Explainer
Can a smoker be used as a dehydrator?
A smoker can dry food, but no offset smoker on this site's list publishes the low, steady temperature range a dehydrator is built to hold, so it is a drying tool of a different kind.
By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared
A smoker can be used to dry food, but it is not a dehydrator. The offset smokers this site has compared publish no low, steady temperature range for drying, while the dehydrators on this site’s list publish thermostats that hold between 85°F and 195°F depending on the model.
The difference is control. A dehydrator is built to sit at one low temperature for hours with a timer and an automatic shutoff. An offset smoker is built to burn charcoal and wood splits and to hold a cooking temperature for barbecue, and its makers describe it in those terms. Drying in a smoker means managing a fire to keep heat low and airflow constant, which is a different job from setting a dial.
What dehydrator makers publish about heat and time
The Best Food Dehydrators for Jerky, Herbs and Big Harvests guide lists five machines, and each one publishes a temperature range and a timer. The HOPERAN 16-Tray Stainless Steel Food Dehydrator runs from 85°F to 195°F with a timer of 1 to 24 hours in 30 minute steps, and it powers off when the cycle ends. The Magic Mill Pro runs from 95°F to 176°F in 1 degree increments with a timer up to 48 hours in 30 minute steps.
The Cosori Food Dehydrator also runs from 95°F to 176°F in 1°F increments, and its listing notes that the USDA recommends 165°F for safe jerky. The FOHERE Food Dehydrator runs from 95°F to 158°F with a timer of 0 to 48 hours. The PSIIDAN 8-Tray machine publishes a timer from 30 minutes to 48 hours and a temperature up to 167°F, with no lower bound stated.
Those figures describe a machine whose whole purpose is a long, low, unattended hold. The bottom of the range matters as much as the top: herbs and thin slices want the low end, and jerky wants the higher end. A dehydrator maker publishes both ends because the buyer sets one number and walks away.
What offset smoker makers publish about temperature
The Best Offset Smokers for Long Low Temperature Cooks guide lists five products, and none of them publishes a thermostat range. The Oklahoma Joe’s Longhorn Reverse Flow Offset Charcoal Smoker and Grill publishes a professional temperature gauge to track cooking temperature, four baffles under the grates to spread heat and smoke, and a large charcoal basket for a steady burn. A gauge tells you what the chamber is doing. It does not hold a number for you.
The Dyna-Glo DGO1890BDC-D Wide Body Vertical Offset Charcoal Smoker publishes a built-in stainless steel thermometer with a Smoke Zone marking the ideal temperature for infusing smoke flavor, plus an adjustable flue on the smoke stack for temperature control. The Royal Gourmet CC1830SC publishes a lid-mounted thermometer gauge and a two-level height-adjustable charcoal pan that holds up to 4.4 lbs. of coal. The PayLessHere 43-inch Charcoal Outdoor BBQ Grill publishes a temperature controller that shows the heat inside the furnace.
Read those bullets to the end and the pattern holds: every temperature feature on the smoker list is a way to read or adjust heat, not a way to set and forget it. No maker on that list publishes a drying range, a drying timer, or an automatic shutoff for dehydration.
Where the two appliances overlap
The overlap is the low end of the dehydrator range and the smoke zone of a smoker. A dehydrator that bottoms out at 85°F or 95°F is running cool, and a smoker held in its smoke zone is also running cool by barbecue standards. Both move air across food for hours. Both remove moisture. That is why the question gets asked, and it is a fair question.
The difference is what happens when conditions drift. The HOPERAN, Magic Mill, Cosori, FOHERE and PSIIDAN machines each publish a digital control and an automatic shutoff or overheat protection, so a drift gets corrected or the machine stops. The smoker makers publish gauges, baffles, flues and adjustable pans, which are tools for a person standing nearby. The Oklahoma Joe’s Longhorn publishes a firebox door for loading fuel without opening the main chamber, and the Dyna-Glo publishes a charcoal and ash management system with a sliding steel ash pan. Both are about tending a fire, not about leaving one alone.
