Explainer
How do you clean sandwich makers?
Unplug the sandwich maker and let it cool a little, then wipe the warm plates with a damp cloth or paper towel to lift melted cheese and crumbs, scrape stuck bits with a wooden or silicone tool, and wipe again. Wash removable plates separately if they come out, and never submerge the electrical body.
By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared
You clean a sandwich maker (toastie maker) by wiping the plates while they are still warm (after unplugging it), which lifts off melted cheese, grease and crumbs easily before they harden. Unplug the sandwich maker and let it cool for a few minutes so it is warm but safe to touch, then wipe the toasting plates with a damp cloth or paper towel to remove the grease, melted cheese and crumbs, scrape any stuck-on bits gently with a wooden or silicone spatula (never metal, which scratches the nonstick plates), and wipe again until clean. If your sandwich maker has removable plates, you can take them out and wash them in warm soapy water or, if they are dishwasher safe, in the dishwasher, which is easier. Crucially, never submerge the electrical body of the sandwich maker in water, clean the housing by wiping it with a damp cloth. So the key points are: clean while warm, use non-scratch tools, wash removable plates separately, and keep the electrical unit dry, which is essentially the same careful approach as cleaning a panini press. Our Best Sandwich Makers compares five of them.
Clean while warm (after unplugging)
The easiest way to clean a sandwich maker is while the plates are still warm, because melted cheese, grease and crumbs wipe off easily when warm but harden and stick when cold, so cleaning promptly after use (once it is safe) saves effort. First unplug the sandwich maker for safety, then let it cool for a few minutes so the plates are warm rather than hot, not so hot they burn you, but still warm enough that the residue is soft. This timing is the trick to easy cleaning, especially with sandwich makers that seal and cut toasties, where cheese often oozes out and sets.
Then wipe the warm plates with a damp cloth or paper towel (some people lay a damp paper towel over the closed plates briefly to let the steam loosen residue), removing the grease and softened cheese. Because the residue is still soft, it comes off with a wipe rather than needing scrubbing. So the core method is to unplug, let it cool to warm, and wipe the plates while the mess is still soft, which is quick and effective. Waiting until everything is cold and hardened makes it harder, so cleaning the sandwich maker soon after use, while warm, is the main thing that keeps it easy, which is why this timing is emphasized.
Dealing with stuck-on bits and the plate grooves
For any food stuck to the plates, especially melted cheese that has oozed out and set, remove it gently without damaging the plates (most sandwich-maker plates are nonstick). Scrape stuck-on bits with a wooden or silicone/plastic spatula or scraper, never a metal utensil or abrasive scourer, which would scratch and ruin the nonstick coating. Scraping while the plates are still warm makes stuck cheese come away more easily. For the ridges or the sealing/cutting edges of toastie plates (which press and seal the sandwich), where cheese and crumbs lodge, use the edge of a wooden tool, a soft brush or a cloth to get into them.
If something is stubbornly stuck and hardened, lay a warm, damp cloth or paper towel over it for a few minutes to soften it, then wipe or gently scrape it off, rather than forcing it. You can also wipe the plates with a cloth dampened with a little warm soapy water to cut grease, then wipe with a clean damp cloth to remove any soap. Avoid soaking the plates (on a fixed-plate sandwich maker) or using harsh abrasives. So stuck-on bits and the grooves are handled by gentle scraping with non-metal tools and softening with a warm damp cloth, keeping the nonstick plates intact, which deals with the melted-cheese and crumb messes that are the main cleaning challenge on a sandwich maker.
Removable plates and the electrical body
If your sandwich maker has removable plates, cleaning is easier: once it has cooled (or is warm), detach the plates and wash them separately in warm soapy water, or put them in the dishwasher if they are dishwasher safe (check the manual), then dry them and refit. Removable, washable plates let you clean them thoroughly like any pan, a big convenience, so use that if your sandwich maker has it. Handle the plates gently to protect the nonstick.
The electrical body of the sandwich maker, the hinged housing with the heating element and controls, must never be submerged in water or put in the dishwasher, because it contains the electrics. Clean the housing and any non-removable exterior by wiping it with a damp (not soaking) cloth, and dry it, keeping water away from the electrical parts and the power connection. For fixed-plate sandwich makers (where the plates do not come off, common on cheaper or sealed models), you clean the plates in place by wiping and scraping as above, again without submerging the unit. So the rule is: wash removable plates separately (sink or dishwasher), but only ever wipe the electrical body, never immerse it, which keeps the sandwich maker safe while getting the plates properly clean.
