Lush Food & Drink

Explainer

Can a sandwich maker be used to make waffles?

A standard sandwich maker cannot make proper waffles, because its flat or shallow triangular plates do not have the deep waffle grid, so batter would cook into a flat shape; only a combination machine with swappable waffle plates, or a dedicated waffle maker, makes real waffles.

By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared

A standard sandwich maker cannot make proper waffles, because its plates are flat or shallow and shaped for pressing sandwiches, not with the deep ridged grid that gives a waffle its pockets. If you poured waffle batter into a plain sandwich maker, it would cook into a flat, sandwich shaped piece rather than a real waffle, lacking the deep pockets and crisp ridges. The only way a sandwich maker makes waffles is if it is a combination machine with swappable plates that include waffle plates, which many are. Otherwise, you need a dedicated waffle maker. So the answer depends on whether your machine has interchangeable waffle plates. The waffle makers in our best waffle makers guide have the proper deep plates a sandwich maker lacks.

It comes down to the plates

The difference between a sandwich maker and a waffle maker is the plates, and that is why a sandwich maker cannot make waffles. A sandwich maker, or toastie maker, has flat plates, or shallow ridged plates often shaped to seal a sandwich into triangles, designed to press and toast bread. A waffle maker has deep, ridged plates patterned with the grid of square pockets that shape and crisp waffle batter. These are quite different shapes for different jobs, so a sandwich maker’s plates simply cannot form a waffle, and a waffle maker’s deep plates would not press a flat sandwich well either. The plate shape is everything.

What batter would do in a sandwich maker

If you put waffle batter into a plain sandwich maker, the batter would spread across the flat or shallow plates and cook into a flat, pressed piece shaped like the sandwich plates, not a waffle. It would be cooked batter, but without the deep pockets, the crisp ridged texture, or the characteristic waffle form, more like a flat pancake or a batter toastie than a waffle. Any shallow ridges might leave a faint pattern, but nothing like a real waffle’s deep grid. So while the batter would cook, the result would not be a waffle in any meaningful sense, which is why a sandwich maker is not a substitute for a waffle maker.

Combination machines with waffle plates

The exception is a combination machine, often sold as a sandwich maker, grill, and waffle maker in one, that comes with interchangeable plates. These include a set of deep waffle plates you clip in, in place of the sandwich plates, to make real waffles, as well as flat or grill plates for sandwiches and grilling. If your sandwich maker is one of these multi plate machines and you have the waffle plates, then yes, it makes proper waffles, because you are fitting actual waffle plates. So the question really is whether your machine has swappable waffle plates: if so it makes waffles with them, and if not, it cannot.

Check what you have

So to know whether your sandwich maker can make waffles, check whether it is a fixed plate sandwich maker or a combination machine with interchangeable plates. A plain sandwich maker with fixed flat or triangular plates cannot make waffles, and no amount of batter will change that. A combination machine that came with, or offers, deep waffle plates can make waffles once you fit them. If you are unsure, look at whether the plates come out and whether waffle plates were included or are available for your model. If you only have sandwich plates, you would need either waffle plates for a combo machine or a separate waffle maker.

The short answer

So a standard sandwich maker cannot make proper waffles, because its flat or shallow triangular plates lack the deep ridged grid that gives a waffle its pockets, so batter would cook into a flat, sandwich shaped piece rather than a real waffle. The only way to make waffles in a sandwich maker is if it is a combination machine with swappable plates that include deep waffle plates, which you fit in place of the sandwich plates. Otherwise you need a dedicated waffle maker. So check whether your machine has interchangeable waffle plates: with them it makes waffles, without them it cannot.

If you want both sandwiches and waffles

If you would like one appliance that makes both toasted sandwiches and waffles, the answer is a combination machine with interchangeable plates rather than a plain sandwich maker. These are widely sold, often as a three in one that includes sandwich plates, flat grill plates, and deep waffle plates, so you clip in whichever you need. With the waffle plates fitted you get real waffles, and with the sandwich plates you get toasties, from the same base unit. This is the sensible route if counter space or budget means you want a single machine for both jobs, and it avoids the disappointment of trying to force waffle batter into a fixed sandwich maker. So rather than asking a sandwich maker to do a waffle maker’s job, choose a combination model made to do both, or keep a dedicated waffle maker alongside your sandwich maker if you prefer each as a specialist.

Common questions

Can a sandwich maker make waffles?

A standard one cannot, because its flat or shallow triangular plates are shaped for pressing sandwiches, not with the deep ridged grid a waffle needs, so batter would cook into a flat, sandwich shaped piece rather than a real waffle. The only exception is a combination machine with swappable plates that include deep waffle plates, which you fit to make waffles. Otherwise you need a dedicated waffle maker.

What happens if you put waffle batter in a sandwich maker?

It would spread across the flat or shallow plates and cook into a flat, pressed piece shaped like the sandwich plates, more like a flat pancake or a batter toastie than a waffle, without the deep pockets or crisp ridged texture of a real waffle. Any shallow ridges might leave a faint pattern, but nothing like a waffle's deep grid. So the batter cooks, but the result is not a waffle.

Why can't a sandwich maker make proper waffles?

Because of the plates. A sandwich maker has flat or shallow plates shaped to press and seal sandwiches, while a waffle maker has deep, ridged plates with the grid of pockets that shape and crisp waffle batter. These are different shapes for different jobs, so a sandwich maker's plates cannot form a waffle. The plate shape is what makes a waffle, and a sandwich maker simply does not have it.

Can a combination sandwich and waffle maker make real waffles?

Yes. A combination machine with interchangeable plates, often sold as a sandwich, grill, and waffle maker in one, comes with deep waffle plates you clip in place of the sandwich plates, and with those fitted it makes proper waffles. So if your machine has swappable waffle plates, it makes real waffles with them. It is only a plain, fixed plate sandwich maker that cannot, lacking the deep waffle plates.

How do I know if my sandwich maker can make waffles?

Check whether it is a plain fixed plate sandwich maker or a combination machine with interchangeable plates. If the plates come out and deep waffle plates were included or are available for your model, it can make waffles once you fit them. If it has fixed flat or triangular plates only, it cannot, and you would need a separate waffle maker. So look at whether your machine takes swappable waffle plates.

Ready to compare actual models?

Our buying guide puts five products side by side on the numbers their makers publish.

More questions about waffle makers