Explainer
What should you look for in silicone ice cube trays?
Look for flexible, food-grade silicone that pops cubes out easily, the cube size and shape you want, a sturdy tray (ideally with a firm base or frame so it does not spill when carried), a lid to keep ice fresh and spill-free, and easy cleaning. Easy release and the right cube size matter most.
By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared
Silicone ice cube trays make ice cubes in flexible silicone molds you twist or push to release the cubes, so when choosing one, look above all for flexible, food-grade silicone that pops the cubes out easily (the main advantage of silicone over rigid trays), the cube size and shape you want (standard cubes, large cubes for slow-melting drinks, spheres, small cubes, etc.), a sturdy tray that does not flop and spill water when you carry it to the freezer (ideally with a firm base, frame or lid for support), a lid to keep the ice fresh (stop it absorbing freezer odors) and prevent spills, and easy cleaning. The easy release and the right cube size and shape matter most, since the point of a silicone tray is cubes that pop out effortlessly in the form you want, with a stable, spill-free design and a lid being valuable practical extras. So look for easy-releasing food-grade silicone in your preferred cube size, with a sturdy, ideally lidded design and easy cleaning. Our Best Silicone Ice Cube Trays compares five of them.
Easy release: flexible, food-grade silicone
The most important thing to look for is flexible, food-grade silicone that releases the cubes easily, because that is the whole point of a silicone tray over a rigid plastic or metal one. Good silicone flexes so you can twist the tray or push each cube from underneath to pop the ice out cleanly, without the struggle, cracking and running-under-water that stiff trays need, so look for a tray made of quality, genuinely flexible silicone that will release the cubes effortlessly. This easy release is the key benefit and the first thing to get right.
It should also be food-grade (food-safe) silicone, so it is safe for freezing water and food (and does not impart taste or odor), and a quality silicone that stays flexible when frozen (cheap or thin silicone can be stiffer or less durable). So prioritize flexible, food-safe silicone that pops the cubes out easily, since a tray that does not release cleanly defeats the purpose of choosing silicone. This easy, clean release is what silicone ice cube trays are chosen for, so it is the essential quality to look for, flexible, good-quality, food-grade silicone that lets the cubes come out with a simple twist or push.
Cube size and shape
Look for the cube size and shape you want, since silicone trays come in many options and the right one depends on your use. Standard cube size suits everyday drinks; large (king/jumbo) cubes or spheres melt more slowly and are good for whisky, cocktails and keeping drinks cold without watering them down fast; small cubes chill quickly and suit lots of small drinks; and there are specialty shapes (sticks for water bottles, fun shapes, etc.). So decide what you want the ice for and choose the cube size and shape to match, since this affects how the ice performs in your drinks.
Also consider how many cubes the tray makes and the total capacity, matching it to how much ice you use, and whether you want one size or a few different trays for different purposes. The cube shape and size are a defining choice with silicone trays because so many options exist, and getting the size/shape right for your drinks (slow-melting large cubes versus quick-chilling small ones, etc.) is a key part of choosing well. So look at the cube size and shape as a main consideration, picking what suits your drinks and ice needs, since that, along with easy release, determines how useful the tray is for you. So match the cubes to your use, which is one of the most important things to decide.
Sturdiness, spill prevention and a lid
Look for a sturdy design that does not spill, because a common drawback of flexible silicone trays is that they are floppy, so a tray of water can bend and spill as you carry it to the freezer. To avoid this, look for a tray with a firm base, a rigid frame or tray around the silicone, or a lid, that supports it and keeps it flat and stable so the water does not slosh out, making it easy to fill, carry and freeze without mess. Some silicone trays sit in a plastic frame or come with a solid base for exactly this reason, which is worth looking for.
A lid is a valuable feature to look for: a lid keeps the ice fresh by stopping it absorbing odors and tastes from the freezer (freezer-burn and off-flavors are common with uncovered ice), prevents spills while carrying and in the freezer, keeps the ice clean, and often lets you stack trays. So a lidded silicone tray is more practical, fresher ice, no spills, stackable. So sturdiness (a firm base or frame to prevent the floppy-tray spill) and a lid (for fresh, clean, spill-free, stackable ice) are important practical features to look for, addressing silicone trays’ main weaknesses. So look for a stable, spill-resistant, ideally lidded design, which makes the tray much nicer to use than a floppy, open one.
