Lush Food & Drink

Explainer

What happens if pressure is too high when canning?

Excess pressure forces steam and liquid past the jar seals and can drive the canner's own relief valves, so the batch loses liquid and the seals may fail.

By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared

When the pressure inside a canner runs above the setting the recipe calls for, steam and boiling liquid are forced out of the jars past the lids, and the canner’s own relief valves may open to vent the excess. The result is jars that lose liquid, seals that may not hold, and food that can be underprocessed if the gauge reading was wrong to begin with.

The fix is not a bigger number on the dial. It is matching the pressure to the food and the altitude, and trusting a gauge you can check. The canners in our Best Pressure Canners for Large-Batch Home Canning guide show how differently makers publish pressure information, and that difference matters when you are trying to hold a setting.

What excess pressure does inside the jar

A pressure canner works by holding steam at a set pressure, which raises the boiling point of the water and the food inside the jars. When the pressure climbs above the target, the temperature inside climbs with it, and the food boils harder than the process assumes. That hard boil pushes liquid up against the lid, and the lid’s sealing compound is designed to vent air out during processing, not to hold back a rush of liquid.

What follows is siphoning: liquid leaves the jar and ends up in the canner water. Jars come out with less liquid than they went in, and food above the liquid line can darken or dry at the top. The seal itself may still form, but a jar that lost a large share of its liquid is a sign the process ran hotter and harder than intended.

None of this is a reason to lower pressure below the recipe. Underpressure is the more dangerous error, because the food never reaches the temperature the process requires. Too much pressure is a quality and seal problem; too little is a safety problem.

The canner’s own valves and locks

Makers build relief paths into these canners, and they describe them in their published features. Presto states that the air vent and cover lock on its Presto 01784 23-Quart Induction Compatible Pressure Canner allow pressure to build only when the cover is properly closed and prevent the cover from opening until pressure is safely reduced. That lock is a backstop, not a gauge, and it does not stop you from running the burner too high.

Siftary describes a triple-protection mechanism on its 24 QT Pressure Canner for Induction and Gas, listing a secure locking lid and dual over-pressure relief valves to prevent accidental steam discharge. RVGMBO lists a secure-lock lid, safety valve, lid window, and pressure release valve on its 12 Quart 18/8 Stainless Steel Pressure Canner. Hestroney describes a six-tier protection system on its 10.57Quart Stainless Steel Pressure Canner Cooker that includes pressure release valves, safety valves, and self-locking valves.

Read those lists as what the makers say the hardware will do if pressure gets away from you. A relief valve that opens is doing its job, but it also means the batch is no longer being held at the pressure the recipe named, so the process is compromised.

Gauges, weights, and where the number comes from

Pressure control comes from either a dial gauge or a weighted regulator, and the two are not the same instrument. All American states that its 21.5qt Pressure Cooker/Canner (The 921) has an easy-to-read steam gauge and a precision machined regulator weight for accurate pressure control. A weighted regulator holds a pressure by rocking; a dial gauge shows you a number you have to read and act on.

RVGMBO publishes a three-level pressure adjustment on its 12 Quart canner, from HIGH at 15 PSI to LOW at 10 PSI. Siftary publishes a gauge calibrated to 14.5 PSI on its 24 QT canner. Those are the makers’ stated figures, and they are the settings the hardware is built around, not a menu of options for any given recipe.

Presto states that its 01784 includes a precise pressure gauge for accuracy but does not publish a pressure range in its listed features. All American publishes no pressure range either. Hestroney publishes no pressure figure at all in its features. Where a maker does not publish a number, this site has not compared one, and you should follow the process your recipe and your altitude call for.

Altitude changes the number, not the goal

Pressure settings rise with altitude because water boils at a lower temperature as you climb, so the canner has to hold more pressure to reach the same internal temperature. Siftary frames its 14.5 PSI gauge as suited to high-altitude canning in its published features. That is the maker’s claim about the gauge calibration, not a table of settings for your kitchen.

The practical point is that a pressure that is correct at sea level is too low at elevation, and a pressure that is correct at elevation is too high at sea level. Running a high-altitude setting on a low-altitude batch is one common way to overpressure a canner, and it produces exactly the siphoning and seal trouble described above.

