How the Five Compare on the Numbers
A fluted tube pan has two diameters and they are not close together. The outside is what the cupboard and the oven shelf have to take. The inside is the cake. Three of these five publish both, or label which one they mean, and on one of the three the exterior is 12 inches where the interior is 9.5.
That listing is casaWare, which states an exterior of 12 by 10.5 by 3.5 inches and an interior of 9.5 by 9.5 by 3 inches on a pan sold as a 9.5 inch, 10 cup pan. Both figures are honest and only one of them is the pan you store. The other four are less explicit, and two publish a single number with no surface attached.
What the table cannot settle is how deep the flutes are. Every height here is the wall of the pan, and a fluted pattern takes some of that depth back. None of these five publishes a flute depth, so the usable volume of a pan without a stated cup capacity cannot be worked out from its dimensions.
The Pan You Store and the Cake You Bake
casaWare Publishes Both and They Are Far Apart
casaWare’s last bullet reads exterior 12 by 10.5 by 3.5 inches, interior 9.5 by 9.5 by 3 inches. The pan is titled a 9.5 inch, 10 cup pan, so the name describes the cake and the exterior describes the object. Two and a half inches on the long axis is the difference between fitting a shelf and not.
The rest of the listing is the most specific of these five. A silicate and glass based ceramic coating derived from quartz sand, free of cadmium, lead, PFOA, PTFE, PFOS and PFAS, double coated over 0.6 mm carbon steel, with heat tolerance to 450 degrees Fahrenheit. Hand washing is recommended, immersion is discouraged and the microwave is ruled out.
Novery Names Both Diameters in One Sentence
Novery publishes a 9.5 inch outer diameter, a 9 inch inner diameter and a 3 inch height in its first bullet, and its dimension fields read 9.5 by 9.5 by 3.0 inches. Half an inch between outside and inside is a thin wall and a believable figure, and the two sources agree.
It also describes the shape rather than just the size: a narrow base, straight sides and an extra large center tube, in professional weight formed carbon steel with a scratch resistant nonstick coating. What it never publishes is a capacity in cups, an oven temperature, or a washing instruction, which leaves three of the five columns on this page empty for it.
Two Pans Sized by Volume Instead
Bake Choice Publishes Twelve Cups and a Square
Bake Choice publishes a 12 cup capacity in its title and a 450 degrees F ceiling in two separate bullets, on premium three layer carbon steel with a PFAS free nonstick coating and smooth rolled edges for carrying it hot. That is a well specified pan on everything except its size.
Its size statement is the oddity: an inner size given as a square cake pan of 9.5 by 9.5 inch, on a round fluted tube pan. Two equal figures are how a diameter is usually entered twice, so the number is probably right and the word square is not. Its dimension fields, 10.3 by 3.8 by 10.83 inches, do not match either.
BNYD Publishes a Diameter and a Capacity Together
BNYD states a 10 inch pan with a generous 12 cup capacity, oven safe up to 450 degrees F, stain resistant and dishwasher safe, with dimension fields of 10.0 by 10.0 by 4.0 inches that agree with the stated diameter. For a buyer who wants one number and one volume, it is the cleanest listing here.
It publishes nothing about the inside. A 10 inch outside diameter on a pan with 12 cups of volume implies a 9 point something inch cake, and the listing does not say. It also names no material beyond high quality and heavy duty, and at 1.55 lb it is the heaviest pick on this page.
The Pan That Is Two Materials
Silicone Inside a Steel Frame
Boxiki is the only pick here that is not a single piece of coated metal. A silicone baking dish sits inside a heavy grade steel frame with handles, stated to protect the silicone from bending and folding and to stop it sagging after hundreds of uses. It is the only pan on this page with published handles.
Its size bullet gives 9 inches long by 9 wide by 4.6 deep and marks the figures as the internal size, which makes it the only listing here to label an internal measurement without also giving an external one. The frame adds something on every axis and the listing does not say how much.
What It Publishes Instead of a Temperature
It states the dish is safe in an oven, a freezer and a dishwasher, with no figure for any of the three. On silicone that omission matters more than on steel: the other picks here publish 450 degrees F, and a silicone dish in a steel frame is the pan on this page whose limit a buyer would most like to know.
At 0.99 lb it is the lightest of the five, which makes sense for silicone with a wire frame, and its 4.6 inch internal depth is more than any other listing here publishes. Deep and light is a combination none of the coated steel pans offers.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
Measuring the shelf before you buy. casaWare, a 9.5 inch 10 cup pan in ceramic over 0.6 mm carbon steel, publishing an exterior of 12 by 10.5 by 3.5 inches and an interior of 9.5 by 9.5 by 3 inches, hand washed and rated to 450 degrees Fahrenheit.
A thin wall and a big tube. Novery, carbon steel publishing a 9.5 inch outer diameter, a 9 inch inner diameter and a 3 inch height, with a narrow base, straight sides and a scratch resistant nonstick coating, at 1.06 lb.
Something to hold while it is hot. Boxiki, a silicone dish in a steel frame with handles, published at 9 by 9 by 4.6 inches internally, stated safe in an oven, a freezer and a dishwasher, at 0.99 lb.
Baking to a recipe written in cups. Bake Choice, a 12 cup fluted pan in three layer carbon steel with a PFAS free coating and rolled edges, oven safe to 450 degrees F, with an inner size given as 9.5 by 9.5 inches.
One diameter, one volume, one wash. BNYD, a 10 inch pan stated to hold 12 cups with a nonstick easy release surface, stain resistant and dishwasher safe, oven safe to 450 degrees F, at 1.55 lb.
What We Could Not Verify
Every figure above comes from the maker’s own listing text. These are the things we went looking for and could not source in any of them.
- No listing publishes a flute depth, so usable volume cannot be worked out from the dimensions.
- Two of the five publish no inside diameter at all.
- Two publish no oven temperature figure, including the one silicone pick.
- Boxiki publishes an internal figure and never measures the steel frame around it.
- Bake Choice describes the inner size of a round pan as a square cake pan.
- Two of the five publish no washing instruction in either direction.