotic Yogurt Maker with TruTemp™ Adjust...

Built for long low ferments, holding a steady temperature for up to 48 hours and naming the cultures it is for, L. reuteri and L. gasseri, with two 1-quart glass containers making about eight 1-cup servings a batch, a recipe ebook and an unlimited lifetime warranty.

  • For it
  • Built explicitly for long ferments, holding temperature up to 48 hours
  • The only pick naming the cultures it is designed for, L. reuteri and L. gasseri
  • Two 1-quart glass containers, about eight 1-cup servings per batch
  • An unlimited lifetime warranty, the only warranty in this pool
  • Against it
  • Publishes no temperature range, only that the temperature is adjustable
  • Publishes no display, no auto shut-off and no strainer
  • Publishes no dishwasher statement for its glass containers
4 Best for straining Greek yogurt in the machine

Bear Yogurt Maker

The only pick supplying a strainer, a 100-mesh food-safe one for turning plain yogurt into Greek, alongside a 304 stainless inner pot, a microcomputer timer up to 14 hours, an LED display, auto shut-off with a buzzer and dishwasher-safe containers.

  • For it
  • The only strainer supplied, a 100-mesh food-safe Greek yogurt strainer
  • A 304 stainless steel inner pot rather than plastic or glass alone
  • Makes cheese, kefir, fruit wine and plant-based yogurt as well as dairy
  • An LED display, a one-touch button and auto shut-off with a buzzer
  • Against it
  • Its timer runs to 14 hours, far short of the 48 on three rivals
  • Publishes no temperature range, only that temperature is constant per function
  • Its dimension fields are millimeters sitting in inch fields and are discarded
5 Best for a switch and nothing to program

Euro Cuisine YM80 Electric Yogurt Maker Machine- Pro...

The simplest machine here: an on and off switch, an indicating light, a time reminder and a transparent lid, with seven 6 ounce glass jars and BPA-free lids so seven different yogurts can be made and then stored in the refrigerator in the same jars.

  • For it
  • Seven 6 ounce glass jars, so seven different yogurts in one run
  • BPA-free lids for airtight storage in the refrigerator
  • A transparent lid and an indicating light, with a plain on and off switch
  • Publishes its size, 9.5 by 9.5 by 5.75 inches, and its weight, 4.0 pounds
  • Against it
  • Publishes no temperature range at all
  • Publishes a time reminder rather than a timer, with no hour figure
  • No digital display, no auto shut-off and no strainer

Our verdict

GDOR publishes the widest stated range, 68 to 131 degrees Fahrenheit, with a 48 hour timer, 8 glass jars and a stainless body. cewajbaa publishes 68 to 127 across the same 48 hours and 8 jars, with a clear cover. Ultimate holds temperature for 48 hours in two 1-quart containers and names the cultures it is for. Bear includes a 100-mesh Greek strainer. Euro Cuisine has seven jars and a switch.

“Three of these never publish a temperature at all.”

Lush Editorial Team

What separates these five

Temperature, published twice GDOR states 68 to 131 degrees Fahrenheit and cewajbaa 68 to 127. Ultimate, Bear and Euro Cuisine publish no range at all, though all three describe holding a steady temperature.
Timers from 14 hours to 48 GDOR and cewajbaa publish 48 hour timers and Ultimate a 48 hour hold. Bear's microcomputer runs to 14 hours. Euro Cuisine publishes a time reminder and no figure.
Jars against quarts GDOR and cewajbaa supply 8 glass jars of 6 ounces, Euro Cuisine seven. Ultimate supplies two 1-quart containers and Bear two of 1 quart plus a 304 stainless inner pot.
Only one strainer in the box Bear includes a 100-mesh Greek yogurt strainer and states the whey is strained by hand. Euro Cuisine tells you to strain to your own thickness. The other three do not mention it.
Displays and shut-off GDOR and cewajbaa publish digital or LED displays, Bear an LED with a buzzer and auto shut-off. Ultimate publishes neither, and Euro Cuisine offers an indicating light and a switch.

How we chose

Priorities, not a computed score. The inputs are published specifications, so we rank by what matters most and say how much.

