A cloche lives in a cabinet between bakes, and it is the one piece of bakeware people leave on the floor of the oven because getting it out again is a chore. So the figure that decides this page is published weight, and the range here is extreme: from 1.0 pounds to 17.2 pounds for objects that do the same job.
Three of the five state a weight in their own words as well as in the fields, which is unusual. Three of the five state a maximum temperature and two do not. Two state that no preheating is required, which changes the routine completely, and only one states a warranty, at ten years.
| Specification |
Brod and Taylor |
LemonRoad |
HAWOK Cast Iron |
Emile Henry |
Bulka |
| Size stated in a bullet |
12.5 by 8 by 5.5 inches |
13 inches by 5.5 inches |
Diameter 11.8 inches, total height 7.48 inches |
13.2 by 11.2 by 7 inches |
not published |
| Published dimension fields |
12.5 by 5.5 by 5.5 inches |
13.39 by 13.39 by 6.69 inches |
12 by 14.8 by 7.7 inches |
5.2 by 4.41 by 2.76 inches, not credible |
11.3 by 11.3 by 5.2 inches |
| Published weight |
1.0 pounds |
1.93 pounds |
17.2 pounds |
6.5 pounds |
8.5 pounds |
| Weight in the maker’s own words |
1 lb |
Under 2 pounds |
not published |
not published |
8.5 lbs |
| Stated material |
Food safe aluminum |
Anodized aluminum |
Enameled cast iron |
Ceramic, made in France |
Nitrided carbon steel with an aluminum core |
| Stated maximum temperature |
550 F |
550 F |
not published |
270 C |
not published |
| Preheating stated |
Not required |
Not required, saving 30 to 45 minutes |
not published |
not published |
About 15 minutes, stated |
| Seasoning stated |
not published |
not published |
Enamel inside and out |
not published |
Nothing to season, chip or flake |
| Loaf shape it is built for |
Batard |
Round |
Round, on a ridged shallow base |
Round, from 3 cups of flour |
A wider chamber for room to rise |
| Stated cleaning |
A quick wipe |
A quick wipe |
Effortless, ultra smooth enamel |
Dishwasher safe |
Hand wash and dry |
| What comes with it |
Doubles as a bread cover |
Doubles as a bread dome |
A dome lid with a stainless knob and a base |
A recipe and instruction booklet |
A silicone coated sling |
| Stated warranty |
not published |
not published |
not published |
Ten years |
not published |
The table cannot tell you which of these gives a better crust, because that is a baking result and nothing here was baked in. It cannot give a maximum temperature for the cast iron or the carbon steel pick, which is the omission that matters least in practice and most on paper. And it cannot give an internal volume for four of the five.
Weight Is the Cabinet Problem
One pound against seventeen
Brod and Taylor publishes 1.0 pounds and states 1 lb in its own bullet. HAWOK publishes 17.2 pounds for its enameled cast iron bread oven, the heaviest of the five. Those two are answering the same question about steam and crust, and they ask entirely different things of the cupboard you keep them in and the wrist that lifts them.
In between, LemonRoad publishes 1.93 pounds, Emile Henry 6.5 pounds and Bulka 8.5 pounds. Bulka states the figure twice, in the fields and as 8.5 lbs in a bullet. For a cabinet with a shelf above waist height, the difference between two pounds and seventeen is the difference between reaching and lifting.
What the makers say about each other
Unusually, three of these listings make the comparison themselves. Brod and Taylor states its shell weighs just 1 lb, unlike your typical 15 lb Dutch oven, and that cast iron pots need scrubbing and reseasoning. LemonRoad states that at under 2 pounds its dome is 85 percent lighter than cast iron and can be lifted with one hand even when hot.
Bulka states that at just 8.5 lbs its carbon steel pot is far easier to lift than a typical 15 to 20 lb cast iron pot with no loss of performance. All three are selling against the same object, and the 17.2 pound HAWOK on this page is heavier than the figure any of them cites as the thing to avoid.
Footprint, Height and Loaf Shape
Round domes and batard shells
Brod and Taylor states its shell is for a batard, and states 12.5 by 8 by 5.5 inches, which is a long low shape rather than a circle. Its own bullet notes you can use two side by side in a wide oven. That is the only pick here shaped for an oval loaf rather than a boule.