Easy cleaning and choosing
Easy cleaning is worth looking for, and silicone trays are generally good here: look for a tray that is easy to clean, flexible silicone wipes and washes easily and does not hold residue much, and many are dishwasher safe, so choose one that is easy to wash and, ideally, dishwasher safe for convenience. A design without awkward crevices, and silicone that does not readily stain or hold odors, keeps it hygienic and simple to clean.
Pulling it together, look for a silicone ice cube tray made of flexible, food-grade silicone that pops the cubes out easily (the key feature), in the cube size and shape you want for your drinks, with a sturdy design that does not spill when carried (a firm base or frame, or a lid), a lid to keep the ice fresh and prevent spills, and easy cleaning. The easy release and the right cube size/shape matter most, since they determine whether the tray does its job the way you want, with sturdiness, a lid and easy cleaning making it practical and pleasant to use. So choose easy-releasing quality silicone in your preferred cube form, with a stable, lidded, easy-clean design, and it will make and release good ice conveniently, which is exactly what to aim for when choosing silicone ice cube trays.
The short answer
When choosing silicone ice cube trays, look above all for flexible, food-grade silicone that pops the cubes out easily, since easy release is the whole point of silicone over rigid trays, so you want quality, genuinely flexible, food-safe silicone that lets the cubes come out with a simple twist or push, no struggling or running under water. Next, choose the cube size and shape you want for your use: standard cubes for everyday drinks, large cubes or spheres that melt slowly for whisky and cocktails, small cubes that chill quickly, or specialty shapes, and consider how many cubes the tray makes. Look for a sturdy design that does not spill when carried, since flexible trays can be floppy and slosh water, so a firm base, a rigid frame around the silicone, or a lid that keeps it stable is valuable. A lid is a worthwhile feature generally: it keeps the ice fresh by stopping it absorbing freezer odors, prevents spills, keeps the ice clean, and often lets you stack trays. Finally, look for easy cleaning, silicone washes easily and many trays are dishwasher safe. The easy release and the right cube size and shape matter most, with sturdiness, a lid and easy cleaning making the tray practical. So choose easy-releasing quality silicone in your preferred cube form, with a stable, lidded, easy-clean design.
Common questions
What should you look for in silicone ice cube trays?
Above all flexible, food-grade silicone that pops the cubes out easily, since easy release is the whole point of silicone, plus the cube size and shape you want (standard, large/slow-melting, small, or specialty), a sturdy design that does not spill when carried (a firm base, frame or lid), a lid to keep the ice fresh and prevent spills, and easy cleaning. The easy release and the right cube size matter most, with sturdiness, a lid and easy cleaning making the tray practical and pleasant to use.
Why does the silicone quality matter in an ice cube tray?
Because easy release is the main advantage of a silicone tray over a rigid one, and that depends on the silicone being genuinely flexible, good-quality, food-grade silicone flexes so you can twist the tray or push the cubes out cleanly with no struggling, cracking or running under water, while cheap, thin or stiff silicone releases poorly and may be less durable or stiffer when frozen. So look for quality, flexible, food-safe silicone that pops the cubes out effortlessly, since a tray that does not release cleanly defeats the purpose of choosing silicone.
What cube size and shape should you choose?
Whatever suits your use: standard cubes for everyday drinks, large (king or jumbo) cubes or spheres that melt slowly for whisky and cocktails (keeping drinks cold without watering them down fast), small cubes that chill quickly for lots of small drinks, or specialty shapes like sticks for water bottles. Also consider how many cubes the tray makes and the total capacity for how much ice you use. So decide what you want the ice for and pick the cube size and shape to match, since it affects how the ice performs in your drinks.
Why does a silicone ice cube tray need a sturdy base or frame?
Because flexible silicone trays can be floppy, so a tray full of water can bend and spill as you carry it to the freezer, a common drawback. A firm base, a rigid frame around the silicone, or a lid supports the tray and keeps it flat and stable so the water does not slosh out, making it easy to fill, carry and freeze without mess. So look for a tray with such support to avoid the floppy-tray spill, which makes it much nicer to use than an unsupported open one.
Is a lid worth having on a silicone ice cube tray?
Yes, a lid is a valuable feature: it keeps the ice fresh by stopping it absorbing odors and tastes from the freezer (uncovered ice often picks up off-flavors), prevents spills while you carry the tray and in the freezer, keeps the ice clean, and often lets you stack trays to save space. So a lidded silicone tray gives fresher, cleaner ice with no spills and better stacking, addressing some of the weaknesses of open trays, which makes a lid well worth looking for when choosing one.
Ready to compare actual models?
Our buying guide puts five products side by side on the numbers their makers publish.