  1. 30% The temperature it will holdFermentation is a temperature problem before it is anything else, and only two of these five publish a range, 68 to 127 degrees Fahrenheit and 68 to 131, while three publish none.
  2. 25% How long the timer runsA 36 hour reuteri ferment needs a machine that runs past a day, and the published timers here are 48 hours, 48 hours, a 48 hour hold, 14 hours, and on one pick no figure at all.
  3. 20% Jars or a bulk containerEight 6 ounce jars make eight flavors and four pounds of washing up; two 1-quart containers make a week of breakfasts in one go. The arrangement decides how the machine gets used.
  4. 15% Getting to Greek yogurtStraining is what turns yogurt into Greek yogurt, and one machine supplies a 100-mesh strainer, one tells you to strain it yourself, and three leave the subject alone entirely.
  5. 10% Display, shut-off and warrantyA readout of the set temperature, an automatic shut-off at the end of a 48 hour run, and a warranty are the differences that show up on day one and in year three.

How the Five Compare on the Numbers

Six yogurt makers were in this pool and one is not here. Party Desserts publishes two 2-liter inner buckets in its bullets and 2 quarts in its own title, which are different volumes, and then publishes no temperature, no timer figure and no dimensions. It includes a strainer, as Bear does, and there is nothing else on the listing to compare.

Among the five that remain, the split is not features but candor about heat. Fermentation is a temperature problem: too cool and nothing sets, too warm and the culture dies. Two listings publish the range their machine will hold. The other three, including the one designed specifically for 36 hour ferments, describe a steady temperature and never say what it is.

Specification GDOR cewajbaa Ultimate Bear Euro Cuisine
Temperature range stated 68 to 131 F 68 to 127 F not published Constant per function, no figure not published
Timer stated Up to 48 hours Up to 48 hours Holds temperature up to 48 hours Up to 14 hours Time reminder, no figure
Containers supplied 8 glass jars of 6 oz 8 glass jars of 6 oz Two 1-quart glass containers 2 glass containers of 1 Qt Seven glass jars of 6 oz
Inner pot stated not published not published not published 304 stainless steel not published
Batch volume stated not published not published 2 quarts, about eight 1-cup servings 2 by 33.8 oz, in the size field not published
Display Digital display LED display and clear top cover not published LED display, one-touch button Indicating light, transparent lid
Auto shut-off Yes not published not published Yes, with a buzzer not published
Strainer included not published not published not published Yes, 100-mesh No, strain it yourself
Body material stated Stainless steel not published not published Stainless inner pot not published
Other ferments named not published not published L. reuteri, L. gasseri Greek, cheese, fruit wine, kefir, plant-based Dairy and vegan, Greek by straining
Dishwasher stated not published Jars, dishwasher safe not published All containers, dishwasher safe Easy to clean, no method given
Warranty stated not published not published Unlimited lifetime not published not published
Published weight not published 4.21 lb 4.45 lb 3.5 lb 4.0 lb
Dimension fields not published not published 7.6 by 14.37 by 5.71 in Millimeters in inch fields, discarded 9.5 by 9.5 by 5.75 in
Size in the maker’s words not published not published not published 7.6 by 7.6 by 7.3 in not published

What the table cannot tell you is what any of these cost to run. No listing publishes a wattage, and a machine holding 110 degrees for 48 hours is drawing power the whole time. Nor does any listing publish a temperature accuracy or a variation figure, which on a culture that dies a few degrees too warm is the specification that separates a good machine from a lucky one.

The Temperature Nobody Has to Publish

Two Ranges, Four Degrees Apart

GDOR publishes 68 to 131 degrees Fahrenheit and cewajbaa 68 to 127. Both start in the same place, which is cool enough for a slow culture, and GDOR’s ceiling is 4 degrees higher. Both pair the range with a 48 hour timer and a readout showing the set values, which is what makes the range usable rather than decorative.

That pairing is the point. A range without a display means guessing, and a display without a range means reading a number you cannot interpret. These two listings are the only ones in the pool that publish both, and cewajbaa adds a clear top cover so the set can be judged by eye as well.

