Lush Food & Drink

Explainer

What type of cutting board should you get?

Plastic and titanium are the two types compared here, and the choice comes down to whether you want a soft, dishwasher safe surface or a hard, non porous metal one.

By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared

Plastic and titanium are the two types of cutting board compared on this site, and the difference that matters is the surface: plastic is soft and dishwasher safe, titanium is hard and non porous. Neither type is better in every kitchen, so the useful question is which of the two published sets of features fits how you prep food.

What a plastic cutting board set gives you

The plastic picks in the Best Cutting Boards for Plastic and Titanium Sets guide are sold as sets of three, and the sizes are the main way they separate food types. The THETCHRY set lists a large board at 15 by 10 in for meat and fish, a medium at 11 by 8 in for vegetables and fruit, and a small at 9 by 6 in for onions and peppers. The maker states the boards are BPA free and can go straight into the dishwasher.

GORILLA GRIP publishes the same three tier approach with larger boards. Its set lists a largest board at 16 by 11.2 in, a medium at 13.8 by 9.6 in and a small at 11.8 by 8 in, each .37 in thick, with a combined weight of 4.25 lbs. The maker states the surface is nonporous, that deep grooves catch juices, and that the boards are dishwasher safe and need no oiling. A rubber border and slip resistant handle are listed to reduce sliding on the counter.

Empune publishes its three sizes in inches as well: extra large at 17.0 by 11.8 by 0.4 in, large at 14.0 by 9.5 by 0.35 in and medium at 11.4 by 7.8 by 0.35 in. The maker states the plastic is high density, that a juice groove runs around all sides, and that a TPR edge handle holds the board in place. Rinsing with warm water or a dishwasher cycle are both listed as cleaning options.

What a titanium cutting board gives you

The titanium picks are double sided rather than sold as three separate boards. Sumzzz lists a board at 16 by 11 in with one side for meat and the other for fruits and vegetables. The maker states the titanium surface is non porous and helps reduce the absorption of liquids, odors and stains, and that both sides rinse clean with water. A hanging hole, a juice groove and a garlic grinding area are listed.

Pexucalm publishes a board at 15.4 by 10.4 in with a titanium side for raw meat and seafood and a wheat straw PP side for vegetables and fruit. The maker states the softer PP side protects knife edges, that the titanium has a matte texture finish to conceal minor knife marks, and that the wheat straw side carries a deep juice groove and a garlic grinder zone. A silicone edge is listed for grip.

The trade the makers describe is hardness against softness. Titanium is presented as the surface that resists odor, stains and residue, while the plastic boards are presented as the ones that go into the dishwasher and, in Pexucalm’s case, the PP face is described as the softer side that protects a knife edge. If you want one board that wipes clean, the titanium picks are built around that. If you want several boards you can run through a dishwasher, the plastic sets are built around that.

Sizes and weights the makers publish

Board size decides how much counter space a board takes and how much food it holds. The largest plastic board here is Empune’s extra large at 17.0 by 11.8 in, followed by GORILLA GRIP at 16 by 11.2 in and THETCHRY at 15 by 10 in. The titanium boards sit close to that range: Sumzzz at 16 by 11 in and Pexucalm at 15.4 by 10.4 in. Thickness is published for some picks only: Empune lists 0.4 in on its extra large board, GORILLA GRIP lists .37 in on each board, and Pexucalm lists 0.5 in.

Weight is published unevenly. THETCHRY lists 1.4 lbs in its specifications and states 2.3 pounds in its feature text, so the two figures do not match and both are reported here as the maker gives them. GORILLA GRIP lists 4.24 lbs for the set and states a combined 4.25 lbs in its feature text. Empune lists 4.53 lbs. Neither titanium maker publishes a weight, so this site has not compared the titanium boards by weight.

What follows from those figures is simple. The plastic sets carry three boards for the weight of roughly one large board, and the titanium boards are single units with no published weight at all. If you store boards on a hook, THETCHRY lists a triangular handle and Sumzzz lists a hanging hole. If you stack them, the three board plastic sets give you more separate surfaces to work with.

