Explainer
Can a sandwich maker be washed?
The plates can; the body cannot. Sandwich makers often have removable plates that go to the sink or dishwasher, while fixed plates are wiped and the housing is never submerged.
By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared
A sandwich maker is washed the same way every electrical cooking appliance is: the parts that touch food get cleaned, and the body that holds the element and the wiring never goes near water. Whether that means wiping a fixed plate or lifting out a removable one depends on which kind you own, and sandwich makers are more likely than most to have plates that come out. Our Best Sandwich Makers compares the published figures of five of them.
Find out which kind you have first
Open the machine and look at the plates. If they are fixed into the hinged body, the plates are cleaned in place and the whole unit is never submerged. If there is a release catch or a button that frees the plates from the body, you own a removable-plate machine, and those plates can be taken to the sink and, on many models, put in a dishwasher.
This distinction matters more on a sandwich maker than on most appliances because the filling is the mess. Melted cheese and sauce escape the edges of a sandwich and bake onto the plate, and a plate you can lift out and scrub is far easier to clear than one you have to wipe inside a warm hinged body. If clean-up is a deciding factor for you, removable plates are the feature to look for.
Washing a removable plate
Let the machine cool enough that the plates are warm rather than hot, release them, and wash them in warm soapy water at the sink. Warm is deliberate: baked-on cheese lifts more easily before it has gone fully cold and hard. Use a soft sponge or a nylon brush, not a metal scourer, because the plates are almost always nonstick and a scratch in that coating is what makes the next sandwich stick.
If a model states its plates are dishwasher safe, that is the easiest route, though hand washing a nonstick plate makes the coating last longer than repeated dishwasher cycles do. Dry the plate fully, including the contacts where it seats back into the body, before it goes back in and before the machine is plugged in.
Cleaning a fixed-plate machine
When the plates do not come out, the method is to wipe rather than wash. With the machine cool, wipe the plates with a damp soapy cloth and work any set filling out of the corners with a wooden or plastic tool. For cheese that has welded to the plate, lay a damp cloth over the closed machine for a minute so the residual warmth and moisture soften it, then wipe it away.
The body, the hinge and the outside get a wipe with a cloth that is damp rather than wet, and no part of the machine is held under a tap or lowered into a sink. A triangular toastie machine with sealed pockets is the hardest of these to clean, because the sealing ridge traps filling exactly where a cloth struggles to reach, so getting to it while the residue is still warm matters most there.
How often, and the grease you cannot see
A sandwich maker should be cleaned after every use rather than saved up, because the mess here is fat and dairy, and both go rancid if they sit. Cheese and buttered bread leave a greasy film even on a session that looked clean, and that film is what builds into a smell and a haze on the plates over a few weeks. A quick wipe or rinse while the plates are still warm takes seconds and prevents all of it.
The grease also collects where you do not look: in the hinge, around the edge of the plate, and in the drip channel if the machine has one. Those are the spots to check on a deeper clean, because a machine that smells faintly of old cooking even after the plates are clean almost always has residue trapped in one of them.
Drying, storage and the rule that does not change
Whatever you clean, the machine goes away dry and cool. A sandwich maker stored warm or with a damp plate traps moisture against the cooking surface, which turns leftover residue into a smell and marks a bare plate. Stand it closed once it is dry, and if it stores upright, that drains any last drops away from the plates rather than pooling them in a corner.
The rule that never changes, on either kind of machine, is that the body stays out of the water. A removable-plate design lets you wash the part that gets dirty; a fixed-plate design lets you wipe it. Neither lets you submerge the housing that holds the element, and a machine that has been dunked should be dried for days and treated with caution before it is plugged in again.
Common questions
Can I wash the whole sandwich maker?
No. The body holds the heating element and wiring and must never be submerged. What you wash is the cooking surface: removable plates go to the sink or sometimes a dishwasher, and fixed plates are wiped with a damp soapy cloth while the body stays dry.
How do I know if my plates come out?
Open the machine and look for a release catch or button that frees the plates from the hinged body. If there is one, the plates are removable and can be washed at the sink. If the plates are fixed in place, you clean them where they are and never take the unit to water.
Are sandwich maker plates dishwasher safe?
Some removable-plate models state they are, which is the easiest way to clean off baked-on cheese. Hand washing a nonstick plate in warm soapy water makes the coating last longer than repeated dishwasher cycles, so even a dishwasher-safe plate benefits from an occasional hand wash.
How do I get melted cheese off the plates?
Deal with it while the plates are warm rather than cold, because set cheese lifts more easily before it hardens. On a removable plate, wash it in warm soapy water with a soft sponge. On a fixed plate, lay a damp cloth over the closed machine for a minute to soften the cheese, then wipe it away.
What if I already put it in water?
Do not plug it in to test it. Unplug it, open it fully, and leave it somewhere warm and dry for a couple of days so trapped moisture can evaporate. Even then, watch the first use for a burning smell or a warm plug, which would mean water reached the wiring.
Ready to compare actual models?
Our buying guides put five products side by side on the numbers their makers publish.