LemonRoad, HAWOK and Emile Henry are all round. LemonRoad publishes a 13.39 inch diameter and states 13 inches by 5.5 inches. HAWOK states a diameter of 11.8 inches, or 30 cm. Emile Henry states 13.2 by 11.2 by 7 inches and, more usefully than anyone, that it is sized for a round loaf made with 3 cups of flour.
Heights that have to clear a shelf
Height is the second cabinet figure. HAWOK states a total height of 7.48 inches, or 19 cm, and Emile Henry states 7 inches. Brod and Taylor publishes 5.5 inches and LemonRoad publishes 6.69 inches, both of which are domes rather than pots and so store flatter.
Bulka publishes 5.2 inches of height for an 11.3 inch pot, the lowest credible height figure of the five, and states a wider chamber than a classic Dutch oven so the dough has room to rise sideways rather than upwards. On a shelf that is what actually matters, since a shallow wide pot fits under a fixed shelf that a tall one does not.
Figures That Do Not Add Up
One cloche’s fields are half its size
Emile Henry publishes dimension fields of 5.2 by 4.41 by 2.76 inches. Its own size field and a bullet both state 13.2 by 11.2 by 7 inches. The published fields are less than half the stated figures in every axis, so they cannot describe the cloche, and this page uses the maker’s sentence throughout.
The other picks have smaller versions of the same problem. Brod and Taylor states 12.5 by 8 by 5.5 inches and publishes fields of 12.5 by 5.5 by 5.5, so its 8 inch figure exists only in the sentence. LemonRoad states 13 inches by 5.5 inches and publishes fields of 13.39 by 13.39 by 6.69. HAWOK states 11.8 inches across and publishes 12 by 14.8 by 7.7.
Dome plus base does not equal total
HAWOK publishes its parts separately and the parts do not sum. Its bullet gives a dome lid height of 3.8 inches, or 9.7 cm, a base depth of 1.6 inches, or 4.1 cm, and a total height of 7.48 inches, or 19 cm. Three point eight plus one point six does not reach seven point four eight.
Bulka is the opposite case: it publishes 11.3 by 11.3 by 5.2 inches in its fields and states nothing about its outer size in words, so there is nothing to check the fields against. The other four all publish both a sentence and a set of fields, and in all four the two do not match. The sentence is the figure this page quotes.
Which One Fits Your Kitchen
A cabinet you reach into. Brod and Taylor publishes 1.0 pounds, the lightest of the five, states 12.5 by 8 by 5.5 inches for a batard, needs no preheating, withstands 550 F and cleans with a quick wipe. It also doubles as a bread cover.
A round loaf and no preheating. LemonRoad publishes 1.93 pounds and a 13.39 inch diameter in anodized aluminum, states 550 F, and states that skipping the preheat saves 30 to 45 minutes. It doubles as a bread dome on the counter.
Traditional cast iron, shallow base. HAWOK states a diameter of 11.8 inches with a dome of 3.8 inches over a base 1.6 inches deep, in enameled cast iron with a stainless knob. It publishes 17.2 pounds, the heaviest of the five.
Ceramic with a stated loaf size. Emile Henry states 13.2 by 11.2 by 7 inches, a maximum of 270 C, dishwasher safe cleaning, a ten year warranty and that it is sized for a round loaf made with 3 cups of flour. It publishes 6.5 pounds.
No seasoning, nothing to flake. Bulka publishes 11.3 by 11.3 by 5.2 inches and 8.5 pounds, states nitrided carbon steel hardened through rather than coated, an aluminum core for faster heating, and includes a silicone coated sling.
What We Could Not Verify
These are the figures a baking cabinet would want, and that these listings do not give.
- A maximum temperature for the HAWOK cast iron and the Bulka carbon steel picks.
- An internal volume for four of the five, published only as a 6 Qt figure by LemonRoad.
- Whether the HAWOK, LemonRoad or Bulka picks may go in a dishwasher.
- Any outer size stated in words for the Bulka pot, which publishes fields only.
- The dough weight or flour quantity each is sized for, stated only by Emile Henry.
- Why the HAWOK dome height and base depth do not sum to its stated total height.