What drying in a smoker actually asks of you
If you dry food in an offset smoker, you are running a small fire for a long time and watching a gauge. The Royal Gourmet pan holds up to 4.4 lbs. of coal, and the Dyna-Glo publishes 1890 square inches of total cooking space across six height-adjustable grates with a 25 pound capacity per grate. That is a lot of chamber to keep at one low number with a charcoal fire, and the maker gives you a flue and a pan height to work with rather than a dial.
Smoke is the other variable. A dehydrator moves hot air; a smoker moves hot air and smoke, and the smoke is the point of the appliance. Food dried in a smoker will take on smoke flavor, which suits jerky and does not suit delicate herbs or fruit leather. The dehydrator guide’s picks ship with mesh screens and fruit roll sheets for exactly those jobs, and the smoker list’s only accessory item, the UNCO Grill Gasket, is a 1/2 inch by 1/8 inch by 15 ft seal rated to 500°F for stopping smoke leaks around a door. It seals a smoker. It does not turn one into a dehydrator.
The practical answer
Use a smoker when you want smoke and are willing to tend a fire and watch a gauge. Use a dehydrator when you want a set temperature, a timer and a shutoff. The machines on the dehydrator list publish all three, from the HOPERAN’s 85°F to 195°F range and 1 to 24 hour timer to the Magic Mill’s 48 hour timer and 95°F Keep Warm hold. The smokers on the other list publish gauges, baffles and flues.
One more figure worth knowing: the dehydrator guide’s picks are countertop appliances, and the Cosori publishes dimensions of 13.9 by 11.3 by 8.9 inches with 3.1 square feet of drying space across five trays. The smallest smoker on the other list, the PayLessHere, publishes 43 by 24 by 44 inches. A dehydrator fits under a cabinet. A smoker lives outdoors, which is also where a long, low, smoky fire belongs.
Common questions
Do offset smokers have a thermostat?
No maker on this site's offset smoker list publishes a thermostat range. The Oklahoma Joe's Longhorn publishes a temperature gauge, the Dyna-Glo publishes a built-in thermometer with a Smoke Zone and an adjustable flue, the Royal Gourmet publishes a lid-mounted gauge and a height-adjustable charcoal pan, and the PayLessHere publishes a temperature controller that shows the heat inside. Each is a way to read or adjust heat, not to set a number and leave it.
What temperature do dehydrators hold?
The five picks publish different ranges. The HOPERAN runs from 85°F to 195°F, the Magic Mill Pro and the Cosori run from 95°F to 176°F, the FOHERE runs from 95°F to 158°F, and the PSIIDAN publishes a top of 167°F with no lower bound stated. Each maker pairs the range with a timer, from 1 to 24 hours on the HOPERAN up to 48 hours on the Magic Mill and FOHERE.
Can I make jerky in a smoker?
You can dry meat in a smoker, and the smoke flavor suits jerky. The difference is control. The Cosori listing notes that the USDA recommends 165°F for safe jerky, and the Cosori, Magic Mill and PSIIDAN machines publish top temperatures at or above that figure with a timer and automatic shutoff. A smoker maker publishes a gauge and a flue, so you hold the temperature yourself for the whole run.
Will food dried in a smoker taste smoky?
Yes, and that is the point of the appliance. A smoker moves hot air and smoke across the food, and the Dyna-Glo listing describes a Smoke Zone for infusing smoke flavor. A dehydrator moves hot air only. For herbs, fruit leather and delicate slices, the dehydrator guide's picks include mesh screens and fruit roll sheets so the food dries without picking up smoke.
Does a smoker need a seal to hold low temperatures?
The UNCO Grill Gasket on the smoker list is a 1/2 inch by 1/8 inch by 15 ft seal rated to 500°F, and its listing states that it seals the gap around a grill door to keep smoke in and heat from escaping. A tighter door helps any low, slow cook. It does not add a thermostat, a timer or a shutoff, so the fire still needs watching.
How much space does a dehydrator take compared with a smoker?
The Cosori publishes dimensions of 13.9 by 11.3 by 8.9 inches and 3.1 square feet of drying space across five trays. The PayLessHere smoker publishes 43 by 24 by 44 inches, and the Dyna-Glo publishes 21 by 43.3 by 50.2 inches. A dehydrator sits on a counter. A smoker takes up outdoor floor space and runs on charcoal.
Ready to compare actual models?
Our buying guides put five products side by side on the numbers their makers publish.