Lush Food & Drink

Buying Guide ·Baking

Best Sourdough Starter Jars for a Kitchen Drawer

The deciding specification is the published height, because a drawer closes on whatever stands highest inside it, and half of this pool publishes no usable height at all.

By the Lush Editorial Team·Researched & Compared

  • Researched & ComparedSpecs pulled from the manufacturer listing
  • Like-for-LikeSame measures across every model
  • No Paid PlacementsNobody pays to appear here

I compared the height field against the height each maker writes into its own bullets, counted what else ships in the box and has to share the space, and set aside every listing whose figures describe a carton, using only the manufacturers' published text.

Our shortlist

Five products, one set of published numbers.
  1. Brod & Taylor Small Sourdough Starter Jar (12oz) Les...
    Best for a shallow drawer and a small culture

    Brod & Taylor Small Sourdough Starter Jar (12oz) Les...

    A 12 oz borosilicate jar with a loose plastic lid and a black silicone ring for marking the rise, published at 3.6 by 3.6 by 4.6 inches in the fields while its own bullet says three inches wide and 3.6 inches tall, at 0.39 lb, rated for up to 100 g of fully risen starter.

    • Brod & Taylor
    • 12 Ounce
    • 0.39 lb
  2. Brod & Taylor Sourdough Starter Jar (32oz) 100% Dish...
    Best for one jar that covers a week of loaves

    Brod & Taylor Sourdough Starter Jar (32oz) 100% Dish...

    A 32 oz jar with straight vertical sides, a four inch opening, a loose plastic lid and a black silicone level marker, published at 4.0 by 4.0 by 5.5 inches in the fields while the maker itemizes a four by five inch jar in the box, at 0.7 lb, rated for up to 300 g of active starter.

    • Brod & Taylor
    • 32 Ounce
    • 0.7 lb
  3. Howasai Sourdough Starter Jar 50oz
    Best for a big culture with covers for both stages

    Howasai Sourdough Starter Jar 50oz

    A 50 oz borosilicate jar with a five inch wide mouth, straight sides and a non-slip silicone base, published at 5.0 by 5.0 by 5.9 inches and 1.46 lb, arriving with a bamboo lid for storage, two breathable cotton covers for fermentation and an adjustable feeding band.

    • Howasai
    • 50 Oz
    • 1.46 lb
  4. KNEADACE Pro Sourdough Bread Starter Kit - 34 oz Lar...
    Best for a baker who wants the whole routine boxed

    KNEADACE Pro Sourdough Bread Starter Kit - 34 oz Lar...

    A 34 oz jar with a funnel-shaped opening, volume, net weight and feed line marks, and a day-marked elastic band, published at 4.13 by 4.13 by 6.7 inches and 1.98 lb, shipping with a thermometer, a cloth cover, a silicone cover that doubles as a non-slip base and a spatula.

    • KNEADACE
    • 1 Pack
    • 1.98 lb
  5. Weck Tulip Jars 1 Liter - Large Sour Dough Starter J...
    Best for a baker who cans with the same jar

    Weck Tulip Jars 1 Liter - Large Sour Dough Starter J...

    A one liter tulip jar in thick glass with a glass lid, rubber gaskets and stainless steel clips, stated for dishwasher and microwave, published at 4.5 by 4.5 by 7.0 inches and 1.0 lb, with a title that describes two jars and no dimension anywhere in its bullets.

    • WECK
    • Glass Lids
    • 1 lb

Side by side

Blank means the maker does not publish it.
ModelBrandSize (capacity)WeightBest for
Brod & Taylor Small Sourdough Starter Jar (12oz) Les... Brod & Taylor 12 Ounce 0.39 lb Best for a shallow drawer and a small culture
Brod & Taylor Sourdough Starter Jar (32oz) 100% Dish... Brod & Taylor 32 Ounce 0.7 lb Best for one jar that covers a week of loaves
Howasai Sourdough Starter Jar 50oz Howasai 50 Oz 1.46 lb Best for a big culture with covers for both stages
KNEADACE Pro Sourdough Bread Starter Kit - 34 oz Lar... KNEADACE 1 Pack 1.98 lb Best for a baker who wants the whole routine boxed
Weck Tulip Jars 1 Liter - Large Sour Dough Starter J... WECK Glass Lids 1 lb Best for a baker who cans with the same jar

Each pick in detail

What the listing says for it, and against it.
1 Best for a shallow drawer and a small culture

Brod & Taylor Small Sourdough Starter Jar (12oz) Les...

