Lush Food & Drink

Explainer

How to use a sandwich maker in different ways

Beyond toasties, the hot plates of a sandwich maker will cook omelettes, small cakes and brownies, hash browns, quesadillas, French toast, and more, treating the machine as a compact two-sided hot plate.

By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared

A sandwich maker is more versatile than its name suggests, because at heart it is just two hot, non-stick plates that press and cook from both sides. Once you think of it that way, you can use it for far more than toasties: omelettes and mini frittatas, small cakes and brownies, hash browns, quesadillas, French toast, grilled vegetables and even cookies all cook in it. The trick is to treat the machine as a compact two-sided griddle and adapt what you put in it to its shape and heat. Our Best Sandwich Makers compares the published figures of five of them.

Think of it as two hot plates

The key to using a sandwich maker in different ways is to stop thinking of it as a sandwich-only gadget and see it as what it physically is: two heated non-stick plates that close together. That means it can cook anything that suits a hot, enclosed, two-sided surface and fits in the plate pockets, heating food from top and bottom at once without you flipping it.

The pocketed or ridged shape of the plates does influence what works, since it portions food into the pocket shapes, but that is often an advantage, giving neat individual portions. Within those limits, batters, eggs, breads and fillings all cook happily. Recognising the machine as a small press-grill is what unlocks every other use, so that is the starting point.

Eggs, omelettes and breakfast

Eggs are one of the best alternative uses. Pour beaten egg with your fillings into the warm, lightly greased plates and close the lid, and you get a quick omelette or egg pocket cooked on both sides, ready in a couple of minutes. The pockets shape the egg into tidy portions, which is handy for serving.

Breakfast more broadly suits the machine. French toast cooks well, with bread dipped in egg and pressed until golden, and hash browns crisp nicely between the hot plates. You can warm or lightly cook many breakfast items that benefit from a quick two-sided heat, turning the sandwich maker into a fast breakfast station beyond its toastie role.

Cakes, brownies and sweet treats

The sandwich maker also bakes small sweet things surprisingly well, because the enclosed hot plates work like a tiny oven for batter. Spoon cake or brownie batter into the greased pockets, close the lid, and in a few minutes you have individual little cakes or brownie bites shaped by the plates, with no oven needed.

Cookies, muffins in batter form, and other small bakes work on the same principle, cooking faster than a conventional oven because the heat presses directly onto the batter from both sides. Keep portions small so they cook through, and check them, as timings are shorter than you might expect. For a quick single serving of something sweet, this is one of the most popular off-label uses.

Savory meals and snacks

Beyond breakfast and baking, plenty of savory food works. Quesadillas press and melt beautifully between the plates, grilled vegetables soften and char-mark, and small portions of meat or halloumi cook through with the press helping them sear. You can also reheat and crisp leftovers like pizza slices that fit the plates.

The same rules apply throughout: grease the plates lightly if the food is not self-greasing, do not overfill so the lid can close and the food cooks evenly, and expect the pocket shapes to portion the result. Many of these foods cook faster than on a hob because of the two-sided contact, so watch them and lift the lid to check rather than relying on toastie timings.

What to keep in mind

A few cautions keep these uses safe and the machine in good order. Do not put metal utensils or foil inside, protect the non-stick plates by using wooden or silicone tools, and never overload the machine with so much batter or filling that it leaks out of the sides, which makes a mess and can reach the hinge. Let fillings that expand, like batters, have room to rise.

Clean the machine after these uses as you would after a sandwich, wiping the warm plates and avoiding immersion in water since the electrics are sealed inside. And remember the plate shape limits very liquid or very large items. Within those sensible limits, though, a sandwich maker genuinely doubles as a compact, fast cooker for a wide range of small meals and treats.

The short answer

To use a sandwich maker in different ways, treat it as two hot non-stick plates that cook from both sides, not just a toastie machine. It will make omelettes and egg pockets, French toast and hash browns, small cakes and brownies, cookies, quesadillas, grilled vegetables and more, all shaped by the plate pockets and cooked fast by the two-sided heat. Grease the plates, do not overfill, use wooden or silicone tools rather than metal, watch the shorter cooking times, and clean the warm plates afterward without immersing the machine. Within the limits of its size and shape, it is a versatile little press-grill.

Common questions

What else can you cook in a sandwich maker?

Plenty beyond toasties: omelettes and egg pockets, French toast, hash browns, small cakes and brownies, cookies, quesadillas, grilled vegetables and halloumi, and reheated pizza slices. The machine is really two hot non-stick plates that cook from both sides, so it handles anything that suits a quick, enclosed, two-sided heat and fits the plates.

Can you make cake in a sandwich maker?

Yes. The enclosed hot plates work like a tiny oven for batter. Spoon cake or brownie batter into greased pockets, close the lid, and in a few minutes you get individual little cakes or brownie bites shaped by the plates. They cook faster than a conventional oven because heat presses directly on the batter from both sides, so check them.

Can you cook eggs in a sandwich maker?

Yes, very well. Pour beaten egg with fillings into the warm, lightly greased plates and close the lid for a quick omelette or egg pocket cooked on both sides in a couple of minutes, with the pockets shaping it into tidy portions. French toast and other breakfast items work too, making it a fast breakfast station.

What should you avoid when using a sandwich maker for other foods?

Do not use metal utensils or foil inside, which damage the non-stick plates or arc; use wooden or silicone tools. Do not overfill with batter or filling that leaks out the sides into the hinge. Leave room for batters to rise, watch the shorter cooking times, and clean the warm plates afterward without immersing the machine in water.

Do foods cook faster in a sandwich maker?

Often yes, because the two hot plates press directly onto the food and cook it from both sides at once, unlike a hob that heats only the bottom. That means cakes, eggs and many items cook faster than you might expect, so use toastie timings only as a rough guide and lift the lid to check rather than overcooking.

Ready to compare actual models?

Our buying guide puts five products side by side on the numbers their makers publish.

More questions about sandwich makers