Explainer
Can a sandwich maker cook an egg?
Yes, a sandwich maker cooks eggs well in its hot plates, from a flat egg for a sandwich to scrambled in a heatproof dish, as long as you grease it and watch the short cook time.
By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared
Yes, a sandwich maker cooks eggs perfectly well, because it is really two hot plates pressed together, and that is all a cooked egg needs. You can crack an egg straight onto the plates for a flat, folded egg to go in a sandwich, or cook scrambled or whisked eggs in a small heatproof dish set on the plates. The main things to get right are greasing the plates, keeping the egg contained, and not overcooking it, since a sandwich maker is hotter and faster than it looks. Our Best Sandwich Makers compares the published figures of five of them.
Why it works
A sandwich maker heats both plates to a cooking temperature and closes them around the food, so an egg between them cooks from both sides at once, faster than a pan where only the bottom is heated. The nonstick plates most machines have are well suited to eggs, which stick easily, and the enclosed design keeps the heat in so the egg sets quickly.
That two-sided heat is why a sandwich maker egg cooks in a couple of minutes rather than the several a pan takes. It is the same reason the machine toasts a sandwich quickly, applied to an egg, and it is why eggs are one of the most common things people cook in a sandwich maker beyond actual sandwiches.
Cooking a flat egg
For a flat egg to layer into a sandwich or a muffin, grease the bottom plate lightly, crack the egg straight onto it, and pierce the yolk if you want it cooked through rather than runny. Close the lid gently, because pressing hard squeezes the white out of the sides before it sets. In a minute or two the egg sets into a flat round shaped by the plate, ready to fold or cut.
A whisked egg poured onto the plate gives a more even flat omelette-style round, which is tidier for a sandwich. Either way, the egg takes the shape of the plate’s cooking surface, so a machine with flat plates gives a flat egg and one with shaped pockets gives a shaped one, which is worth knowing if you are making eggs for a specific bread.
Scrambled and other styles in a dish
For scrambled eggs, or to stop a runny egg escaping, cook the egg in a small heatproof dish or silicone mold that sits on the plate rather than directly on it. Whisk the egg in the dish, set it on the lower plate, and close the lid to heat it from above as well. Stir once partway if you want a soft scramble, and the enclosed heat cooks it quickly.
A dish also lets you make a contained omelette with fillings, or a baked egg, without any of it running into the hinge. The dish has to be heatproof and small enough that the lid still closes over it, even if only partway, and silicone molds made for this are the easiest option because they flex out of the machine and wash easily.
The pitfalls to avoid
The two mistakes are overflow and overcooking. A raw egg is liquid, and if you crack it onto the plates and close the lid firmly, the white runs into the hinge and the edges before it sets, which is both wasteful and a cleaning problem, since set egg in the hinge is hard to reach. Closing the lid gently, or using a dish, prevents it.
Overcooking is the other, because the two-sided heat works fast and an egg left even a minute too long turns rubbery and dry. Check it early, after a minute or so, rather than setting it and walking away. And grease the plates even if they are nonstick, because egg is the food most likely to find a worn spot in the coating and stick there.
The short answer
A sandwich maker cooks eggs well and quickly, using its two hot plates to set an egg from both sides at once. Crack one straight onto a greased plate for a flat egg, or cook scrambled and filled eggs in a small heatproof dish on the plate to contain them. Close the lid gently so raw white does not escape, grease the plates even if nonstick, and check the egg after a minute because the enclosed heat cooks faster than a pan and overcooks just as fast.
Common questions
Can you cook an egg in a sandwich maker?
Yes. It is two hot plates that close around the food, so an egg cooks from both sides at once, faster than in a pan. Crack one onto a greased plate for a flat egg, or cook scrambled eggs in a small heatproof dish on the plate. Grease it, close gently, and watch the short cook time.
How do I cook a flat egg for a sandwich?
Grease the bottom plate, crack the egg onto it, and pierce the yolk if you want it set through. Close the lid gently, because pressing hard squeezes the white out before it sets. In a minute or two the egg sets into a flat round shaped by the plate, ready to fold into a sandwich.
Can a sandwich maker do scrambled eggs?
Yes, cooked in a small heatproof dish or silicone mold set on the plate rather than directly on it, so the liquid egg is contained. Whisk the egg in the dish, close the lid to heat it from above too, and stir once partway for a soft scramble. The enclosed heat cooks it quickly.
How do I stop the egg running into the hinge?
Close the lid gently rather than pressing it, so the white sets before it spreads, or cook the egg in a small heatproof dish that contains it. A raw egg is liquid and a firm press squeezes it into the hinge and edges before it cooks, which wastes it and is hard to clean.
Why did my egg come out rubbery?
It was overcooked. A sandwich maker heats from both sides, so it cooks an egg in a couple of minutes and overcooks it just as fast, turning it dry and rubbery if left too long. Check it after about a minute rather than setting it and walking away, and take it out as soon as it is set.
Ready to compare actual models?
Our buying guides put five products side by side on the numbers their makers publish.