A 12 oz borosilicate jar with a loose plastic lid and a black silicone ring for marking the rise, published at 3.6 by 3.6 by 4.6 inches in the fields while its own bullet says three inches wide and 3.6 inches tall, at 0.39 lb, rated for up to 100 g of fully risen starter.

  • For it
  • Publishes a height in its own words, 3.6 inches, as well as in the fields
  • At 0.39 lb it is the lightest of these five
  • Jar and plastic lid are both stated dishwasher safe
  • States what it is rated for, up to 100 g of fully risen starter
  • Against it
  • Its own bullet and its data field disagree about height by a full inch
  • A 12 oz capacity is the smallest here, so a large culture is out
  • The maker's stated width of three inches does not match the 3.6 in the field either
2 Best for one jar that covers a week of loaves

Brod & Taylor Sourdough Starter Jar (32oz) 100% Dish...

A 32 oz jar with straight vertical sides, a four inch opening, a loose plastic lid and a black silicone level marker, published at 4.0 by 4.0 by 5.5 inches in the fields while the maker itemizes a four by five inch jar in the box, at 0.7 lb, rated for up to 300 g of active starter.

  • For it
  • Itemizes what is in the box, including a four by five inch glass jar
  • Straight vertical sides, which the listing says make the rise uniform
  • Jar and lid both stated 100 percent dishwasher safe
  • Rated for up to 300 g of fully active starter without overflow
  • Against it
  • The field height of 5.5 inches is half an inch over the maker's own figure
  • The loose-fitting lid rests rather than seals, so a drawer opened hard can shift it
  • No internal depth published, so reach to the curved bottom is unstated
3 Best for a big culture with covers for both stages

Howasai Sourdough Starter Jar 50oz

A 50 oz borosilicate jar with a five inch wide mouth, straight sides and a non-slip silicone base, published at 5.0 by 5.0 by 5.9 inches and 1.46 lb, arriving with a bamboo lid for storage, two breathable cotton covers for fermentation and an adjustable feeding band.

  • For it
  • States a five inch wide mouth, the only opening figure published on this page
  • Ships covers for both stages: two cotton for fermentation, bamboo for storage
  • A non-slip silicone base is included rather than sold on
  • 50 oz is the largest stated capacity among these five
  • Against it
  • Publishes no dimension in words, so the 5.9 inch field cannot be checked
  • Says nothing about a dishwasher for jar, lid or base
  • Four separate pieces beyond the jar all have to be stored somewhere
4 Best for a baker who wants the whole routine boxed

KNEADACE Pro Sourdough Bread Starter Kit - 34 oz Lar...

A 34 oz jar with a funnel-shaped opening, volume, net weight and feed line marks, and a day-marked elastic band, published at 4.13 by 4.13 by 6.7 inches and 1.98 lb, shipping with a thermometer, a cloth cover, a silicone cover that doubles as a non-slip base and a spatula.

  • For it
  • Itemizes more separate pieces than any other listing on this page
  • Volume, net weight and feed line marks are all stated on the glass
  • An elastic band marked with days of the week records the last feed
  • A silicone cover doubles as a non-slip base, so one piece does two jobs
  • Against it
  • At 1.98 lb it is the heaviest of these five
  • Publishes no dimension in words, so the 6.7 inch field stands alone
  • Says nothing about a dishwasher for any part of the kit

Who should skip this: Skip this if weight matters: at 1.98 lb it is the heaviest of the five published weights.

5 Best for a baker who cans with the same jar

Weck Tulip Jars 1 Liter - Large Sour Dough Starter J...

A one liter tulip jar in thick glass with a glass lid, rubber gaskets and stainless steel clips, stated for dishwasher and microwave, published at 4.5 by 4.5 by 7.0 inches and 1.0 lb, with a title that describes two jars and no dimension anywhere in its bullets.

  • For it
  • Stated safe for both dishwasher and microwave, which no other pick claims
  • Glass lid with rubber gaskets and stainless steel clips rather than plastic
  • Thick glass, and the listing offers the jar for canning as well as starter
  • At 1.0 lb it is lighter than both the Howasai and the KNEADACE jars
  • Against it
  • Publishes no dimension in any bullet, and no capacity outside the title
  • The title describes two jars while the fields describe a single shape
  • Clips and gaskets stand proud of the rim, which adds to what a drawer closes on

Our verdict

Published heights run 4.6 to 7.0 inches across these five. The 12 oz Brod & Taylor is lowest on both readings, 4.6 inches in its field and 3.6 inches in its own bullet, at 0.39 lb. Its 32 oz sibling reads 5.5 and 5 inches. Howasai reads 5.9, KNEADACE 6.7 and the WECK tulip 7.0, and none of those three publishes a height in words to check against.

