Lush Food & Drink

Explainer

What is the difference between canning and freezing tomatoes?

Canning tomatoes heat-seals them in jars for shelf storage, while freezing tomatoes chills them in containers for the freezer, and each route uses different equipment and different published capacities.

By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared

Canning tomatoes packs them into jars and heat-processes the sealed jars so they keep on a shelf, while freezing tomatoes puts them in containers or bags and holds them below freezing until you cook with them. The practical difference is the equipment: canning needs a water bath canner or a pressure canner sized to your jar count, and freezing needs only containers and freezer space.

Tomatoes sit in the acidic group, so the water bath method is the usual route for them, and the electric canners and pressure canners this site has compared publish jar capacities you can check before you commit to a batch size. Freezing has no jar capacity to publish at all, because the maker of a freezer bag or container does not state how many tomatoes fit.

How the two methods work

Water bath canning covers the filled, lidded jars with boiling water and holds them there for a set processing time, which is why the pot has to be deep enough for the jars plus water above them. The McSunley Prep•N•Cook 21.5Qt Stainless Steel Water Bath Canner is a stovetop pot at 21.5 quarts, and its maker states the rack holds 7 one-quart jars, 9 one-pint jars or 12 half-pint jars. That is a published jar count, not a tomato count.

Freezing skips the jar and the boiling water entirely. You core, peel or chop the tomatoes, pack them, and freeze. There is no processing time, no headspace rule tied to a canner, and no rack. What you give up is shelf storage: frozen tomatoes occupy freezer space and depend on the freezer staying cold, while canned jars sit in a cupboard.

Pressure canning is the other canning route. It uses a locked, pressurized vessel rather than an open pot of boiling water, and the makers describe it for low-acid foods. The Presto 01784 23-Quart Induction Compatible Pressure Canner is listed with space for 7 quarts, 20 pints or 26 half-pints of regular Mason jars. Those are the maker’s jar figures for that canner, and they say nothing about how many tomatoes a jar holds.

Electric canners and their published capacities

An electric canner plugs in and runs its own heating cycle, so you do not need a stove burner sized for a heavy pot. The Best Electric Canners for Pressure and Water Bath Preserving guide compares five of them, and the capacity figures below come from that guide’s fact sheet.

The Presto 02144 12-Quart Digital Pressure Canner is a 12-quart unit, and its maker states it automates both pressure canning and water bath canning. The NESCO NPC-9 is listed at 9 quarts in its size field, while its own feature text describes a 9.5-quart removable nonstick inner pot with canning and steam racks included. The WantJoin water bath canner is listed at 33 quarts in its size field, and its feature text states a 30-quart capacity that holds up to 11 one-quart jars. Where a listing shows two figures, both are the maker’s, and this site has not resolved which one governs.

The McSunley pot is the stovetop option in that guide at 21.5 quarts, and the VEVOR unit is listed at 10 quarts. For tomatoes specifically, the water bath mode is the relevant one, and the WantJoin and McSunley entries are the two that describe water bath canning in their published features. The Presto 02144 covers both modes in one unit.

Pressure canners and batch size

A pressure canner is a heavier vessel with a locking cover and a gauge or regulator weight. The Best Pressure Canners for Large-Batch Home Canning guide compares five, and the jar counts below are the makers’ published figures for those picks.

The All American 921 is a 21.5-quart canner, and its maker states it holds approximately 19 pint jars or 7 quart jars. The Presto 01784 is the 23-quart model listed at 7 quarts, 20 pints or 26 half-pints. The RVGMBO 12-quart cooker lists three pressure settings from 15 PSI at the high end to 10 PSI at the low end. The Siftary 24 QT canner states a gauge calibrated to 14.5 PSI. The Hestroney unit is listed at 10.6 quarts.

None of those makers publish a tomato quantity, and neither does any freezer container maker. If you want to plan a batch, the jar count is the number you can actually check, and the tomato count per jar is something you work out from your own jar size and pack style.

What the makers do and do not publish

For the canners, the published numbers are capacity in quarts, jar counts for some models, and in a few cases pressure in PSI. The Presto 02144 states that no adjustments are needed for high altitudes, and the All American 921 states a metal-to-metal sealing system with no gasket. The NESCO NPC-9 states a safety lock lid, an automatic float valve and a pressure regulation system. Those are descriptions of how the unit operates, not measurements of output.

For freezing, there is nothing comparable to cite. No maker in either guide publishes a freezing capacity, a container count, or a tomato weight, because neither guide covers freezer containers. This site has not compared freezer containers, so any figure for how many tomatoes a bag or box holds would be invented, and this page does not give one.

One more limit worth stating plainly: nobody at Lush has used any of these canners. Everything above is what the makers state in their published features and specifications, plus what follows from those statements. Whether a given canner fits your stove, your cupboard or your jar supply is a question about your kitchen, and the dimensions in the guides are the maker’s published figures for checking that.

Choosing between the two for tomatoes

If you want tomatoes on a shelf at room temperature, canning is the route, and for tomatoes the water bath mode is the one the makers describe for acidic foods. That points to a water bath canner such as the McSunley 21.5-quart pot or the WantJoin unit, or to a dual-mode electric canner such as the Presto 02144, which states both pressure and water bath functions.

If freezer space is what you have, freezing needs no canner at all, and the equipment question disappears. The trade is that frozen tomatoes take up freezer room and canned jars take up shelf room, and only the canning side has published capacities you can compare before you buy. Pick the storage you have, then size the gear to the jar count the maker states.

Common questions

Do you need a pressure canner to can tomatoes?

Tomatoes are acidic, and the makers in the electric canner guide describe water bath canning for fruits, jams, jellies and salsa. The Presto 02144 states it automates both pressure canning and water bath canning, and the Presto 01784 states it doubles as a boiling water canner. A pressure canner is the route the makers describe for low-acid foods such as meat and vegetables.

How many jars fit in a water bath canner?

It depends on the model and the jar size. The McSunley Prep•N•Cook 21.5Qt states its rack holds 7 one-quart jars, 9 one-pint jars or 12 half-pint jars. The WantJoin unit states a 30-quart capacity that holds up to 11 one-quart jars. Both are the makers' published figures for those specific models.

Can you freeze tomatoes in the same jars you can them in?

Neither guide covers freezer containers, so this site has not compared them and cannot give a container figure. What the guides do publish is canning capacity: jar counts for some canners and quart capacities for all of them. Freezing capacity is not published by any maker cited here.

Does freezing take the place of a canner?

Yes, in the sense that freezing needs no canner, no jars and no processing time. You pack the tomatoes and freeze them. The difference is storage: frozen tomatoes need freezer space and a working freezer, while canned jars sit on a shelf. Only the canning side has published capacities to compare.

Which canner holds the most quart jars?

Among the picks in the pressure canner guide, the Presto 01784 23-Quart model states space for 7 quarts, 20 pints or 26 half-pints, and the All American 921 states approximately 19 pint jars or 7 quart jars. In the electric canner guide, the WantJoin unit states up to 11 one-quart jars. Check the maker's figure for the exact model you consider.

Do these canners need altitude adjustments?

The Presto 02144 states that no adjustments are needed for high altitudes. The Siftary 24 QT canner states its gauge is calibrated to 14.5 PSI and describes itself as suited to high-altitude canning. Other picks in the two guides do not state an altitude position in their published features, so this site cannot say what applies to them.

Ready to compare actual models?

Our buying guides put five products side by side on the numbers their makers publish.

More questions about electric canners