Three Machines That Promise Steadiness

Ultimate is the most interesting omission. Its whole listing is built on temperature stability, stating that long low-temperature ferments are where delicate cultures get ruined and that its TruTemp system holds a steady temperature for up to 48 hours, exactly the conditions for a 36 hour L. reuteri ferment. It never publishes what that temperature is or what it can be set to.

Bear states the temperature is constant for each function automatically, which means the machine chooses rather than you. Euro Cuisine publishes no temperature information at all, offering an on and off switch, an indicating light and a time reminder. All three may hold temperature perfectly well; none of the three lets you check.

Jars, Quarts and How You Will Eat It

Eight Small Jars

GDOR and cewajbaa each supply 8 BPA-free glass jars of 6 ounces, and Euro Cuisine seven of the same size. The argument is variety: each jar can take a different milk, a different starter or a different flavor in one run, and each one goes into the refrigerator with its own lid rather than being decanted.

The cost is washing up and portion size. Six ounces is a single serving, so a family eating yogurt daily will run the machine often, and eight jars plus eight lids go through the sink each time. cewajbaa and Bear both state their containers are dishwasher safe; GDOR and Euro Cuisine do not.

Two Quarts at Once

Ultimate goes the other way, with two 1-quart glass containers making about eight 1-cup servings per batch, which is a week of breakfasts in one run and two containers to wash. It also states you can use one ounce of each batch to start the next, which is how a long culture is kept going without buying starter again.

Bear supplies two 1 quart glass containers as well, plus a 304 stainless inner pot for the machine itself, which is the only stainless cooking surface in this pool. Its size field describes the containers as 2 by 33.8 ounces where its bullet says 1 quart each, two ways of saying nearly the same thing.

Greek Yogurt, Other Ferments and the Figures That Fail

Straining Is a Separate Job

Bear is the only machine here that ships a strainer, a 100-mesh food-safe one, and its listing is honest about what happens next: you will need to use the strainer and manually strain the whey out to turn plain yogurt into Greek. That is an accurate description of the process and the only mention of mesh size in the pool.

Euro Cuisine says the same thing without supplying anything, suggesting you simply strain to your desired thickness. GDOR frames thickness as a function of temperature and time rather than of straining, which is partly true and does not replace a cloth. Ultimate and cewajbaa do not raise the subject.

What Else Goes in the Pot

Bear publishes the widest set of uses: Greek yogurt, cheese, fruit wine, kefir, plant-based yogurt and enzymes, with the choice of fermentation agent left to you. That versatility is the reason for the 304 stainless pot and the 14 hour microcomputer timer, which suits an overnight ferment rather than a two day one.

Ultimate is specific in a different way, naming L. reuteri and L. gasseri and the 36 hour ferment those cultures need. Those two listings describe opposite machines: one that does many fermentations for less time, and one that does a single fermentation for longer than anything else here.

Where the Published Sizes Break Down

Bear’s dimension fields read 76.38 by 76.38 by 72.83 inches, which would be a walk-in cupboard. Its own bullet gives 7.6 by 7.6 by 7.3 inches, so the fields are millimeters in the wrong unit, and even read as millimeters they come out near 3 inches, which is too small. The maker’s sentence is the figure used here.

Euro Cuisine and Ultimate are the only two picks whose fields describe plausible machines, 9.5 by 9.5 by 5.75 inches and 7.6 by 14.37 by 5.71. GDOR and cewajbaa publish no dimensions at all, and GDOR publishes no weight either, so on that pick nothing about the physical object is stated.

Which One Fits Your Kitchen

Anyone who wants to control the ferment. GDOR publishes 68 to 131 degrees Fahrenheit, a 48 hour timer, a digital display, auto shut-off and a stainless steel body across 8 BPA-free glass jars of 6 ounces. It publishes no weight, no dimensions and no strainer.

A cook who judges yogurt by eye. cewajbaa pairs 68 to 127 degrees Fahrenheit and a 48 hour timer with an LED display of both values and a clear top cover, across 8 dishwasher-safe 6 ounce glass jars, at 4.21 pounds.