This site has not compared altitude charts for any of these canners, and the makers do not publish altitude tables in the features listed here. Use the altitude guidance that comes with your recipe source and your canner’s own instructions.

Capacity, burner heat, and the pressure you actually get

Pressure is a function of heat input and venting, so a large canner on a hot burner can overshoot while a small one on the same burner may struggle to reach the setting. The Presto 01784 is listed at 24.3 Quarts with space for 7 quarts, 20 pints, or 26 half-pints of regular Mason jars, and it measures 17.5 inches wide, 13.5 inches deep, and 15.5 inches tall at 12.49 pounds. The All American 921 is listed at 21.5 Quarts and holds about 19 pint jars or 7 quart jars, at 15 inches wide, 16 inches deep, and 17 inches tall, 20 pounds.

The Siftary canner is listed at 24 Quarts, the RVGMBO at 12 Quarts, and the Hestroney at 10.6 Quarts. Width, depth, height, and weight are not published for those three in the features this site compared. A bigger pot holds more steam and takes longer to respond when you turn the burner down, which is why the moment pressure is reached is the moment to cut the heat.

Presto states that its canner works on induction, gas, electric, and smooth-top stoves. All American states suitability for gas, electric, or flat top stoves. Siftary states induction, gas, and electric compatibility, and RVGMBO states induction, gas, and electric compatibility. Hestroney publishes no stove compatibility in its listed features. Match the canner to the burner, then watch the gauge or the regulator rather than the clock.

What to do when the pressure climbs too high

Turn the heat down and let the canner settle at the setting the recipe names. Do not open the cover to release pressure, and do not run cold water on the canner. Presto’s cover lock is designed to prevent opening until pressure is safely reduced, and forcing the issue on any canner risks a steam release you cannot control.

After the batch is done, check the jars. Low liquid, food stuck above the liquid line, or a lid that did not seal are the marks of a batch that ran too hot. Siftary’s kit includes a magnetic lid lifter, jar wrench, lifting tongs, wide-mouth funnel, stirrer, canning tongs, and a reinforced rack, which covers the handling side but not the pressure side.

The habit that prevents all of this is simple: bring the canner up, vent it as the maker instructs, let it reach the setting, then lower the heat to hold that setting steady. Pressure that holds steady is the goal. Pressure that keeps climbing is the problem.

Common questions

Does too much pressure ruin canned food?

It can spoil the quality and the seal rather than the safety. Excess pressure drives liquid out of the jars, so food above the liquid line darkens and the seal may fail. The food was still processed at or above the required temperature, so the risk is a poor seal and dry contents, not underprocessing. Discard any jar that did not seal.

Should I lower the pressure if the gauge reads high?

Lower the heat, not the target. Turn the burner down and let the canner settle at the pressure your recipe and altitude call for. Dropping below that setting is the dangerous direction, because the food may not reach the temperature the process requires. Hold the setting steady rather than chasing the gauge up and down.

Why did my jars lose liquid during pressure canning?

Siphoning happens when the canner runs hotter and harder than the process assumes, or when pressure is released too fast at the end. Steam and boiling liquid push past the lid. Let the canner come down to zero pressure on its own, and hold the setting steady during the process. Jars that lost most of their liquid should be treated as suspect.

What pressure do these canners publish?

RVGMBO publishes a three-level adjustment on its 12 Quart canner, from HIGH at 15 PSI to LOW at 10 PSI. Siftary publishes a gauge calibrated to 14.5 PSI on its 24 QT canner. Presto, All American, and Hestroney do not publish a pressure range in the features this site compared, so this site has not compared one for those three.

Can I open the canner to let pressure out faster?

No. Presto states that the air vent and cover lock on its 01784 canner prevent the cover from opening until pressure is safely reduced. Other makers list locking lids and relief valves for the same reason. Opening early releases a rush of steam and boiling liquid. Let the canner cool until the gauge reads zero and the lock releases on its own.

Does altitude change the pressure I should use?

Yes. Water boils at a lower temperature as altitude rises, so the canner has to hold more pressure to reach the same internal temperature. Siftary frames its 14.5 PSI gauge as suited to high-altitude canning. This site has not compared altitude charts for these canners, so follow the guidance that comes with your recipe source.

Ready to compare actual models?

Our buying guide puts five products side by side on the numbers their makers publish.

More questions about pressure canners