How the Five Compare on the Numbers
A scale that is hard to move is a scale that lives on the counter, and these five publish weights that differ by a factor of more than forty. BOMATA publishes 0.22 pounds and BakFee 0.49. Salter publishes 1.15 and Ooni 1.76. The Edlund foodservice scale publishes 10 pounds, which the fact sheet flags against a pool median of 0.4.
The published sizes split the same way. BakFee publishes an 8 by 5.5 by 0.6 inch profile and calls it slim. BOMATA publishes 7.3 by 9.8 by 1.5 inches with a 7.2 by 7.2 inch platform. The Edlund publishes a 12.25 by 12.5 inch platform and an indicator that mounts to a table or a wall, which is a fitted appliance rather than a tool you put away.
What the table cannot tell you is how any of them sits in a hand. No listing in thirty-three publishes a grip, a recess, a carry handle or a thickness at the edge, so the only proxy for liftability is the published weight and the footprint it is spread over.
Ten Pounds, or a Quarter of One
The Two You Pick Up Without Thinking
BOMATA publishes 0.22 pounds, the lightest published figure of these five, on a scale measuring 7.3 by 9.8 by 1.5 inches with a 7.2 by 7.2 inch stainless platform. That is a large weighing surface on a body that weighs less than a can of beans, which is the combination that lets a scale live in a drawer and come out only when dough is being made.
BakFee publishes 0.49 pounds and an 8 by 5.5 by 0.6 inch profile it calls slim, which is the lowest published profile of these five. It is the only pick that publishes non-slip feet and states what they are for, keeping the scale steady and protecting the counter. A light scale that slides is worse than a heavy one that does not.
The One That Is Not Going Anywhere
The Edlund EPZ-20 publishes 10 pounds and the fact sheet flags the figure against a pool median of 0.4 pounds. In this case the flag is worth reading rather than obeying: a stainless NSF platform scale of 12.25 by 12.5 inches taking six AA cells is a commercial fitting, and ten pounds is a credible weight for one. We have not built any comparison on it.
What makes it the outlier is not the weight but the mounting. Its indicator is published as wall or table mounted, so the display is fixed somewhere and the platform stays under it. It publishes a 20 pound capacity and no readability at all, which is the opposite trade to every other pick here and the reason it is on this page.
What the Fields Say and What the Makers Say
One Object Filed Twice, Correctly
Ooni is the only listing in this pool whose two size statements agree. Its dimension fields read 7.09 by 12.2 by 1.18 inches and its size field reads 31 by 18 by 3 cm, and those are the same object in two unit systems. Ooni publishes 1.76 pounds for it, along with dual brushed steel platforms and a dual LCD that shows both readings at once.
That last feature is the reason the body is 12.2 inches long. Two platforms side by side need the width, and a scale of that length is a counter resident rather than a drawer one. Ooni also publishes a custom-fit measuring dish for yeast or herbs, which is the only container published with any scale here besides the BOMATA tray box.
Three Listings That Disagree With Themselves
The Edlund publishes three different sets of numbers. Its title says 12.25 inches long by 12.5 wide by 12.25 high, its dimension fields say 16 by 20 by 6 inches, and its own platform figure is 12.25 by 12.5 inches. Two of those three cannot both describe the same scale, and nothing in the listing says which is the appliance and which is the carton.
BakFee publishes a bullet reading 8 by 5.5 by 0.6 inches and a size field reading 5.6 by 8.7 by 0.65 inches, which are close enough to be the same scale and far enough apart to be two different measurements of it. Salter publishes fields of 0.76 by 2.64 by 3.38 inches, which is smaller than the bowl it expects you to put on top.
Reading It, Powering It, Keeping It Still
Where the Display Sits
Salter publishes the most specific display claim of these five and it is about geometry rather than brightness: the large backlit display is shown clearly without being covered by your mixing bowl. On a scale with a 2.64 inch published field that is a real design decision, and it is the only listing here that names the bowl as the thing blocking the screen.
The others describe angle instead. BOMATA publishes a full viewing angle LCD it says reads clearly from all angles, BakFee a backlit display readable from any angle, and Ooni a dual LCD showing both platform measurements at the same time. The Edlund publishes an indicator rather than a display, mounted to a table or a wall away from the platform.
Power, and What Arrives in the Box
BOMATA publishes the fullest power statement here: USB-C charging for a built-in lithium cell, plus the option of two external AAA cells, with a note that the AAA cells must come out before charging. It also publishes a 100 g calibration weight in the purchase, which is the only way any of these five lets you check whether the reading is still true.
At the other end the Edlund requires six AA cells and states they are not included, so a scale published at 10 pounds arrives unable to switch on. Ooni publishes batteries included without naming the type. Salter and BakFee publish nothing about power at all, and BakFee instead publishes five auto-off settings from 0 to 30 minutes.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
You want a light body and a large weighing pan. BOMATA publishes 0.22 lb, a 7.2 by 7.2 inch stainless platform, 0.1 g readability, a 5 kg range, USB-C or AAA power and a 100 g calibration weight in the purchase.
You want it flat and hard to shift. BakFee publishes an 8 by 5.5 by 0.6 inch body at 0.49 lb, non-slip feet stated to protect the counter, 33 lb capacity at 1 g, six units and five auto-off settings from 0 to 30 minutes.
You weigh into a bowl that covers the screen. Salter publishes 0.5 g increments and a large backlit display stated to stay visible with a mixing bowl on the platform, at 1.15 lb, with add and weigh for several ingredients in one bowl.
You weigh two things at once. Ooni publishes two brushed steel platforms and a dual LCD showing both readings, at 7.09 by 12.2 by 1.18 inches and 1.76 lb, with a tenth of a gram readability and a measuring dish included.
You want a fixed station rather than a tool. The Edlund EPZ-20 publishes a 12.25 by 12.5 inch stainless platform, a 20 lb capacity, NSF certification and an indicator that mounts to a table or a wall, and takes six AA cells that are not included.
What We Could Not Verify
Every figure above is a manufacturer’s own published number or sentence, taken from the listing itself. These are the things we went looking for across all thirty-three listings on this fact sheet and could not find in any of them.
- A grip, a recess or a carry handle on any of the thirty-three listings.
- Which of the three Edlund figure sets is the scale and which is the carton.
- An overall size from Salter, whose fields are smaller than a mixing bowl.
- A readability figure from the Edlund EPZ-20, which publishes only a 20 lb capacity.
- A capacity from Salter or Ooni, both of which publish a readability instead.
- Which cells Ooni includes, on the only pick here that says batteries are supplied.