“Two makers here publish a smaller jar than their own data.”

Lush Editorial Team

What separates these five

Two heights, one jar Brod & Taylor publishes 4.6 inches in the field for its 12 oz jar and 3.6 inches in its own bullet. Its 32 oz listing reads 5.5 in the field and five inches in words.
The published ladder Field heights run 4.6, 5.5, 5.9, 6.7 and 7.0 inches across these five, which is the only figure available for three of them.
Only two jars publish words Howasai, KNEADACE and WECK write no dimension into any bullet. Howasai gets closest with a five inch wide mouth, which measures an opening rather than a jar.
The kit shares the drawer KNEADACE itemizes a thermometer, a cloth cover, a silicone cover and base and a spatula. Howasai itemizes two cotton covers, a bamboo lid, a band and a base.
Seven listings measure a box Seven of the sixteen listings on this sheet had their dimensions set aside because the title or size field describes a two pack rather than a jar.

How we chose

Priorities, not a computed score. The inputs are published specifications, so we rank by what matters most and say how much.

  1. 40% The published heightA drawer closes on whatever stands highest, so height is the figure that decides the page. The five picks read 4.6, 5.5, 5.9, 6.7 and 7.0 inches in their data fields, which is the only height available for three of them and the larger of two readings for the other two.
  2. 25% Whether the maker publishes that height in wordsA field figure with nothing to check it against is a single unverified number. Only Brod & Taylor writes dimensions into a bullet, and it does so on both of its listings. Where the two disagree, this page quotes the sentence and prints the field beside it rather than choosing silently.
  3. 15% What else ships and has to be storedThe jar is not the only thing going in the drawer. KNEADACE names five extra pieces, Howasai names four, and the two Brod & Taylor listings name one or two. A kit that arrives complete is a benefit on the counter and a problem in a shallow space.
  4. 10% The closure standing on the rimA loose plastic lid adds least above the glass and needs no hand room to open. A bamboo lid is similar. Glass with rubber gaskets and steel clips adds hardware, and a silicone cover that doubles as a base adds a piece that is sometimes under the jar instead.
  5. 10% The stated capacity and what it is rated forHeight only matters against what the jar is for. Brod & Taylor is the only maker here that publishes a starter weight, up to 100 g on the 12 oz jar and up to 300 g on the 32 oz. The other three publish a fluid capacity and stop there.

How the Five Compare on the Numbers

A drawer closes on whatever stands highest inside it, so this page ranks by published height. The structured fields give a clean ladder across these five: 4.6 inches for the 12 oz Brod & Taylor, 5.5 for its 32 oz sibling, 5.9 for Howasai, 6.7 for KNEADACE and 7.0 for the WECK tulip. Two of the five also publish a height in words, and neither agrees with its field.

The gap is not small. Brod & Taylor’s own bullet for the 12 oz jar reads three inches wide and 3.6 inches tall, a full inch under the 4.6 in its field. Its 32 oz listing says the box holds a four by five inch glass jar, half an inch under the 5.5 recorded for it. The other three publish no height in words anywhere.

Specification Brod & Taylor 12 oz Brod & Taylor 32 oz Howasai KNEADACE WECK Tulip
Capacity stated 12 oz 32 oz 50 oz 34 oz 1 liter
Height in the structured field 4.6 in 5.5 in 5.9 in 6.7 in 7.0 in
Height in the maker’s own words 3.6 in 5 in not published not published not published
Width in the structured field 3.6 in 4.0 in 5.0 in 4.13 in 4.5 in
Width in the maker’s own words 3 in 4 in 5 in at the mouth not published not published
Published weight 0.39 lb 0.7 lb 1.46 lb 1.98 lb 1.0 lb
Lid stated Loose plastic Loose plastic Bamboo Silicone cover Glass with gaskets and clips
Starter weight the jar is rated for Up to 100 g Up to 300 g not published not published not published
Other pieces in the listing Silicone height ring Plastic lid, silicone level marker Two cotton covers, feeding band, silicone base Thermometer, cloth cover, silicone cover and base, spatula Glass lid, rubber gaskets, steel clips
Jars the listing describes One One One One Two
Dishwasher stated Jar and lid Jar and lid not published not published Stated, and microwave too

What the table cannot tell you is which of the two heights a drawer will actually meet. No listing here says whether its field figure includes the lid, whether it was taken with clips fastened, or whether it describes the jar or the carton it shipped in. It also says nothing about depth front to back beyond the round footprint, and nothing at all about how a jar behaves lying down.

