Lush Food & Drink

Buying Guide ·Baking

Best Madeleine Baking Pans and What Two of Them Occupy

The deciding specification is how many pans arrive and what one pan is stated to measure, because four of these five are two-packs and the pans split into a 13.8 by 10.4 inch rectangle and a long narrow strip near 15.75 inches.

By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared

  • Researched & ComparedSpecs pulled from the manufacturer listing
  • Like-for-LikeSame measures across every model
  • No Paid PlacementsNobody pays to appear here

I compared the pans per purchase against the size each maker states for one pan, the cavity sizes, the steel gauges where any are published, the coating claims, the cleaning instructions and the published weights, across five madeleine pans using only each maker's own published text.

Our shortlist

Five products, one set of published numbers.
  1. Waylenbo Madeleine- Pan 2 Pack
    Best for a dishwasher and a stated 0.8 mm gauge

    Waylenbo Madeleine- Pan 2 Pack

    Two 12-cavity carbon steel pans, each stated at 13.8 by 10.4 by 1 inch with a full cavity size of 2.5 inches, in what the maker calls thickened 0.8 mm carbon steel with a strengthened edge against warping, stated dishwasher safe, publishing 0.74 pounds for the pair.

    • Waylenbo
    • one size
    • 0.74 lb
  2. 2 Pack Non-Stick Madeleine Pan
    Best for fill lines inside each cavity

    2 Pack Non-Stick Madeleine Pan

    Two 12-cavity pans stated at 13.8 by 10.4 inches with 2.6 inch cavities, and the only listing here with clear measurement markers inside each cavity for portioning, on thick-gauge carbon steel with reinforced edges, PFOA and PTFE free, stated dishwasher safe, publishing 1.49 pounds.

    • CHENZORVAX
    • 2pcs
    • 1.49 lb
  3. Shinsin Nonstick Madeleine Pans
    Best for a strip that fits a narrow shelf

    Shinsin Nonstick Madeleine Pans

    Two pans in the long narrow shape rather than the rectangle, stated at 15 and two thirds by 7 by two thirds inches with wells of 3 by 2 inches, on a carbon steel core with a food grade coating, and hand wash only in warm soapy water with thorough drying before storage, at 2.03 pounds.

    • Shinsin
    • Standard Size
    • 2.03 lb
  4. Chicago Metallic Professional 12-Cup Non-Stick Madel...
    Best for a single pan rather than a pair

    Chicago Metallic Professional 12-Cup Non-Stick Madel...

    One 12-cup pan rather than two, stated at 15.75 inches by 7.75, which the maker describes across three separate bullets as heavy-weight aluminized steel, as silicone based with a non-stick coating, and as crafted from durable carbon steel. Dishwasher safe, with hand washing recommended.

    • Chicago Metallic
    • 15.75-Inch-by-7.75-Inch
    • Weight not listed
  5. Mold Cake Pan for Madeleine
    Best for a metric size that converts cleanly

    Mold Cake Pan for Madeleine

    Two 12-cavity spherical shell pans published in metric at 26.5 by 18.5 by 2.2 cm, which converts to 10.43 by 7.28 by 0.87 inches, in thickened 0.8 mm carbon steel stated non-Teflon and free of PTFE and PFOA, with a strengthened edge against warping, at 1.45 pounds.

    • ZEENEEK
    • 26.5 x 18.5 x 2.2 cm
    • 1.45 lb

Side by side

Blank means the maker does not publish it.
ModelBrandSize (capacity)WeightBest for
Waylenbo Madeleine- Pan 2 Pack Waylenbo one size 0.74 lb Best for a dishwasher and a stated 0.8 mm gauge
2 Pack Non-Stick Madeleine Pan CHENZORVAX 2pcs 1.49 lb Best for fill lines inside each cavity
Shinsin Nonstick Madeleine Pans Shinsin Standard Size 2.03 lb Best for a strip that fits a narrow shelf
Chicago Metallic Professional 12-Cup Non-Stick Madel... Chicago Metallic 15.75-Inch-by-7.75-Inch not published Best for a single pan rather than a pair
Mold Cake Pan for Madeleine ZEENEEK 26.5 x 18.5 x 2.2 cm 1.45 lb Best for a metric size that converts cleanly

Each pick in detail

What the listing says for it, and against it.
1 Best for a dishwasher and a stated 0.8 mm gauge

Waylenbo Madeleine- Pan 2 Pack

Two 12-cavity carbon steel pans, each stated at 13.8 by 10.4 by 1 inch with a full cavity size of 2.5 inches, in what the maker calls thickened 0.8 mm carbon steel with a strengthened edge against warping, stated dishwasher safe, publishing 0.74 pounds for the pair.