Cleaning and maintenance

Dishwasher safety is published for all three plastic picks. THETCHRY states its BPA free boards can be put directly into the dishwasher or washed by hand with soap. GORILLA GRIP states its boards are dishwasher safe and that the plastic helps prevent liquid and odor absorption. Empune states you can rinse with warm water or use a dishwasher. None of the three plastic makers lists an oiling or seasoning routine.

The titanium makers describe hand cleaning only. Sumzzz states both sides can be rinsed clean with water after use. Pexucalm states the titanium surface has natural non stick properties so grease and meat juices rinse off, and that a prompt rinse keeps the wheat straw side fresh. Neither titanium maker mentions a dishwasher, so this site has not compared the titanium boards on dishwasher safety.

Odor and stain resistance is where the titanium makers make their case. Sumzzz states the non porous structure helps reduce absorption of liquids, odors and stains. Pexucalm states the titanium resists residue better than aged wood. On the plastic side, GORILLA GRIP states its tough plastic material helps prevent liquid and odor absorption. Both types are presented as resisting odor, and the difference the makers describe is how you clean them afterward.

How to choose between the two types

Choose plastic if you want several boards in different sizes and you want to put them in a dishwasher. The three plastic sets here each publish three board sizes, and each maker lists dishwasher cleaning. The sizes let you keep meat, vegetables and small items on separate surfaces, which is the cross contamination point THETCHRY and Empune both raise in their feature text.

Choose titanium if you want one board with two faces and a surface the maker presents as non porous and easy to wipe. Sumzzz and Pexucalm both build their boards around a meat side and a produce side, and Pexucalm adds a softer PP face that it states protects knife edges. Neither titanium maker publishes a weight or a dishwasher claim, so those two points are open.

One more published difference is grip. GORILLA GRIP lists a slip resistant handle and rubber border, THETCHRY lists rubber anti slip feet on both sides, and Empune lists a TPR edge handle. Pexucalm lists a full silicone edge for stability. Sumzzz does not list a grip feature, so this site has not compared that board on grip. Read each maker’s own list before deciding, because the features that matter most, size, cleaning and grip, are the ones the makers actually publish.

Common questions

Is a plastic or titanium cutting board better for raw meat?

Both types are sold with a dedicated meat surface. THETCHRY lists its large 15 by 10 in board for meat and fish, and Sumzzz and Pexucalm each give one titanium face to raw meat and seafood. The difference is cleaning: the plastic makers list dishwasher safety, while the titanium makers describe rinsing by hand with water.

Do titanium cutting boards go in the dishwasher?

Neither titanium maker in this guide mentions a dishwasher. Sumzzz states both sides rinse clean with water, and Pexucalm states the titanium surface rinses off grease and meat juices and that a prompt rinse keeps the wheat straw side fresh. This site has not compared the titanium boards on dishwasher safety.

How thick are the cutting boards in this guide?

Thickness is published for some picks only. GORILLA GRIP lists .37 in on each of its three boards, Empune lists 0.4 in on its extra large board and 0.35 in on its large and medium boards, and Pexucalm lists 0.5 in. THETCHRY and Sumzzz do not publish a thickness, so this site has not compared those two on that figure.

Can one cutting board handle both meat and vegetables?

Yes, if it is double sided. Sumzzz lists one side for meat and the other for fruits and vegetables, and Pexucalm lists a titanium side for raw meat and seafood and a wheat straw PP side for vegetables and fruit. The plastic sets take a different approach, giving you three separate boards in three sizes instead of two faces.

What is the largest cutting board in this guide?

Empune publishes the largest figure, an extra large board at 17.0 by 11.8 by 0.4 in. GORILLA GRIP lists a largest board at 16 by 11.2 in, Sumzzz lists 16 by 11 in, Pexucalm lists 15.4 by 10.4 in and THETCHRY lists 15 by 10 in. Each of those figures is the maker's own published size for its largest board.

Does a titanium cutting board protect knife edges?

Pexucalm addresses this directly: it states the wheat straw PP side is a softer material that protects knife edges from rolling, and positions the titanium side for raw meat and seafood. Sumzzz does not publish a knife edge claim. The plastic makers do not publish a knife edge claim either, so this site has not compared the plastic boards on that point.

Ready to compare actual models?

Our buying guide puts five products side by side on the numbers their makers publish.

More questions about cutting boards