Keeping it clean and finishing up
A few habits keep a sandwich maker easy to clean. Clean it after each use (while warm) so residue does not build up and bake on over repeated uses, which would make it much harder to remove later. Wipe up any cheese or filling that oozes out onto the plates or counter promptly. You can lightly oil or butter the outside of the bread (as many toastie recipes do) which also helps the sandwich release and keeps the plates cleaner, and avoid overfilling sandwiches so less filling escapes. After cleaning, make sure the plates and sandwich maker are dry before storing, and store it closed to keep the plates clean.
So the full method is: unplug the sandwich maker, let it cool to warm, wipe the plates with a damp cloth or paper towel to lift the cheese and grease, gently scrape stuck-on bits with a wooden or silicone tool (softening stubborn spots with a warm damp cloth, and getting into the grooves/sealing edges), wash removable plates in soapy water or the dishwasher, wipe the electrical body without submerging it, and dry everything. Clean it promptly after each use to keep it easy. Done this way, a sandwich maker cleans up quickly and its nonstick plates stay in good condition, so the main things to remember are to clean while warm, use non-scratch tools, and never immerse the electrical unit.
The short answer
Clean a sandwich maker by wiping the plates while they are still warm, after unplugging it. Unplug the sandwich maker and let it cool for a few minutes so the plates are warm but safe to touch, then wipe them with a damp cloth or paper towel to lift the melted cheese, grease and crumbs, which come off easily while still soft (laying a damp paper towel over the closed plates briefly helps loosen residue with steam). Gently scrape any stuck-on bits, especially set cheese that has oozed out, with a wooden or silicone spatula, never metal or abrasive scourers, which would scratch the nonstick plates, and get into the grooves and sealing edges with a soft brush or the edge of a wooden tool, softening stubborn spots with a warm damp cloth. For sandwich makers with removable plates, take them out and wash them in warm soapy water or the dishwasher if dishwasher safe, which is easier. Never submerge the electrical body in water, clean the housing only by wiping it with a damp cloth, keeping water away from the electrics. Clean the sandwich maker after each use while warm so residue does not bake on, and dry everything before storing. So the keys are: clean while warm, use non-scratch tools, wash removable plates separately, and keep the electrical unit dry.
Common questions
How do you clean a sandwich maker?
Unplug it and let it cool to warm, then wipe the plates with a damp cloth or paper towel to lift the melted cheese, grease and crumbs while they are still soft. Gently scrape stuck-on bits with a wooden or silicone tool (never metal, which scratches the nonstick), getting into the grooves and sealing edges, and soften stubborn spots with a warm damp cloth. Wash removable plates in soapy water or the dishwasher if safe, and only wipe the electrical body, never submerge it. Cleaning while warm, soon after use, is the key.
Why clean a sandwich maker while it is still warm?
Because melted cheese, grease and crumbs wipe off easily when warm but harden and stick when cold, so cleaning promptly after use (once unplugged and cooled to warm, not hot) means the residue is still soft and comes off with a simple wipe rather than scrubbing. Waiting until everything is cold and hardened makes it much harder, especially with oozed-out cheese. So unplug the maker, let it cool for a few minutes to warm, and wipe the plates then, which is the trick to easy sandwich-maker cleaning.
How do you remove stuck-on cheese from a sandwich maker?
Scrape it gently with a wooden or silicone spatula or scraper, never metal or abrasive scourers, which scratch the nonstick plates, and do it while the plates are still warm so the cheese comes away more easily. For stubborn, hardened cheese, lay a warm, damp cloth or paper towel over it for a few minutes to soften it, then wipe or gently scrape it off. Use a soft brush or the edge of a wooden tool to clear cheese and crumbs from the ridges and sealing edges of the plates without damaging them.
Can you put sandwich maker plates in the dishwasher?
Only if they are removable and dishwasher safe, check the manual. Many sandwich makers have removable plates you can take out and wash in warm soapy water or, if rated for it, in the dishwasher, which makes cleaning easier. If the plates are fixed (not removable), as on many cheaper or sealed models, you clean them in place by wiping and gently scraping, and cannot put them in the dishwasher. Either way, never put the electrical body in the dishwasher or submerge it in water.
How do you clean the body of a sandwich maker?
Only by wiping it with a damp (not soaking) cloth, then drying it, never submerge the electrical body in water or put it in the dishwasher, because it contains the heating element and electrics. Keep water away from the electrical parts and the power connection. Wipe the hinged housing and exterior to remove any grease or crumbs, and dry it. Removable plates can be washed separately, but the unit itself must only ever be wiped, which keeps the sandwich maker safe and working.
Ready to compare actual models?
Our buying guide puts five products side by side on the numbers their makers publish.