  • For it
  • Publishes a pan size and a cavity size: 13.8 by 10.4 by 1 inch and 2.5 inches
  • States a steel thickness, 0.8 mm, which three listings here do not
  • Dishwasher safe, stated plainly and without a caveat
  • Its published fields and its own sentence agree exactly
  • Against it
  • 0.74 pounds for two carbon steel pans, against 1.49 on an identical footprint
  • States a 2.5 inch cavity where a rival with the same pan size states 2.6
  • Publishes no coating chemistry, where three listings name PFOA or PTFE
2 Best for fill lines inside each cavity

2 Pack Non-Stick Madeleine Pan

Two 12-cavity pans stated at 13.8 by 10.4 inches with 2.6 inch cavities, and the only listing here with clear measurement markers inside each cavity for portioning, on thick-gauge carbon steel with reinforced edges, PFOA and PTFE free, stated dishwasher safe, publishing 1.49 pounds.

  • For it
  • Measurement markers inside each cavity, published by nothing else here
  • States both figures: 13.8 by 10.4 inches and 2.6 inch cavities
  • PFOA and PTFE free, and stated dishwasher safe
  • Tells the buyer to measure the oven before purchase
  • Against it
  • States thick-gauge carbon steel without publishing a thickness
  • Publishes no pan height, so a stack of two cannot be worked out
  • Its 1.49 pounds is twice the figure a rival gives for the same footprint
3 Best for a strip that fits a narrow shelf

Shinsin Nonstick Madeleine Pans

Two pans in the long narrow shape rather than the rectangle, stated at 15 and two thirds by 7 by two thirds inches with wells of 3 by 2 inches, on a carbon steel core with a food grade coating, and hand wash only in warm soapy water with thorough drying before storage, at 2.03 pounds.

  • For it
  • A narrow strip shape, which suits a shelf a wide pan will not fit
  • Publishes a well size, 3 by 2 inches, as well as a pan size
  • The clearest care instruction here: warm soapy water and dry thoroughly
  • States high resistance to warping and bending
  • Against it
  • Hand wash only, where three listings here allow a dishwasher
  • Its package fields of 5 by 9.5 by 1 inches cannot hold the pan it states
  • 2.03 pounds, the heaviest of the four published weights

Who should skip this: Skip this if you want to put it straight in the dishwasher: the listing says hand wash only.

4 Best for a single pan rather than a pair

Chicago Metallic Professional 12-Cup Non-Stick Madel...

One 12-cup pan rather than two, stated at 15.75 inches by 7.75, which the maker describes across three separate bullets as heavy-weight aluminized steel, as silicone based with a non-stick coating, and as crafted from durable carbon steel. Dishwasher safe, with hand washing recommended.

  • For it
  • One pan rather than two, so half the shelf space of the pairs
  • Publishes a clear footprint: 15.75 inches by 7.75
  • Dishwasher safe, with hand washing recommended to extend life
  • States heavy-weight steel for heat conduction and even baking
  • Against it
  • Names three different materials across three bullets
  • Publishes no weight at all
  • Its dimension fields read 7.8 by 0.5 by 0.5, two of which are placeholders
5 Best for a metric size that converts cleanly

Mold Cake Pan for Madeleine

Two 12-cavity spherical shell pans published in metric at 26.5 by 18.5 by 2.2 cm, which converts to 10.43 by 7.28 by 0.87 inches, in thickened 0.8 mm carbon steel stated non-Teflon and free of PTFE and PFOA, with a strengthened edge against warping, at 1.45 pounds.

  • For it
  • Publishes its size in metric and it converts cleanly to inches
  • States 0.8 mm carbon steel and a strengthened edge against warping
  • Non-Teflon, and free of PTFE and PFOA, both stated
  • Two pans at 1.45 pounds, so 24 madeleines in one batch
  • Against it
  • Publishes no cavity size at all
  • States it cleans easier without naming a method
  • Its package fields carry two figures that match the metric size in inches

Our verdict

Waylenbo and CHENZORVAX both publish 13.8 by 10.4 inches for a two-pack of 12-cavity carbon steel pans, and their weights disagree: 0.74 pounds against 1.49. Shinsin publishes a strip at 15 and two thirds by 7 inches. Chicago Metallic publishes 15.75 by 7.75 for a single pan and names three different metals for it. ZEENEEK publishes 26.5 by 18.5 by 2.2 cm for two pans.