The Height in the Fields Is Not the Height the Maker Gives

One Maker Publishes a Smaller Jar Than Its Own Data

Brod & Taylor is the only maker in this pool that writes dimensions into a bullet, and it does it twice. The 12 oz listing ends a bullet with three inches wide and 3.6 inches tall. The 32 oz listing itemizes what is in the box and calls the glass a four by five inch jar. Both figures sit under the height recorded in the structured fields for the same product.

House rule on this page is to take the maker’s sentence and say so, which is what the table does. The likely explanation is the lid: both jars ship a loose-fitting plastic lid that sits on the rim rather than screwing down, and a measured overall figure would include it. That is a guess, though, and neither listing confirms it, so both readings are printed rather than one.

Three Jars Publish No Height in Words at All

Howasai, KNEADACE and WECK give no dimension in any bullet. Howasai comes closest with a five inch wide mouth, which is an opening rather than a jar. KNEADACE describes a funnel-shaped opening and never measures it. WECK spends five bullets on canning, gifting and glass thickness without a single figure, and its own title is the only place a capacity appears.

For a drawer that leaves the field figure as the only number available, and it is the number most likely to include a lid. KNEADACE at 6.7 inches and WECK at 7.0 inches are the two that will decide the question for most drawers, and both are exactly the listings with nothing in words to check the field against.

The Lid and the Kit Decide What the Drawer Closes On

Two Loose Lids, One Bamboo, One Glass With Clips

Both Brod & Taylor jars use a loose-fitting plastic lid, which the listings say prevents pressure building up during active fermentation. A lid that rests rather than seals is the friendliest kind in a drawer, because nothing has to be unscrewed in a tight space, but it is also the kind that lifts if the drawer is opened hard.

The other three are different objects on top. Howasai ships a bamboo lid for storage and two breathable cotton covers for active fermentation. KNEADACE ships a silicone cover that doubles as a non-slip base. WECK uses a glass lid with rubber gaskets and little stainless steel clips, which is the only closure here that adds hardware standing proud of the rim.

What Else Has to Go in the Drawer

A starter jar rarely travels alone, and these listings differ sharply on how much else arrives. KNEADACE itemizes the most: volume, net weight and feed line marks, a thermometer, a cloth cover, a silicone cover that doubles as a base, and a spatula. Howasai itemizes two cotton covers, a bamboo lid, a feeding band and a silicone base.

The two Brod & Taylor jars are the leanest. The 32 oz box holds the glass jar, a plastic lid and a black silicone level marker, and the 12 oz listing names a black silicone ring for marking the current height. If the drawer has to swallow the whole kit rather than just the jar, the published height of the jar stops being the figure that matters.

Half This Pool Publishes No Height You Can Use

Seven Listings Measure a Carton Rather Than a Jar

Of the sixteen listings on this fact sheet, seven had their dimension fields set aside because the title or the size field says two jars, two packs or a gallon pair. Farielyn-X, LLeekk, ComSaf, Ritayedet, Freshmage, Adodeen and a second WECK listing all fall out that way, which is why a page about fitting a jar in a drawer has six candidates rather than sixteen.

The tulip jars picked here are a borderline case worth naming. That title also says two jars with glass lids, and the fields still read 4.5 by 4.5 by 7.0 inches, which is the shape of one tall tulip jar rather than a box holding two. The figure is used on that reading, and a buyer who needs it exact should treat it as unconfirmed.

What a Wooden Spurtle Is Doing in a Jar Pool

Two listings on this sheet are not jars at all. ZLYBox sells a pair of wooden spurtles for reaching the bottom of a jar, and its height field came through at four hundredths of an inch, which is a placeholder rather than a measurement. Superbaking and Friheten are baking kits built around a nine inch banneton basket, and their fields describe the basket.

Ritayedet is the third to set aside. Its listing is a two pack of one gallon cookie jars offered for sourdough, and the weight field reads 9.57 lb against a median near 1.46 for this pool. That figure may well be honest for two gallon jars, but it cannot be set beside a single jar without misleading, so it stays out.