A long culture kept going for months. Ultimate holds temperature for up to 48 hours, names L. reuteri and L. gasseri, makes 2 quarts in two 1-quart glass containers, includes a recipe ebook and carries an unlimited lifetime warranty. It never publishes the temperature itself.

A kitchen that ferments more than yogurt. Bear has a 304 stainless inner pot, a 100-mesh Greek strainer, a 14 hour timer, an LED display, auto shut-off with a buzzer and dishwasher-safe containers, and also makes cheese, kefir and fruit wine at 3.5 pounds.

Someone who wants one switch. Euro Cuisine has an on and off switch, an indicating light, a time reminder and a transparent lid, with seven 6 ounce glass jars and BPA-free lids, at 9.5 by 9.5 by 5.75 inches and 4.0 pounds. It publishes no temperature at all.

What We Could Not Verify

Every figure above comes from the makers’ own listings. These are the things we went looking for and could not source.

  • Three of the five publish no temperature range, including the one built around 36 hour ferments.
  • No listing publishes a wattage, so the cost of holding temperature for 48 hours is unknown.
  • No listing publishes a temperature accuracy or variation figure.
  • Bear’s dimension fields are in the wrong unit, leaving only its own 7.6 by 7.6 by 7.3 inches usable.
  • GDOR publishes no weight and no dimensions, and cewajbaa publishes no dimensions.
  • Only Ultimate publishes a batch volume in quarts and servings, and only it publishes a warranty.

Frequently asked questions

Which of these lets me set the temperature?+

Two. GDOR publishes an adjustable range of 68 to 131 degrees Fahrenheit and cewajbaa 68 to 127, both alongside timers up to 48 hours and a digital readout. Ultimate states its TruTemp system holds the right temperature for up to 48 hours without publishing what that temperature is. Bear states the temperature is constant for each function automatically, and Euro Cuisine publishes no temperature information at all.

Can any of these do a 36 hour ferment?+

Three can on the published figures. Ultimate is built around it, stating it holds a steady temperature for up to 48 hours and naming the 36 hour L. reuteri ferment directly. GDOR and cewajbaa both publish 48 hour timers, so both cover it too. Bear's microcomputer timer runs to 14 hours, which is short of a long culture, and Euro Cuisine publishes a time reminder rather than a timer.

Jars or one big container?+

It depends how you eat it. GDOR and cewajbaa each supply 8 glass jars of 6 ounces and Euro Cuisine seven, so each jar can take a different milk or flavor and then go straight into the refrigerator. Ultimate supplies two 1-quart glass containers, about eight 1-cup servings per batch, and Bear two 1 quart containers plus a stainless inner pot for larger single batches.

How do I get Greek yogurt out of these?+

By straining, and only one machine helps. Bear includes a 100-mesh food-safe Greek yogurt strainer and states plainly that you strain the whey out by hand once the yogurt is set. Euro Cuisine says the same thing without supplying anything, telling you to strain to your desired thickness. GDOR mentions a Greek-style texture through temperature and time rather than through straining.

What else can they ferment?+

Bear publishes the longest list: Greek yogurt, cheese, fruit wine, kefir, plant-based yogurt and enzymes, with fermentation agents and dairy or non-dairy bases. Ultimate names specific cultures instead, L. reuteri and L. gasseri, which is a different kind of specificity. Euro Cuisine names dairy and vegan yogurt. GDOR and cewajbaa describe yogurt only, though cewajbaa notes its settings suit most types.

Which figures here should be treated carefully?+

Bear's dimensions. Its fields read 76.38 by 76.38 by 72.83 inches, which is a room rather than an appliance, and its own bullet states 7.6 by 7.6 by 7.3 inches. Read as millimeters the fields would be about 3 inches, which is too small, so the maker's own sentence is the figure used here. Its size field also gives its containers as 2 by 33.8 ounces where its bullet says 1 quart each.

Specifications come from the manufacturers' own published listings. Lush Food & Drink may earn a commission if you buy through a link on this page, at no extra cost to you. How we research.