“Four of these five put two pans in the cabinet.”

Lush Editorial Team

What separates these five

Four two-packs, one single Three listings pair 12-cavity pans and a fourth pairs a narrow strip. Only Chicago Metallic sells one pan, which is half the shelf space.
Two pan shapes A 13.8 by 10.4 inch rectangle on three listings against a strip near 15.75 by 7.75 on two. The same twelve cavities, arranged two ways.
One footprint, two weights Waylenbo publishes 0.74 pounds and CHENZORVAX 1.49 for pairs of pans both stated at 13.8 by 10.4 inches. LORGVEXN also publishes 1.49.
Two publish a steel thickness Waylenbo and ZEENEEK both state thickened 0.8 mm carbon steel with a strengthened edge. The other three say thick, heavy-duty or heavy-weight.
One publishes fill lines CHENZORVAX states clear measurement markers inside each cavity for accurate portioning, which is the only internal marking published in this pool.

How we chose

Priorities, not a computed score. The inputs are published specifications, so we rank by what matters most and say how much.

  1. 30% How many pans arriveA two-pack is two pans of shelf space, and four of these five are two-packs. Waylenbo, CHENZORVAX and ZEENEEK each pair 12-cavity shell pans, and Shinsin pairs the narrow strip shape. Chicago Metallic is the only single pan here, which halves what the cabinet has to take and also halves the batch: twelve madeleines instead of twenty-four.
  2. 25% What one pan is stated to measureThe pool splits into two shapes. Waylenbo states 13.8 by 10.4 by 1 inch and CHENZORVAX 13.8 by 10.4, which are broad rectangles. Shinsin states 15 and two thirds by 7 by two thirds inches and Chicago Metallic 15.75 by 7.75, which are long strips. ZEENEEK publishes 26.5 by 18.5 by 2.2 cm, the smallest footprint of the five.
  3. 20% Whether the cavity size is publishedThree of the five give one and two of those three disagree about apparently the same pan. Waylenbo states a full cavity size of 2.5 inches and CHENZORVAX 2.6 inch cavities, both on pans stated at 13.8 by 10.4 inches. Shinsin states a well of 3 by 2 inches on its strip. ZEENEEK and Chicago Metallic publish no cavity figure at all.
  4. 15% Whether the steel has a thicknessWaylenbo and ZEENEEK both state thickened 0.8 mm carbon steel with a strengthened edge to avoid warping, in nearly identical wording. CHENZORVAX states thick-gauge carbon steel with reinforced edges and no figure. Shinsin states a superior carbon steel core, and Chicago Metallic heavy-weight aluminized steel, again without a number.
  5. 10% What happens after bakingWaylenbo and CHENZORVAX both state dishwasher safe outright, CHENZORVAX adding that the coating withstands repeated washing without flaking. Chicago Metallic states dishwasher safe and then recommends hand washing to extend life. Shinsin states hand wash only, with warm soapy water, thorough drying and no aerosol sprays. ZEENEEK states only that it cleans easier.

How the Five Compare on the Numbers

Seven live pages on this pool already rank by cavity count, coating, footprint, weight, temperature and cleaning. What none of them says is that most of these purchases are two pans rather than one, so the figure a cabinet actually needs is the pan size multiplied by the pack. Four of these five are two-packs and only one is a single pan.

The pans also come in two shapes. Waylenbo and CHENZORVAX both state 13.8 by 10.4 inches, a broad rectangle. Shinsin states 15 and two thirds by 7 by two thirds inches and Chicago Metallic 15.75 by 7.75, which are long strips. ZEENEEK publishes 26.5 by 18.5 by 2.2 cm, which is the smallest footprint here.

Specification Waylenbo CHENZORVAX Shinsin Chicago Metallic ZEENEEK
Pans per purchase Two Two Two One Two
Pan size stated, in 13.8 x 10.4 x 1 13.8 x 10.4 15 and two thirds x 7 x two thirds 15.75 x 7.75 10.43 x 7.28 x 0.87, as 26.5 x 18.5 x 2.2 cm
Cavity size stated, in 2.5 full size 2.6 a well of 3 x 2 not published not published
Cavities per pan Twelve Twelve Twelve Twelve Twelve
Steel thickness stated 0.8 mm thick-gauge, no figure a core, no figure heavy-weight, no figure 0.8 mm
Metal named heavy duty carbon steel heavy-duty carbon steel core carbon steel core aluminized steel, and carbon steel carbon steel
Fill lines inside cavities not published measurement markers, stated not published not published not published
Coating chemistry stated non-stick, chemistry not named PFOA and PTFE free food grade coating non-stick, silicone based non-Teflon, PTFE and PFOA free
Cleaning stated dishwasher safe dishwasher safe hand wash only, dry before storing dishwasher safe, hand wash advised cleans easier, no method
Warping claim a strengthened edge reinforced edges high resistance to warping not published a strengthened edge
Published weight, lb 0.74 1.49 2.03 not published 1.45
Published dimension fields, in 13.8 x 10.4 x 1 10.43 x 13.78 x 0.98 package 5 x 9.5 x 1 7.8 x 0.5 x 0.5 package 7.28 x 0.87 x 0.98