Which One Fits Your Kitchen

The baker with a shallow cutlery drawer. The 12 oz Brod & Taylor publishes the lowest pair of figures here, 4.6 inches in the field and 3.6 inches in its own bullet, at 0.39 lb. It holds up to 100 g of risen starter, which is a small culture by design.

The baker who wants one jar for weekly loaves. The 32 oz Brod & Taylor is rated for up to 300 g of active starter, publishes 5.5 inches in its field and 5 inches in words, and is the only other pick that states a dishwasher for both jar and lid.

The baker feeding a large culture. Howasai states 50 oz and a five inch mouth, at 5.9 inches in the field and 1.46 lb. The bamboo lid and two cotton covers mean more pieces to store, but the mouth is the widest opening any listing here puts a figure on.

The baker who wants the whole routine in one box. KNEADACE itemizes a thermometer, a cloth cover, a silicone cover and base, a spatula and a day-marked band, at 1.98 lb and 6.7 inches. It is the heaviest of these five and needs a deep drawer.

The baker who also cans. The WECK tulip is glass throughout with rubber gaskets and steel clips, stated for dishwasher and microwave, at 7.0 inches and 1.0 lb. Its title describes two jars with glass lids, so plan drawer space for both.

What We Could Not Verify

Every figure above is from the makers’ own published data, and on the question this page asks that data runs out quickly.

  • No listing says whether its published height includes the lid, which is the difference between the two heights on two of these picks.
  • Howasai, KNEADACE and WECK publish no dimension in words, so there is nothing to check their fields against.
  • No listing publishes an internal depth, so how far a spatula has to reach is unstated.
  • Only the two Brod & Taylor listings state how much starter the jar is rated for, in grams.
  • The WECK title describes two jars while its fields describe one shape, and the listing never resolves which the figures belong to.
  • No listing states whether the glass is safe to store on its side, which is what a shallow drawer would require.

Frequently asked questions

Which of these fits the shallowest drawer?+

The 12 oz Brod & Taylor, on both of its published readings. Its data field says 4.6 inches and its own bullet says 3.6 inches tall by three inches wide. Even the larger figure is almost an inch under the next pick, the 32 oz jar from the same maker at 5.5 inches. It is also the lightest here at 0.39 lb, and it is rated for up to 100 g of risen starter.

Why do two picks have two different heights?+

Because the structured data fields and the maker's own sentences disagree. Brod & Taylor writes three inches wide and 3.6 inches tall into the 12 oz listing, against a 4.6 inch field, and itemizes a four by five inch jar in the 32 oz box against a 5.5 inch field. This page quotes the sentence and prints the field beside it, because neither listing explains the gap.

Is the lid included in the published height?+

No listing says. That is the most likely explanation for both gaps, because the two Brod & Taylor jars ship a loose-fitting plastic lid that rests on the rim, and an overall measurement would include it while a bullet describing the glass would not. It is an inference, not a published fact, so the page prints both figures rather than picking one.

Which jar brings the most pieces to store?+

KNEADACE. Its listing itemizes a thermometer, a cloth cover, a silicone cover that doubles as a non-slip base and a spatula, on top of a jar with volume, net weight and feed line marks and a day-marked elastic band. Howasai is next with two cotton covers, a bamboo lid, a feeding band and a silicone base. The 12 oz Brod & Taylor names one extra piece, a silicone ring.

Why are only six jars in the running from a pool of sixteen?+

Because seven listings publish dimensions that describe the box rather than the jar, and those figures were set aside: Farielyn-X, LLeekk, ComSaf, Ritayedet, Freshmage, Adodeen and a second WECK listing. Two more are not jars at all, a pair of wooden spurtles and a baking kit built around a nine inch banneton basket. That leaves six listings with a usable height and five on this page.

Can I store a starter jar on its side to save height?+

Nothing in these listings says so, and two of them argue against it by design. Both Brod & Taylor jars use a loose-fitting lid that prevents pressure building up, which means it is not sealed, and the Howasai listing pairs a bamboo storage lid with breathable cotton covers for active fermentation. A jar that breathes is a jar that can leak, so the answer here is unpublished rather than yes.

Specifications come from the manufacturers' own published listings. Lush Food & Drink may earn a commission if you buy through a link on this page, at no extra cost to you. How we research.