What the table cannot tell you is what a pair of these measures stacked. Not one listing publishes a stacked height, and only two publish a pan height at all, so a buyer with a 2 inch gap between shelves cannot check whether two pans will slide in. On a product sold in pairs, that is the figure the whole category omits.

Two Pans, One Shelf

One Footprint and Two Weights

Waylenbo and CHENZORVAX describe what looks like the same object. Both are two-packs of 12-cavity nonstick carbon steel shell pans, both state 13.8 by 10.4 inches, both claim reinforced or strengthened edges against warping, and both state dishwasher safety. Waylenbo publishes 0.74 pounds for the purchase and CHENZORVAX publishes 1.49.

A third listing in this pool, LORGVEXN, publishes the same 13.8 by 10.4 inch figure and the same 1.49 pounds, which puts Waylenbo alone. Either Waylenbo’s figure is one pan rather than two, or one of the three is wrong. Nothing on any of the three listings resolves it, so no comparison on this page is made by weight.

Two Pans Shaped Like a Strip

The other shape in this pool is long and narrow, and it fits a different shelf entirely. Shinsin states dimensions of 15 and two thirds by 7 by two thirds inches with a well of 3 by 2 inches, in a two-pack. Chicago Metallic states 15.75 inches by 7.75 for a single pan and puts that figure in its own title.

Twelve cavities laid out in a strip need more length and much less depth than twelve laid out in a rectangle, which is the practical difference between these two groups. A shelf 8 inches deep will take either strip and will not take a 10.4 inch rectangle, and neither group publishes anything about how two of them sit together.

Cavity Sizes and Gauges

Two and a Half Inches, or 2.6

Three of the five publish a cavity figure and the two that share a pan size do not share a cavity size. Waylenbo states that the full size of each cavity is 2.5 inches. CHENZORVAX states 2.6 inch cavities, and adds the instruction that matters more than either figure: measure your oven before purchase.

Shinsin publishes a well of 3 by 2 inches, which is a different way of describing the same shell: a length and a width rather than a single dimension. ZEENEEK and Chicago Metallic publish no cavity size at all, which on a pan whose entire purpose is a specific shell shape is the most useful figure to omit.

Two Listings Publish a Steel Thickness

Waylenbo and ZEENEEK both state thickened 0.8 mm carbon steel to accelerate even heat, with a strengthened edge for convenient use and to avoid warping, in wording so close that they read as the same factory. It is the only numeric material figure in this group and it lets those two be compared with each other directly.

The other three claim thickness without measuring it. CHENZORVAX states thick-gauge carbon steel with reinforced edges ensuring structural rigidity. Shinsin states a superior carbon steel core with high resistance to warping and bending. Chicago Metallic states heavy-weight aluminized steel for superior heat conduction. Three adjectives and no millimeters.

Where the Fields and the Words Part Company

A Package That Cannot Hold Its Pan

Shinsin states a pan of 15 and two thirds inches in length and publishes package fields of 5 by 9.5 by 1 inches. A 9.5 inch box does not contain a pan over fifteen inches long, so the package triple does not describe this purchase and this page uses the maker’s own dimensions instead.

Chicago Metallic has the same problem in a different form. Its title and its own text both give 15.75 inches by 7.75, and its published dimension fields read 7.8 by 0.5 by 0.5 inches, with two figures at 0.5 that are plainly placeholders. The 7.8 matches the stated 7.75 closely enough to be real; the rest is not a measurement.

One Listing That Names Three Metals

Chicago Metallic describes the same pan three ways across three consecutive bullets: made from heavy-weight aluminized steel for superior heat conduction and even baking; silicone based with a non-stick coating; and crafted from durable carbon steel for superior heat conduction. Those are not obviously the same sentence twice.

Two of them can be reconciled, since aluminized steel is carbon steel with an aluminum layer on it, and the silicone reference belongs to the coating rather than the body. The listing never says so, and it is the only one in this group that leaves a buyer to work out what the pan is made of from three competing claims.

Which One Fits Your Kitchen

You want a figure for the steel. Waylenbo publishes two 12-cavity pans at 13.8 by 10.4 by 1 inch with 2.5 inch cavities, in thickened 0.8 mm carbon steel with a strengthened edge, dishwasher safe, at 0.74 pounds for the pair.

You want every madeleine the same size. CHENZORVAX publishes two pans at 13.8 by 10.4 inches with 2.6 inch cavities and clear measurement markers inside each one, PFOA and PTFE free, dishwasher safe, at 1.49 pounds.

Your shelf is shallow. Shinsin publishes two pans in the strip shape at 15 and two thirds by 7 by two thirds inches with 3 by 2 inch wells, hand wash only in warm soapy water and dried before storage, at 2.03 pounds.

You only want one pan. Chicago Metallic publishes a single 12-cup pan at 15.75 inches by 7.75, dishwasher safe with hand washing recommended. It publishes no weight and names three different metals across its bullets.

You want the smallest pair. ZEENEEK publishes two 12-cavity pans at 26.5 by 18.5 by 2.2 cm, in thickened 0.8 mm carbon steel, non-Teflon and free of PTFE and PFOA, at 1.45 pounds. It publishes no cavity size and no cleaning method.

What We Could Not Verify

These are the figures the five listings do not publish, or publish twice in ways that disagree, and nothing above has been supplied in their place.

  • No listing publishes the height of two pans stacked, on a category sold in pairs.
  • Waylenbo and CHENZORVAX publish the same pan size and weights that differ by half.
  • Waylenbo states a 2.5 inch cavity and CHENZORVAX 2.6 on the same stated pan size.
  • Shinsin’s package fields of 5 by 9.5 by 1 inches cannot hold the pan it states.
  • Chicago Metallic publishes no weight, and two of its three field figures are 0.5.
  • Three of the five claim a thick or heavy steel without publishing a thickness.

Frequently asked questions

How much cabinet space does a madeleine pan need?+

Twice as much as most buyers expect, because four of these five are two-packs. Waylenbo states 13.8 by 10.4 by 1 inch per pan, CHENZORVAX 13.8 by 10.4, ZEENEEK 26.5 by 18.5 by 2.2 cm and Shinsin 15 and two thirds by 7 by two thirds inches. Only Chicago Metallic sells a single pan, at a stated 15.75 inches by 7.75.

Why do two listings with the same pan size publish different weights?+

There is no explanation on either listing. Waylenbo publishes 0.74 pounds and CHENZORVAX 1.49 pounds, both for two 12-cavity carbon steel pans stated at 13.8 by 10.4 inches, and a third listing in this pool, LORGVEXN, also publishes 1.49 for the same footprint. Either one figure is per pan rather than per pair, or one is simply wrong.

Which shape fits a narrow shelf?+

The strip. Shinsin states 15 and two thirds by 7 by two thirds inches and Chicago Metallic 15.75 by 7.75, both long and narrow with twelve cups in a line or two. The rectangles are broader: Waylenbo and CHENZORVAX both state 13.8 by 10.4 inches. A shelf 8 inches deep takes the strips and refuses the rectangles.

Does anyone publish how thick the steel is?+

Two of the five. Waylenbo and ZEENEEK both state thickened 0.8 mm carbon steel to accelerate even heat, with a strengthened edge to avoid warping, in almost the same words. CHENZORVAX says thick-gauge, Shinsin says a superior carbon steel core, and Chicago Metallic says heavy-weight aluminized steel. Three claims about thickness with no thickness attached.

Which of these can go in the dishwasher?+

Three say yes and one says no. Waylenbo states dishwasher safe in its material bullet. CHENZORVAX states dishwasher safe and adds that the non-stick surface withstands repeated washing and high-heat cycles without flaking or fading. Chicago Metallic states dishwasher safe but recommends hand washing to extend life. Shinsin states hand wash only, and ZEENEEK names no method.

Why does one listing name three different metals?+

Chicago Metallic's five bullets describe the same pan as heavy-weight aluminized steel for superior heat conduction, as silicone based with a non-stick coating, and as crafted from durable carbon steel. Aluminized steel is carbon steel with an aluminum coating, so two of those can be reconciled, and the silicone reference belongs to the coating rather than the body. The listing never resolves it.

Specifications come from the manufacturers' own published listings. Lush Food & Drink may earn a commission if you buy through a link on this page, at no extra cost to you. How we research.